As Zimbabwe’s doctors strike, pregnant women search for care – The Zimbabwean

New mother Vimbai Mhere gave birth to her daughter in a ‘back yard’ clinic run by midwife Esther Zinyoro [File: Chris Muronzi/Al Jazeera]

Harare, Zimbabwe – Thirty-three-year-old Vimbai Mhere sits on the cement floor of a modest, two-room apartment, sipping tea from a plastic cup and snacking on homemade cakes as she recovers from having just given birth to her fourth child.

“My prayer this morning in the bus was to find someone who could help me deliver my baby,” Mhere tells Al Jazeera.

Never had Mhere imagined she would be scrambling last minute for medical assistance. Early in her pregnancy, she registered to deliver her baby at her local state-funded clinic in Hopley, a poor, densely populated area on the periphery of Harare. But the health facility shut its doors to new patients before her due date.

Mhere’s story has become dangerously common in Zimbabwe, as state-run clinics and hospitals turn away patients or close down while junior doctors and nurses strike for better wages and conditions.

Caught in the crossfire of the standoff between healthcare workers and the government are people in desperate need of medical care, including expectant mothers.

Unable to accommodate her, Mhere’s local clinic referred her to another state-run facility in the Harare suburb of Utsanana.

“Last week, my sister-in-law who was also pregnant went to Utsanana to deliver and was sent away,” she said. “I knew I would not get help delivering my child there.”

Nor could Mhere afford a private hospital. So when her water broke, she and her husband boarded a bus bound for Harare Central Hospital, where she had delivered her other three children.

“Some people on the bus told us not to go to Harare hospital, saying there were no doctors or nurses,” she recalled. “Some said we should go to a home maternity in Mbare.”

By “home maternity”, they meant an unlicensed, informal, back yard facility.

As the pain of Mhere’s contractions intensified, the gravity of her predicament fully dawned on her. Her only option was to have her baby in a back yard clinic.

Worthless wages

Medical staff at Zimbabwe’s state-run facilities have seen their wages decimated by hyperinflation that has roiled the country’s economy this year.

Depleted state coffers have also left the government unable to purchase sufficient supplies for state medical facilities. Power shortages and rolling blackouts have only added to the myriad difficulties facing healthcare providers.

A junior doctor only earns about 400 Zimbabwean dollars ($20 at black market rates) as a basic salary and an “on-call allowance” of approximately 1,000 Zimbabwean dollars ($50) a month.

Practitioners want their salaries indexed against the United States dollar, to keep pace with inflation as the Zimbabwean dollar erodes in value against it.

After negotiations between the government and the union representing junior doctors failed in September, the union called a strike, which is still ongoing.

The doctors defend their labour action on the grounds that they have been incapacitated financially. But the government says the strike is illegal, and it has sacked more than 400 junior doctors and withdrawn salaries from others.

In late October, senior doctors who had assumed emergency-room duties downed stethoscopes around the country in solidarity with their junior colleagues.

With state hospitals and clinics in and around the capital Harare effectively closed for business, patients are now being forced to travel to Karanda Mission Hospital, some 200km (124 miles) north.

Karanda is a 150-bed hospital that was built in 1961 by the Evangelical Church of Zimbabwe. Still run by the church, it is now the last port of call for thousands of Zimbabweans who desperately need medical care.

In a bid to end the health crisis, Zimbabwean telecommunications billionaire Strive Masiyiwa offered to pay the salaries of the country’s 2,000 doctors for three months in the local currency if they resumed their duties. Senior doctors rejected the offer and called on their employer, the Zimbabwean government, to redress their grievances.

The dire state of the country’s healthcare system was captured in a report issued by United Nations independent human rights expert Hilal Elver after she visited the country in late November.

“I received disturbing information that public hospitals have been reaching out to humanitarian organisations after their own food stocks were exhausted and medical equipment no longer operational,” Elver wrote in her observations. “The hospital I visited was nearly empty, because of [the] doctors’ strike.”

Not spared

As was the case with other state medical facilities in Zimbabwe, the strikes did not spare Harare General Hospital.

Knowing this, Mhere – still in active labour – and her husband took the advice of their fellow passengers on the bus and headed to the neighbourhood of Mbare to hunt for a back yard maternity clinic.

“We had no choice,” said Mhere.

After a few enquiries, the couple landed on the doorstep of Esther Zinyoro, an elderly midwife and faith healer who delivered Mhere’s baby girl without complications.

“I praise God today I delivered without any problems,” says Mhere.

Zinyoro, who credits her work to the Holy Spirit, told Al Jazeera she has delivered babies for more than 200 women in her modest two-room apartment since she opened her doors to the public on November 11.

Unassuming and cheerful, wearing a white doek headcloth, the 70-year-old midwife said a request to assist two teenagers who were in labour at the understaffed local clinic in Mbare had convinced her to step into the breach left by striking medical workers.

“They were aged 16 and 17 respectively and were in labour and did not get the help they needed,” she said. “They just didn’t know how to handle the labour pain. There was no one to tell them what to do.”

Zinyoro arrived too late to help the young mothers. Bereft of proper medical attention, both of them lost their children. According to Zinyoro, one baby died because the teenaged mother “had not removed her underwear and the child was choked”.

“I was devastated and I wanted to help,” she said. “I retreated to the wilderness for three days and prayed to God on what to do.”

When she emerged, Zinyoro had made up her mind to open a clinic in her home, free of charge, for pregnant women who have no other viable option to deliver their babies.

On the day Al Jazeera visited, her back yard clinic was a hive of activity.

“I had seven women today,” Zinyoro said. “They all delivered their babies and there is only one woman (Mhere) left,” she says.

But patients cannot stay for long, says Zinyoro. Given how small her apartment is and the number of pregnant women who come to her in need, as soon as women deliver, they have to move on to create space for those in labour.

Zinyoro opened her doors thinking it would be temporary – a stopgap to help her fellow citizens weather the crisis. So when nurses from the local clinic told her to discontinue her work because they had reopened their doors, she started referring pregnant women to the government facility.

“I closed for two days but the women came back saying they were not being attended to at the clinic,” Zinyoro says.

Since then, the midwife has not turned anyone away.

From relative obscurity, her work has now won her national fame. The country’s first lady, Auxilia Mnangagwa, has visited Zinyoro’s apartment and donated food.

The midwife’s work has also won her the enduring gratitude of mothers like Mhere who had nowhere else to turn in their hour of need.

“I am grateful to gogo,” Mhere says, using the Shona word for granny. “I am not sure how and where I would have delivered my baby.”

Wife of Zimbabwe vice-president accused of trying to kill him – The Zimbabwean

Marry Chiwenga (R) with her husband, Constantino (C), in August 2018. Photograph: Wonder Mashura/AP

The wife of Zimbabwe’s vice-president, Constantino Chiwenga, has been accused of attempting to kill him by disconnecting his life support while he was undergoing treatment in hospital this year.

Marry Chiwenga, née Mubaiwa, was arrested at the weekend and appeared at Harare’s magistrates court on Monday where she was remanded in custody.

She is accused of illegally transferring almost US$1m (£740,000) overseas to purchase luxury cars and property, and faces additional charges of attempted murder.

Constantino Chiwenga, who played a leading role in ousting Robert Mugabe in a military takeover in 2017, has a serious disease of the oesophagus, which has made eating difficult and has required months of hospital treatment.

The 63-year-old former army chief is a controversial figure, blamed by many for recent waves of repression in the former British colony.

The court case and accusations will focus attention once more on Zimbabwe’s opaque political elite, which is frequently accused of graft and incompetent economic management, and on the significant wealth of some individuals.

Police documents allege that Merry Chiwenga travelled to South Africa with her seriously ill husband in June and attempted to prevent him from seeking medical attention until his security detail intervened.

In July she went to the private hospital in Pretoria where he was being treated and told staff to leave her alone with him before disconnecting vital equipment, police allege. When security personnel and medical staff intervened, she left the hospital, the documents claim.

The vice-president was later treated in China and has since returned to Zimbabwe. His wife has said she is innocent of any wrongdoing.

Local media reported that the marriage of the former beauty queen and the former head of the armed forces had collapsed.

Zimbabwe’s anti-corruption commission brought the fraud and money laundering charges against Merry Chiwenga. The commission has pursued a series of high-profile figures in the last year, jailing several of them.

Critics say the commission is highly politicised and its targets are all enemies of senior officials in the government of the president, Emmerson Mnangagwa.

Zimbabwe faces a profound economic crisis exacerbated by drought. Millions of people there are reliant on food aid. Many of the problems are a legacy of decades of mismanagement under Mugabe, who died in September.

The rising prices have reminded many of the economic collapse just over a decade ago, when hyperinflation emptied shelves of basic foodstuffs and led the country to abandon its currency.

The situation in rural areas is particularly bad, aid workers in Zimbabwe say, though there is growing evidence of widespread malnutrition in cities too.

Morning Docket: 12.18.19

* The Florida Bar is requiring a Florida attorney to take a professionalism workshop after he shooed a stowaway raccoon off of his boat in open waters. Bet the Florida Bar was moved by the heartbreaking pictures of the raccoon in the water. [Tampa Bay Times]

* Notorious RBG threw cold water on President Trump’s impeachment law knowledge yesterday after President Trump suggested that the impeachment process could be stopped by the Supreme Court. [USA Today]

* A California lawyer has been found guilty of running a scheme to secure foreign investment visas when legitimate investments were often not being made. [Mercury News]

* The Washington State Attorney General has sued the Trump Administration over ICE arrests made in state courthouses. [Seattle Times]

* Progressive groups are calling for Justice Brett Kavanaugh to recuse himself from a case involving the constitutionality of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. [CNBC]

* It looks like the CBD industry could be facing a flood of new lawsuits, and that’s not just people being paranoid. [Bloomberg Law]

* Lawyers for a stuntman who was killed on the set of The Walking Dead is asking for up to $100 Million in damages from AMC. [Yahoo Entertainment]


Jordan Rothman is a partner of The Rothman Law Firm, a full-service New York and New Jersey law firm. He is also the founder of Student Debt Diaries, a website discussing how he paid off his student loans. You can reach Jordan through email at jordan@rothmanlawyer.com.

Mary Chiwenga’s controversy – Winky D prophecy fulfilled? – The Zimbabwean

If you are die-hard music fan, then you probably know at least one singer whose words have turned out to be prophetic.

Mary Chiwenga: lover of hugs

Way back in the 1990s, even before the wool was peeled off our eyes, Thomas Mapfumo sang about “corruption in society” and “Jojo siyana nazvo” – a cautionary song to political activists. Decades later, Zanu PF has killed, tortured or disappeared its most vocal critics. Some have been abducted and fed on sewage water before being released.  Lovemore Majaivana’s songs were also ahead of their time. Leli lizwe kalila mali was years before Zimbabwe’s economic meltdown and decades before Mangudya’s bond notes. Even in Zhakata’s dance tunes were subtle messages which only make sense now. The Notorious BIG rapped about blowing up like the World Trade Centre, as early as 1994. The towers fell in 2001 – seven years after his song, Juicy.

Winky D – musician or prophet?

But can we talk about prophetic song lyrics without mentioning Winky D, Zimbabwe’s Messi of dancehall?

NdaiCruiser ndiine jagwa – ndobva ndaona mai mupfanha vakahagwa

The Second Lady, Marry Chiwenga, is in a spot of trouble with the law. She has appeared in court for fraud, apparently at the behest of Vice President General Chiwenga. Allegations of infidelity have been thrown about the independent press which is never short of spicy gossip. When VP Chiwenga appeared on television in November 2017, speaking of the “criminals surrounding President Mugabe,” did he mean his own wife? Who knows. What is clear is that Chiwenga versus Chiwenga certainly fits the lyrics to Winky D’s song Controversy.

NdaiCruiser ndiineArmy Puma. Ndobva ndaona mai mupfanha vakahagwa!

It is very hard to prove infidelity. You have to catch someone in flagrante delicto to prove they cheated. All we know is that the General’s wife loves to hug. A lot!

Hugs all around

My pen is capped

Jera

Most – but not all – South African companies are struggling in Zimbabwe

Post published in: Featured

Donald Trump Puts Normal Tweetstorm In Official Letter To Nancy Pelosi

(Photo by MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images)

President Donald Trump sent a letter to Speaker Nancy Pelosi, railing against his impending impeachment. Like, an actual letter, on White House stationary. Instead of his usual thing of saying batshit crazy things on Twitter, this time he scrawled the batshit on an official Presidential document.

I’m sorry, I know I’m desensitized to Trump’s mania, and I shouldn’t be, but I am fresh out of pearls to clutch. The President is a dangerous lunatic, his letter reads like the ravings a dangerous lunatic, and treating the letter like it’s “news” requires some suspension of disbelief about the dangerous lunatic running the country for the past three years that I can no longer muster.

At least this one was edited. The last time we saw Trump’s writing on the printed page, he was writing to Turkish President Recep Erdogan the way a third-grader writes to pen-pal they’re forced to have through school.

His letter to Pelosi was clearly principally written by an aide, you can tell because it’s written at maybe a fifth-grade level as opposed to third, and with just a few Trumpism interspersed throughout.

Like, you can tell the aide wrote the opening sentence:

I write to express my strongest and most powerful protest against the partisan impeachment crusade being pursued by the Democrats in the House of Representatives.

Trump lacks the vocabulary to write this sentence. Here, “strongest” and “most powerful” are used to modify “protest.” But Trump doesn’t use “protest” as noun, he only uses it as a verb. And he thinks “strong” and “powerful” are only available as adverbs. Also he thinks protest is something women do too much. So, in the original Trump, this sentence probably looked like “I object, strongly, and so, so powerfully, most powerfully really, about your partisan impeachment crusade.”

In the second paragraph, you can see precisely where Trump overruled his aides and put his own language in there. See if you can spot it (it’s not hard):

The Articles of Impeachment introduced by the House Judiciary Committee are not recognizable under any standard of Constitutional theory, interpretation, or jurisprudence. They include no crimes, no misdemeanors, and no offenses whatsoever. You have cheapened the importance of the very ugly word, impeachment!

Right? Referring to things by their correct proper nouns, like “Articles of Impeachment” and “House Judiciary Committee” are not things that Trump is capable of doing. And I bet all the money in my pocket that he does not know what “jurisprudence” means. But “You have cheapened the importance of the very ugly word, impeachment!” That’s straight Trump, right down to the exclamation point. “Very” is one of five or six modifiers he knows, and “ugly” is word that he uses almost exclusively when talking to or about a woman. Like a Pavlovian dog who drools even when there is no food presented, he thinks that “ugly” is the single worst thing you can say (outside of a locker room) about a woman, and so he throws that word in there regardless of the context when he thinks he’s speaking to one.

You can play this game throughout the whole document. It’s almost fun, like going to a masquerade ball and trying to guess who’s behind the masks. And in the same way that playing the guessing game at the masquerade ball distracts you from the fact that you’re at some detestable high society jaunt and really you and all your fellow guests should be eaten by a righteous proletariat, playing the game with Trump’s letter is a grand distraction from the fact that the President of the United States is engaging in outright lies, conspiracy theories, and setting the stage for his supporters to violently defend him if necessary.

But… I guess we have to talk about that part too:

By proceeding with your invalid impeachment, you are violating your oaths of office, you are breaking your allegiance to the Constitution, and you are declaring open war on American Democracy.

It’s actually Trump who wants his supporters to declare open war on American Democracy, should the Constitutional process of impeachment move forward. Not that most of his most violent supporters can be bothered to read something longer than 240 characters.

Even worse than offending the Founding Fathers, you are offending Americans of faith by continually saying pray for the President, when you know this statement is not true, unless it is meant in a negative sense. It is a terrible thing you are doing, but you will have to live with it, not I!

He wrote that last bit. It’s just like his Erdogan letter where he projected history looking at Erdogan “forever as the devil.”

You know that I had a totally innocent conversation with the President of Ukraine. I then had a second conversation that has been misquoted, mischaracterized, and fraudulently misrepresented. Fortunately, there was a transcript of the conversation taken, and you know from the transcript (which was immediately made available) that the paragraph in question was perfect. I said to President Zelensky: would like you to do us a favor, though, because our country has been through a lot and Ukraine knows a lot about it. I said do us a favor, not me, and our country, not a campaign.

If this were a comic book, and really no comic book universe would try to get away with the storylines in present-day America, you’d call this a “retcon.” Trump asked for a personal favor, for his campaign, in exchange for releasing funding and weapons, but that backstory doesn’t fit with where he wants to take the story next, so he’s just changing it. Lying about it. Pretending the old thing never happened the way everybody read it happening.

All these pull quotes are just from the first page of this lunacy. THERE ARE SIX OF THEM.

Impeachment vote is tomorrow. I need to check if I have enough popcorn in the house.

Letter from President Trump


Elie Mystal is the Executive Editor of Above the Law and a contributor at The Nation. He can be reached @ElieNYC on Twitter, or at elie@abovethelaw.com. He will resist.

George Conway Willing To Spend Big To Make Sure His Wife Loses Her Job

George T. Conway III

Every effort to probe the home life of Wachtell’s George Conway and his White House Propaganda Minister Kellyanne Conway has left us more confused than when we came in. Political disagreements around the house are one thing, but when one party spends the entire day lamenting that the other half is enabling a threat to the core constitutional rights, it’s hard to comprehend how this can be anything other than an elaborate performance art piece, one that ends with Andy Kaufman revealing he’s been practicing high-stakes litigation for decades.

But carry on with this odd couple we must, and the latest development is that George is putting his money where his Tweeting thumbs are. Joining with John McCain adviser Steve Schmidt, former Ohio Gov. John Kasich adviser John Weaver, former New Hampshire GOP chair Jennifer Horn, and veteran Republican operative Rick Wilson, Conway is setting up a Super PAC to convince Republicans in battleground states to ditch Trump in 2020. The group, called the Lincoln Project after the nominally Republican president who wanted to aggressively expand federal power over the states and use it to tear down Southern political institutions, represents a long-standing conservative effort to tie their iconography to ideals their movement unceremoniously abandoned at least 50 years ago. A recent poll of Republicans finding Trump a better president than Lincoln should make the organizers wonder if dialing up the Great Emancipator to court Republicans is any better an idea than taking in a show at Ford’s Theater.

The Super PAC will target both Trump and key Trump allies in the Senate, aiming for the disaffected Republican voters that they imagine exist out there. In their defense, the 2016 election swung on such a slim margin that it would only take a few like-minded Republicans to turn the tide in some battleground states. The problem is the entire population of Republicans who don’t like Trump live in this group or the New York Times Editorial page which doesn’t exactly help in Wisconsin. Still, the group is hopeful and claims to have $1 million in donations already lined up with more coming in. Conway had this to say about the mission of the group:

“If he’s not removed by the Senate, he needs to be removed at the ballot box,” he said of Trump. “The people in Congress who are enabling him, either actively or passively, they, too, are violating their oaths of office…. And they need to be removed, too.”

If you’re interested in contributing to the “Take My Wife (Out of the White House), Please! Fund” the organization isn’t really up and running yet, but keep your eyes out. They should have a website as soon as they settle on which stock image of a Lincoln bust they want to use as a logo.

Trump conservative critics launch PAC to fight reelection [AP]

Earlier: Hey Look! George Conway Has Some Thoughts On Trump This Morning!
I’m Starting To Think George Conway Might Not Like Donald Trump
George Conway Throws Shade All Over Kellyanne’s Puff Piece


HeadshotJoe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news. Joe also serves as a Managing Director at RPN Executive Search.

The Flattening Of Associate Salaries: Another Firm Matches New York Pay For Outside Market

Back in the day, New York associates made more money than associates around the country because they worked, on balance, more hours and the complexity of the work demanded top talent that firms were willing to pay a premium to secure. Now it seems like everyone’s paying the New York scale in a bid to break up the Big Apple’s monopoly on that key talent. It started with the 2016 nationwide salary bump and has since trickled into more and more smaller markets ever since. Alston & Bird raised salaries in Charlotte last week, and now Lowenstein has bumped salaries to New York levels for its Northern New Jersey associates starting in the new year.

While there are definitely some markets that have absolutely no business matching the New York scale — you all know which markets you are — Lowenstein’s Roseland, New Jersey office fits the mold of a salary bump that makes a lot of sense. It competes in the same geographic market with New York firms and the cost of living is comparable. A firm hoping to bring high-quality legal service to that office has to be prepared to pony up because otherwise the candidates they’re eyeing will just find themselves a New York firm.

But don’t hold your breath for a boom in New Jersey salaries. Lowenstein isn’t just a national firm that happens to have a New Jersey office. With its home office is almost as big as the New York team and supporting a bustling Life Sciences practice in a hotbed of pharmaceutical and other medical tech headquarters, the New Jersey office is every bit a contributor to the firm’s bottom line as the New York or Palo Alto offices and it needs the talent to get that work done.

That’s not something the bulk of New Jersey regional firms can boast and they’re just not going to be able to match what the folks at Lowenstein can do for its associates. So when other Jersey attorneys reach the bottom of their W2s, these words billow up inside them as prayer, as regret, as praise, “Lowenstein, Lowenstein.”[1]

Earlier: Forget Bonuses, These Associates Just Got RAISES!


[1] Did you think I could successfully wedge a Prince of Tides joke into an article about raises? Me neither.

HeadshotJoe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news. Joe also serves as a Managing Director at RPN Executive Search.