Morning Docket: 11.20.24 – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Mark
Wilson/Getty
Images)

*
With
the
Trump
sentencing
delayed,
prosecutors
are
gearing
up
for
the
inevitable
request
that
state
crimes
should
be
legal
if
the
convict
wins
a
national
election.
Alas,
this
precedent
will
arrive
too
late
for
Charles
Manson.
[

NY
Law
Journal
]

*
Weil
being
dealt
double
whammy
with
a
pair
of
practice
leaders
expected
to
depart.
[American
Lawyer
]

*
Matt
Gaetz
appointment
shines
new
light
on
warnings
from
the
Founders
[Daily
Report
]

*
New
record
for
the
youngest
person
to
pass
California
bar
exam,
topping
her
own
brother’s
previous
record.
[ABA
Journal
]

*
Employers
considering
reversing
raises
now
that
Trump
is
expected
to
nix
overtime
rules.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
Lawyer
in
Megan
Thee
Stallion
case
begs
judge
not
to
impose
sanctions
over
missed
in-person
court
date.
[Legal
Affairs
and
Trials
]

*
Penn
State’s
plan
to
merge
its
law
schools
receives
ABA
approval.
[Penn
Live
]

Mnangagwa appoints Lovemore Matuke as state security minister

HARARE

President
Emmerson
Mnangagwa
has
appointed
Zanu
PF
senator
Lovemore
Matuke
as
state
security
minister,
ending
nearly
three
years
of
waiting
to
fill
up
the
position.

The
post
was
rendered
vacant
following
his
surprise
sacking
of
top
ally
Owen
Muda
Ncube
in
January
2022
while
serving
his
first
term
as
president.

Now
Minister
of
State
for
Midlands
Provincial
Affairs,
Ncube
was
sacked
over
what
was
described
as
“conduct
inappropriate
for
a
minister
of
government.”

Since
his
dismissal,
Mnangagwa
has
kept
the
dreaded
spy
agency
directly
under
his
supervision.


Hatcliffe
MP
Agency
Gumbo
(CCC)
told
parliament
this
week
that
by
keeping
the
position
vacant,
Mnangagwa
was
in
breach
of
section
225
of
the
Zimbabwe
constitution
which
placed
an
obligation
on
him
as
president
to
appoint
a
minister
in
charge
of
the
country’s
intelligence
service.

Gumbo
said
it
was
important
to
have
a
minister
in
charge
of
the
national
intelligence
services
so
that
questions
on
national
security
issues
could
be
directed
to
them.

“In
the
absence
of
a
minister
of
national
security
in
this
country,
there
are
serious
national
security
questions.
We
are
unable
to
interrogate
and
demand
answers
from
the
executive.
This
goes
to
the
heart
and
core
of
our
role
of
oversight,”
Gumbo
added.

As
if
to
respond
to
the
MP’s
concerns,
Mnangagwa
on
Tuesday
appointed
Matuke
to
the
position.

In
a
statement
on
Tuesday,
Chief
Secretary
to
the
President
and
Cabinet,
Martin
Rushwaya
said,
“In
terms
of
Section
104
Subsection
(1)
as
read
with
Section
225
of
the
Constitution,
His
Excellency,
the
President
Emmerson
Dambudzo
Mnangagwa
has
appointed
Honourable
Lovemore
Matuke,
Senator
as
the
Minister
of
State
for
National
Security
with
immediate
effect.”

Matuke
switches
from
his
role
as
Minister
of
State
for
Presidential
Affairs
in
the
Office
of
the
President
and
Cabinet
to
the
new
post.

Harare Mayor Pledges Orderly Enforcement Of Demolition Court Orders


20.11.2024


3:47

Harare
Mayor
Councillor
Jacob
Mafume
has
said
the
council
is
working
with
the
government
to
enforce
demolition
court
orders
in
an
orderly
manner,
to
protect
residents
who
may
have
fallen
victim
to
land
barons.


Jacob
Mafume

Last
week,
the
government
condemned
the
destruction
of
30
houses
in
Ridgeview,
Belvedere,
by
the
Harare
City
Council,
describing
the
action
as
inhumane.

In
an
interview
with NewsDay on
Monday,
Mafume
said
that
the
council
has
reported
land
barons
who
illegally
sold
land
to
residents
to
the
police
and
is
now
awaiting
their
arrest.
Said
Mafume:


We
are
working
with
government
on
the
court
orders.
Demolitions
should
be
done
in
an
orderly
manner
but
at
the
same
time
we
are
saying
people
should
be
compliant
with
the
country’s
laws.

We
have
people
who
have
built
houses
where
children
are
supposed
to
play.
If
we
create
a
city
like
that,
our
children
will
not
be
happy.

We
have
reported
the
land
barons
to
police
and
we
are
waiting
for
their
arrest.
Yes,
if
there
are
those
who
get
to
be
regularised,
they
should
be
cleared.

Reports
indicate
that
there
are
144
applicants
slated
for
regularisation
based
on
recent
council
resolutions.

One
notable
project,
Tafara
Pay
Schemes,
led
by
Everson
Luni,
has
adhered
to
council
by-laws
for
town
planning.

This
compliance
includes
the
payment
of
application
fees,
circulation
fees,
ZESA
charges,
surveying
fees,
and
costs
associated
with
the
Environmental
Management
Agency
and
sewerage
services.

Post
published
in:

Featured

BREAKING: Cravath Delights Associates With BOTH Year-End And Special Bonuses – Above the Law

It
was
just
over
a
week
ago
that

Milbank
got
the
associate
bonuses
rolling
,
now
Cravath
has
entered
the
chat.
For
all
the
initiative
Milbank
has
shown
on
the
associate
compensation
front

this
year
in
addition
to
being
the
first
to
announce
year-end
bonuses,
they
were
alone
in
Biglaw

handing
out
summer
special
bonuses


the
market
still
waits
to
see
what
Cravath
does
before
falling
in
line.
And
tonight
we
have
the
answer.

Cravath
has
revealed
the
following
bonus
scale

of
both
the
end-of-year
and
special
variety.
The
combination
of
those
two
bonuses
match
the
numbers
Milbank
gave
out.

Screenshot 2024-11-19 at 8.48.21 PM

The
bonuses
will
be
paid
in
the
New
York
and
D.C.
offices
on
December
13th;
London
associates
will
get
them
on
December
16th.
And,
as
noted
in
their
memo,
Cravath
bonuses
are
given
without
specific
billable
hours
requirements.
Nice.

Now
that
Cravath
hath
spoken,
we
can
expect
the
biggest
and
most
profitable
Biglaw
firms
to
follow
suit.

So
is
your
firm
matching
*both*
the
year-end
and
special
bonuses?
Let
Above
the
Law
know!
We
depend
on
your
tips
to
stay
on
top
of
important
bonus
updates,
so
when
your
firm
matches
(or
if
they
fail
to
do
so),
please
text
us
(646-820-8477)
or

email
us
 (subject
line:
“[Firm
Name]
Matches”).
Please
include
the
memo
if
available.
You
can
take
a
photo
of
the
memo
and
send
it
via
text
or
email
if
you
don’t
want
to
forward
the
original
PDF
or
Word
file.

And
if
you’d
like
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s
Bonus
Alerts
(which
is
the
alert
list
we
also
use
for
salary
announcements),
please
scroll
down
and
enter
your
email
address
in
the
box
below
this
post.
If
you
previously
signed
up
for
the
bonus
alerts,
you
don’t
need
to
do
anything.
You’ll
receive
an
email
notification
within
minutes
of
each
bonus
announcement
that
we
publish.
Thanks
for
all
of
your
help!

Read
the
full
memo
below.

Compensation
Memo
(1)




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].


Bonus Time

Enter
your
email
address
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s

Bonus
&
Salary
Increase
Alerts
.


Chasing History With Justice Thomas – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Win
McNamee/Getty
Images)


As
Clarence
Thomas
prepares
for
the
grand

unveiling
of
his
new
portrait
,
it’s
increasingly
likely
that
the
justice
hopes
to
clinch
the
title
as
America’s
longest
serving
Supreme
Court
justice.
That
record
is
currently
held
by
Justice
William
O.
Douglas.
Presently,
Thomas
is
the
10th
longest
serving
justice.
Thomas
won’t
reach
the
Douglas
milestone
until
roughly
mid-2028,
but
he
will
match
the
next
person
on
the
list
in
a
little
over
six
months.
Who
will
Thomas
overtake
next?


Hint:
When
it
came
time
to
portray
this
justice
on
film,
the
role
went
to
the
Supreme
Court
justice
who
inherited
this
man’s
seat
on
the
bench.



See the
answer
on
the
next
page.

With Latest Additions, Lex Machina’s Legal Analytics Now Cover Every Federal District Civil Case

The
litigation
analytics
company

Lex
Machina

has
completed
what
it
describes
as
a
milestone
expansion
of
its
data
set
of
court
documents,
adding
another
500,000
federal
district
court
cases
so
that
it
now
has
full
coverage
of
virtually
every
civil
case
filed
in
federal
district
courts
anywhere
in
the
United
States.

The
only
civil
cases
it
does
not
include
are
prisoner
petitions,
which
the
company
deemed
not
commercially
relevant
to
its
customer
base
of
law
firms
and
corporations.

Until
now,
Lex
Machina’s
analytics
have
been
focused
on
specific,
major
practice
areas
(currently
22
practice
areas),
and
in
its
collection
and
tagging
of
federal
cases,
it
prioritized
those
practice
areas.
But
with
this
latest
expansion,
it
has
added
the
remaining
15%
of
district
court
cases
that
did
not
fit
under
one
of
those
major
practice
areas.

“This
is
a
pretty
big
milestone
in
terms
of
our
overall
expansion
to
cover
all
civil
litigation
in
federal
district
court,”

Carla
Rydholm
,
general
manager
and
head
of
product
at
Lex
Machina,
told
me
during
a
briefing
this
week.
“Now
we
have
the
ability
to
provide
coverage
of
every
commercially
relevant
case.”


Before
this
update,
some
analytics
showed
a
grey
area
for
the
15%
of
cases
not
accounted
for.
Now,
the
analytics
give
a
full
picture.

While
analytics
by
practice
area
remain
the
primary
focus
of
the
platform,
it
now
allows
users
to
compare
analytics
across
all
federal
cases,
without
having
to
select
a
case
type,
and
then
drill
down
into
more
granular
data
based
on
courts,
judges,
counsel,
parties,
and
other
filters.

In
addition
to
tagging
cases
based
on
the
22
primary
practice
areas,
Lex
Machina
has
now
added
tagging
for
another
five
categories:
admiralty/maritime,
forfeiture/penalty,
FOIA,
immigration,
and
RICO.

Cases
that
do
not
fit
within
any
of
these
practice
areas
will
be
tagged
as
uncategorized,
but
users
will
be
able
to
view
the
federal
nature-of-suit
code
that
was
applied
to
the
original
filing.


Where
comparisons
previously
could
be
done
only
within
a
practice
area,
they
can
now
be
done
across
all
cases.

This
enhanced
data
set
is
also
available
through
the
litigation
analytics
feature
of
the
legal
research
platform
Lexis+.
Lex
Machina
is
owned
by
LexisNexis.

The
significance
of
this
is
that
users
will
get
a
truly
complete
picture
of
federal
court
analytics
that
encompass
not
just
the
85%
of
cases
previously
covered
but
100%
of
cases.
That
means
that
when
they
are
exploring
analytics
for
factors
such
as
outcomes,
damages,
or
remedies,
they
are
getting
the
comprehensive
view.

Key
to
Lex
Machina’s
analytics
is
how
the
company
processes
the
raw
case
data
after
collection

cleaning,
tagging,
coding
and
enhancing
the
data
so
that
it
can
be
analyzed
across
a
number
of
parameters.

It
allows
users
to
explore
analytics
based
on
entities

judges,
courts,
law
firms,
attorneys
and
parties

and
by
outcomes

case
resolutions,
timing,
damages,
findings,
remedies
and
motion
metrics.

Lex
Machina
evolved
out
of
a
research
project
launched
in
2006
at
Stanford
Law
School
to
collect
and
analyze
data
on
patent
cases.
Since
its

acquisition
by
LexisNexis
in
2015
,
it
has
steadily
added
more
practice
areas,
expanded
into
state
courts,

added
analytics
for
federal
courts
of
appeal
,
and

added
Litigation
Footprint

for
visualizing
litigation.

With
this
latest
traunch
of
cases,
Lex
Machina
can
now
provide
these
outcome-driven
analytics,
including
damages
and
case
resolutions,
for
over
3.7
million
federal
district
civil
cases,
based
on
data
from
17.5
million
documents.

Along
with
this
release,
Lex
Machina
has
updated
certain
tools
and
added new
capabilities
that
it
says
will
allow
for
more
depth,
detail,
and
nuance.
A
new
“Custom
Columns”
feature
streamlines
the
creation,
sharing,
and
export
of
customized
reports,
it
says,
while
a
new
“Findings
Search”
feature
allows
users
to
search
findings
within
a
specific
practice
area
for
findings
that
are
most
relevant
to
their
own
case
and
practice.

Donald Trump Adds To His Clown Show, Erm, That Is, Cabinet With Attorney/Reality TV Star – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Terry
Wyatt/Getty
Images)

I
am
an

avowed
fan

of
the
MTV/Bunim
Murray
reality
TV
universe.
The
Real
World
created
a
genre
out
of
whole
cloth,
and
Road
Rules
built
on
the
brand.
But
it’s
The
Challenge

currently
in
its
40th
season

that
cemented
its
place
in
the
zeitgeist
with
returning
“characters”
and
relationships
that
evolve
over
the
course
of
years.
And
that
formula
has
created
some
stars

some
have
taken
their
fame
to

other


reality

TV

franchises
,
some
have
charted
a

course
in
comedy
,
others
are

actor
s
in

film
and
TV
.
There
are

models
,

wrestlers
,
and

TV
hosts

in
The
Challenge
alumni
ranks.
But
if
you
thought
the
strangest
2024
development
for
a
Challenge
alum
was

Theo
Von
playing
presidential
kingmaker
,
I
have
some
bad
news
for
you.

Last
night,
Donald
Trump

selected
his
pick

for
Transportation
Secretary.
And,
as
you
probably
guessed
from
the
intro,
he
tapped
a
former
MTV
star.


Sean
Duffy

first
came
into
the
public
eye
during
the
sixth
season
of
The
Real
World,
the
Boston
edition.
He
was
a
competitive
lumberjack
who
clashed
with
some
of
his
more
liberal
roommates.
After
his
season
ended,
Duffy
went
on
to
compete
on
The
Challenge
where
he
met
his
future
wife,
star
of
the
San
Francisco
RW
season,
Rachael
Campos.
Duffy
and
Campos
went
on
to
have
nine
children
and
quickly
got
on
the
express
train
to
right-wing
stardom.
Campos
tried
her
hand
as
the
conservative
on
The
View
before
finding
a
home
on
Fox
News.
Duffy
got
that
law
degree
he’d
been
eyeing
(from
William
Mitchell
College
of
Law)
before
starting
his
career
as
a
prosecutor.
He
then
turned
to
politics
as
a
member
of
the
House
of
Representatives,
representing
Wisconsin’s
7th
Congressional
District.
He
left
that
role
to
spend
time
with
his
family
after
learning
his
ninth
child
had
health
complications.
From
there,
Duffy
returned
to
TV
as
a
host
on
Fox
Business.
All
of
which
brings
us
to
last
night’s
announcement,
giving
Duffy
the
nod
as
the
head
of
Transportation.

Listen,
we
live
in
a
world
where
Matt
Gaetz

a
man


is
being
put
up
at
Attorney
General.

And
a
Fox
News
host
got

the
nod
as
Secretary
of
Defense
.
A

reality
TV
star
in
the
Cabinet
?
Seems
entirely
on
brand
for
Trump
2.0.




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].

DOJ Officials Lawyer Up Ahead Of Trump’s Possible ‘Revenge Prosecutions’ – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Brendan
McDermid-Pool/Getty
Images)



Ed.
note
:
Welcome
to
our
daily
feature,

Quote
of
the
Day
.


The
Justice
Department
is
Trump’s
white
whale,
and
like
Captain
Ahab,
Trump
is
determined
to
get
even.





Stephen
Gillers
,
an
ethics
professor
at
New
York
University
Law
School,
in
comments
given
to

NBC
News
,
on
President-elect
Donald
Trump’s
reported
plans
to
seek
revenge
against
those
who
may
have
scorned
him
within
the
Department
of
Justice.
“Trump
aims
to
neutralize
sources
of
power
that
may
impede
him,”
Gillers
said.
“That
includes
the
law
and
legal
institutions.
He
will
tolerate
no
interference
when
the
department’s
decisions
will
benefit
Trump
and
his
buddies
or
when
its
power
can
be
deployed
to
retaliate
against
his
enemies.”



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on

X/Twitter

and

Threads

or
connect
with
her
on

LinkedIn
.

Clarence Thomas Joining Upstanding, Heroic Folks Like Putin And Prince Andrew With New Portrait – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Drew
Angerer/Getty
Images)

Clarence
Thomas
will
become
the
longest
serving
justice
in
Supreme
Court
history
if
he
holds
out
until
mid-2028.
And
despite
the
fervent
wishes
of
conservatives
and

probably
especially

Thomas’s
likely
replacement
Judge
James
Ho,
the
Court’s
senior
justice
seems
likely
to
gun
for
the
record.

And
one
of
the
perks
enjoyed
by
folks
serving
long
tenures
in
important
jobs
is
a
fancy
oil
portrait.
So
it’s
no
surprise
that
Thomas
is

in
the
process
of
having
his
legacy
portrait
done
.
For
this
task,
he’s
chosen
Igor
V.
Babailov,
an
accomplished
portrait
artist
whose
past
subjects
include
Thomas’s
colleague

Samuel
Alito
,

Vladimir
Putin
,
and

Prince
Andrew
.

Honestly,
it’s
a
little
jolting
to
see
any
picture
of
Prince
Andrew
these
days
that

doesn’t
involve
Jeffrey
Epstein
.

For
the
highest
of
comedy,
check
out
the

George
W.
Bush
,
where
America’s
most
destructive
nepo
baby
is
posed
as
the
fifth
head
on
Mount
Rushmore,
juxtaposing
the
man
who
said
“you
can
fool
all
of
the
people
some
of
the
time…”
with
the
man
who
said,
“fool
me
once
shame
on
you,
fool
me

you
can’t
get fooled
again.”

It’s
not
like
Babailov
uniquely
seeks
out
cartoonish
villains
for
his
portfolio.
For
example,
his
Putin
portrait
was
commissioned
as
a
gift
from
the
Canadian
government.
But
still,
it’s
a
man
with
a
history
of
capturing
some
of
the
world’s
most
punchable
people
for
posterity.

While
we
wait
on
the
Thomas
portrait,
Babailov
offers
some
tantalizing
peeks
at
the
process,
including
some
revealing
detail
work
on
the
bookshelf
being
composed
as
a
backdrop.

Screenshot 2024-11-19 at 1.36.05 PM


From
the
Igor
V.
Babailov
website

Not
quite
sure
what
“The
Law”
is
or
why
it
would
be
neatly
held
in
one
relatively
thin
volume.
His
autobiography,

My
Grandfather’s
Son
,
and
his
hagiography, 

Created
Equal,

make
appearances.
The
latter
work
was
a
pillar
of
a
public
relations
blitz
from
conservatives
trying
to
recuperate
Thomas’s
reputation
and
gave
birth
to
a
documentary
film
of
the
same
name
funded
by
right-wing
activists.
Was
FedSoc
honcho
Leonard
Leo
at
the
center
of
raising
over
a
million
and
a
half
from
conservative
non-profits
for
this
effort?
Could
Harlan
Crow
have
been
involved?

You’d
better
believe
it!

The
Bible
shows
up,
presumably
the
Trump
version
that
includes
the
nation’s
founding
documents…
or
at
least
the
parts
that

the
conservative
legal
movement
care
about
.
And
finally,

Littlest
Suffering
Souls
,
a
book
whose
author,
Austin
Ruse,
president
of
the
Catholic
Family
&
Human
Rights
Institute,
once

wrote
,
“Women
should
not
be
able
to
vote
until
they
are
married.”

It’s
unclear
if
other
specific
titles
will
be
added
before
the
portrait’s
completion
or
if
the
rest
become
nondescript
“law-looking
books.”
Any
thoughts
on
what
the
artist
should
add?
The

Bluebook

perhaps?

Blackstone’s
Commentaries
?

Winds
of
Winter
?

We’ll
just
have
to
wait
and
see!




HeadshotJoe
Patrice
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
Feel
free
to email
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments.
Follow
him
on Twitter or

Bluesky

if
you’re
interested
in
law,
politics,
and
a
healthy
dose
of
college
sports
news.
Joe
also
serves
as
a

Managing
Director
at
RPN
Executive
Search
.