Lockdown amid Covid surge has no support for people – The Zimbabwean

Containers and other goods are sold beneath a coronavirus disease (COVID-19) awareness billboard at a marketplace in Harare, Zimbabwe, 26 November 2020. REUTERS/Philimon Bulawayo

A rise in coronavirus cases in Zimbabwe has prompted President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s government to put the nation on a 30 day strict lockdown.

The Southern African country, which had had relatively low coronavirus infection rates since March 2020 when the first death was recorded, saw a rise in cases in December following citizens returning home from neighbouring South Africa for the festive season.

Announcing the stiff lockdown measures in Harare last week, vice-president and health minister Constantino Chiwenga said the country had seen a “surge in COVID-19 cases during the festive season”, with cases almost doubling in the past two months.

Only essential services including hospitals, pharmacies and supermarkets are being allowed to operate, with only essential staff allowed to go to work.

Even though airports remain open, land borders have been closed except for returning residents and essential cargo, impacting cross-border traders.

As of the 6 January, there were more than 17,000 coronavirus cases in Zimbabwe, claiming the lives of more than 400 people, according to the health ministry.

Fears for vulnerable communities

With most of Zimbabwe’s population employed in the informal sector, there are fears there could be widespread hunger as the government did not announce any plans to support citizens who will not be able to work during the lockdown.

Many people are grappling with economic hardships that have been worsened by the global pandemic.

In Zimbabwe, the informal sector dominates with 2.2 million or 76% of the country’s economically active people, according to the Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency (Zimstat) in its 2019 Labour Force and Child Labour Survey.

Zimbabwe Chamber of Informal Economy Associations secretary general Wisborn Malaya tells The Africa Report that informal traders who were yet to recover from the 2020 lockdown have been hit hard again this year, with no bailout packages available from the cash-strapped government.

The country’s economic crisis predates the coronavirus outbreak.

“Measures which have been put [in place] do not at all give any reprieve to informal traders. The government should have cushioned the vulnerable,” says Malaya.

Economist Nigel Chanakira argues it is crucial to impose lockdown measures along with safety nets to protect poor communities.

“The poor need support and subsidies if we elect to have shutdowns,” he explains.

No bailout packages in sight

Information ministry permanent secretary Nick Mangwana tells The Africa Report that he was not aware of any plans to help Zimbabweans during lockdown.

“I am not aware of such plans. If we all comply and do our best, then there is unlikely to be an extension of the lockdown,” he said.

The lockdown is hurting the income of many families, whose earnings have already been eroded by hyperinflation.

As of November 2020, the food poverty line for one poor person was Z$3,279 ($36), according to Zimstat.

Where is the plan?

Zimbabwe Human Rights Association director Dzikamai Bere says that the government must put human rights at the centre in its lockdown measures.

“Zimbabwe’s lockdown is a lockdown without a plan. No budget was announced to fight the pandemic,” he explains. “They are not paying attention to the question of livelihoods. They close the economy for the poor without giving them an option for survival.”

In March 2020 when the government imposed a 21-day hard lockdown, which was later extended by two weeks, the government pledged to provide stimulus packages to vulnerable people. But many claim they did not receive the funds.

Hopes on early vaccines fading from view

While other African countries including Rwanda and South Africa have announced plans to roll out vaccines to their citizens in the first and second quarters of 2021, the Zimbabwean government is yet to make such an announcement.

Donors, instead, are taking a leading role. The United Kingdom embassy in Zimbabwe has pledged to vaccinate three million people drawn from low-income communities in the country.

The United Nations Children’s Fund in October 2020 announced it was stockpiling over half a billion syringes to support poor countries with COVID-19 vaccines when they become available.

The government is leaving this work to donors. The fact that there is no budget announcement for fighting COVID-19 is telling [us that] this is a nation outsourcing the health welfare of its citizens to donors,” says the Zimbabwe Human Rights Association’s Bere. “It is culpable negligence.”

No support

Fadzayi Mahere, spokesperson for the opposition MDC Alliance, says the latest rules do not deal with the complementary measures that are necessary to support communities during lockdown.

“If people must stay at home, they need support because they cannot fend for themselves,” she says. “Commanding the closure of the economy without the necessary supporting economic reliefs, medical and social measures is suicidal.”

Mahere says simply announcing lockdown rules to keep people at home without safety nets “is a command style rulership” that shows total disregard for people’s interests.

Zimbabwe set to establish virtual courts amid COVID-19 pandemic – The Zimbabwean

Chief Justice Luke Malaba said court sittings had been highly affected by lockdown measures instituted by the government since last year to curb the spread of the pandemic, government news agency New Ziana reported.

“Courts could not afford to lag behind in harnessing the potential of ICT in ensuring that access to justice is not disrupted,” he said while opening the 2021 legal year.

“To this end, plans to introduce virtual court sittings are at an advanced stage. The process involves presentation of submissions by litigants and parties to disputes without them being required to be physically present at court,” he said.

Malaba said the digitization of the courts and their processes had already been adopted in other jurisdictions in the region and beyond.

He said the JSC had entered into memoranda of understanding with cooperating partners to assist with the establishment of virtual courts throughout the country.

“One courtroom at Harare Magistrates’ Court has already been fitted with virtual court equipment which connects the court to Harare Remand Prison. A pilot run of the equipment was successfully done towards the end of 2020,” he said.

Malaba said the JSC had not been spared by the COVID-19 pandemic and currently there were 31 confirmed cases among members, with two in critical condition while one died on Jan. 5.

Post published in: Featured

Zimbabwe gold deliveries tumble nearly a third to 19 tonnes in 2020 – The Zimbabwean

A Zimbabwean miner works underground at Metallon Gold mine in Shamva, about 80 km (50 miles) north of the capital Hararre, file. REUTERS/Philimon Bulawayo/File Photo

FPR pays U.S. dollars in cash to small-scale gold miners, but a shortage of hard cash caused delays in payments most of last year. That forced many of the miners to sell their gold to illegal buyers, industry officials say.

Deliveries of gold, the top foreign currency earner, have been on the decline since reaching a record 33.2 tonnes 2018, mainly due to delays by FPR in paying miners.

The central bank last month announced plans to unbundle FPR into two separate companies and sell a majority stake in the new gold refinery business to miners, in a bid to boost output.

FPR data showed that total gold deliveries fell to 19.05 tonnes from 27.66 tonnes in 2019.

Small-scale producers sold only 9.35 tonnes last year compared with 17.48 tonnes in 2019.

The government says gold worth at least $1.2 billion is illegally exported from the country annually.

Last month, Zimbabwe banned the use of mercury in mining, which could further curtail output in the short term from the small-scale sector, which is the major user of the toxic metal when extracting gold.

Post published in: Business

Zimbabwe Food Security Monitoring Report: December 2020 – The Zimbabwean

The COVID-19 situation in Zimbabwe continues to deteriorate with the number of confirmed cumulative cases increasing by more than 70% from 10,129 cases including 277 deaths by the 1st of December 2020 to 17,804 including 431 deaths by the 7th of January 2021.

On the 6th of January, the government reintroduced a 30-day lockdown and restrictive measures at level 4, which has seen the closure of most formal and informal businesses which are not categorized as essential services.

During December, most parts of the southern region in the country experienced above-average rainfall, partially induced by tropical depression Chalane that passed through the southern part of Zimbabwe at the end of the month.

The macro economic environment continues to stabilize recording a decline in annual inflation for a fourth consecutive month.

The Hunger Map for Zimbabwe for the month of December 2020 showed an improvement in the number of provinces experiencing very high prevalence of insufficient food consumption, from the 7 reported in November to 5 out of 10 provinces in the country.

The Hunger analysis estimated the number of people with insufficient food consumption to have decreased from 6 million at the end of the November to 5.58 million at the end of December 2020. This improvement is linked to an increase in agricultural casual labour opportunities and in availability of local produce from early green harvest.

Supply of maize grain on the formal markets remained critically low, estimated to be available in only 3% of monitored markets, while availability of maize meal remained stable at an average of 61%.

In ZWL terms, prices were relatively stable over the month for vegetable oil and sugar beans, while prices for maize grain and unrefined maize meal recorded a 6% increase.

Prices in USD remained relatively stable over the month of December compared to November for maize grain and vegetable oil, while the average price reported for sugar beans and unrefined maize meal increased by 4% and 9% respectively.

Post published in: Agriculture

Zimbabwe’s inflation down to 348 pct in December – The Zimbabwean

“Month on month inflation rate in December 2020 was 4.22 percent, gaining 1.07 percentage points on the November 2020 rate of 3.15 percent,” the Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency revealed Monday on its official Twitter account.

In his 2021 budget presentation to parliament last November, Finance and Economic Development Minister Mthuli Ncube projected Zimbabwe’s annual inflation to close the year at 336 percent.

Inflation topped 837 percent last July, but fell to 761 percent in August following the introduction of a foreign exchange auction trading system which brought stability to the foreign exchange market.

Inflation has since maintained a downward spiral.

Zimbabwe’s economy is expected to grow by 7.4 percent after a projected 4.1 percent contraction this year.

Post published in: Business

Statement on the continued incarceration of Mayor of Harare, Cllr Jacob Mafume – The Zimbabwean

Jacob Mafume

Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition (CiZC) notes with great concern the arbitrary and insensitive incarceration of the Mayor of Harare and former CiZC Coordinator Cllr Jacob Mafume.

The Coalition feels that the right to liberty and free and fair trial are fundamental rights as enshrined in our constitution.  The inhuman incarceration comes at a time when news from the Mayor’s lawyer and Medical Doctor state that Cllr Mafume’s health has deteriorated drastically.

The Coalition wants to state in no unequivocal terms that the right to health is sacrosanct and must be accorded even to those in prison. The delay to try Cllr Mafume and exposing him to inhuman and degrading treatment must be condemned with the contempt it deserves.

The Symptoms that Cllr Mafume is showing are akin to Covid19 pandemic infection considering the living conditions in our prisons.

The constitution states that one is innocent until proven guilty, but in Cllr Mafume’s case, he has already been tried, convicted and sentenced. The state must not use the Ian Smith’s Rhodesian tactics to silence or punish its political opponents through persecution by prosecution.  The recent arrests of freelance Journalist Hope Chin’ono and Zengeza West MP, Hon. Job Sikhala, MDC Alliance Spokesperson Fadzayi Mahere proves our assertion.

The refusal by the High Court to release a passport to former Vice President, retired Army Commander, Dr.  Constantino Guvheya Nyikadzino Chiwenga’s wife Mary Mubaiwa to receive specialist medical attention outside the country in December 2020 attests to the state’s violation of human rights with impunity.

We call upon the state to allow Cllr Mafume access to health care, a free and fair trial without inordinate delay.

We also call upon the state not to use judicial capture as a weapon to punish and interfere with cases that involve those in the higher echelons of power.

We implore the state to seriously consider Mary Mubaiwa’s condition and lead by example in protecting the rights of women and their health.

We finally urge the state to provide adequate PPEs and humane conditions not only to  Cllr Mafume but all prisoners in Zimbabwe.

Post published in: Featured

UK Concerned About Chin’ono, Mafume, Sikhala And Mahere’s Arrest – The Zimbabwean

 

UK in Zimbabwe also raised concern about Harare Mayor Jacob Mafume’s continued detention since 11 December. Using microblogging site Twitter UK In Zimbabwe tweeted:

Following the arrests of Fadzayi Mahere & Job Sikhala after Hopewell Chin’ono’s arrest Friday. Concerned too by reports of ill health of Jacob Mafume who’s held in Harare. Important the law is equally applied to all & rights of prisoners upheld incl during C19 #ActiononReform

The embassy which is using the hashtag #ActiononReform tweeted over the weekend when Chin’ono was arrested and said:

Concerned to hear Hopewell Chin’ono will remain in custody for two more nights following his re-arrest on Friday. We continue to follow this case closely #ActiononReform

Meanwhile, law experts have said ZRP is charging Chin’ono, Mahere, Sikhala using a non-existant law that was struck off from the statutes in 2014 by the constitutional court.

Fadzayi Mahere Arrested – The Zimbabwean

MDC Alliance national spokesperson Fadzayi Mahere has been arrested and is currently at Harare Central Police Station, according to the Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights.

Posting on Twitter this Monday, Nyasha Musandu said members of the Criminal Investigations Department (CID) Law and Order visited the home of Mahere on Sunday but she was not in.

Mahere then turned herself in at C.I.D this Monday at 9 am in the presence of her lawyers.

The lawyer-cum politician been placed under arrest and awaits her warned and cautioned statement, Musandu further revealed.

@advocatemahere has now been fingerprinted, given a form 242 (initial charge form) and issued with a warned & cautioned statement. She denies the charge.

Police are currently saying they do not intend to take @advocatemahere to court today despite all paperwork having been completed and her having turned herself into CID Law & Order this morning at 9 am. They have offered no rational explanation for this.

Mahere is being accused of peddling falsehoods concerning a recent incident in which a police officer is alleged to have beaten up a mother and injured her baby.

More to follow…

Journalists dogged by poor wages, harassment – The Zimbabwean

HARARE, Zimbabwe

Poor wages, a devalued currency, and intimidation are haunting journalists in the southern African country of Zimbabwe.

With over a decade of experience as a freelance journalist under his belt, Thomas Madhuku, 35, has faced imprisonment and harassment from law enforcement agencies, and has faced numerous attacks while performing his duties.

Just last year, he was attacked at a press conference organized by student leaders over the abduction of Tawanda Muchehiwa, a Midlands State University journalism student.

“We were covering a press conference by ZINASU [Zimbabwe National Students Union] leaders who were demanding answers on the abduction of Muchehiwa. My phone was taken away by some militia with the assistance of the police,” he told Anadolu Agency.

It is not only the bouts of harassment at the hands of authorities and militia, but low wages are also impacting the journalists’ working conditions.

“I think the work environment is not ideal. The remuneration levels are too low to survive. Employers are also struggling because the media sector has been affected the most by current economic challenges,” said Madhuku.

Speaking to Anadolu Agency, Nkosana Dhlamini, editor of news portal NewZimbabwe.com, said that journalists are becoming victims as they often expose rights abuses against the public.

“In terms of wages, there is general despondency within the fraternity. They are often paid in the resented local currency,” added Dhlamini.

Serious threats from authorities

Landlocked Zimbabwe, the scene of much turmoil over the years, has seen its dollar drastically lose value against the US currency. At the current rate, 85 Zimbabwean dollars equal $1.

Such is the fear of intimidation that a top journalist reporting for an international news agency chose to speak on condition of anonymity about the crisis.

“Zimbabwe’s journalists are poorly remunerated, with many of them only able to make it to live the next day,” the journalist told Anadolu Agency on the condition of anonymity.

“Further, so-called handlers have turned many of them into lapdogs deciding what stories they should or should not write.”

“Zimbabwean journalists face serious threats from those in positions of power who want to use them as mere pawns in the game of politics,” said Mlondolozi Ndlovu, head of the Young Journalists Association.

He said those in power feel journalists should take positions that suit them, which affects those who report objectively and expose misdeeds by those in power.

“In terms of wages, journalists are some of the least-paid personnel, as they receive peanuts from both the privately owned and publicly owned media,” said Ndlovu.

Some earn less than $50 per month, which is not enough to take care of their personal needs and makes them more prone to corruption, he added.

Regime change makes no difference

Journalist Lucy Yasini said even in the wake of the 2017, the end of late President Robert Mugabe’s era of despotism, there has been no respite for journalists.

“The situation has not changed much as compared to the previous regime. What is new are the faces in power, but the tactics towards journalists are still the same. They are treated like enemies when they write in a way that is critical to those in authority,” Yasini told Anadolu Agency.

She said the country’s weak economy has affected the media industry as well.

“As we speak, some journalists are failing to even put food on their table,” she explained. “In the end, media owners are paying journalists next to nothing due to the non-performance of the economy leading to reduction of revenue flows into these companies, thereby affecting the quality of stories published or broadcast by media houses.”

On Friday Hopewell Chin’ono, a prominent Zimbabwean journalist known for covering corruption, was arrested by state security, his third such arrest in only six months.

He had exposed corruption in procurements related to combat COVID-19. His coverage led to the resignation of Health Minister Obadiah Moyo, accused of diversion in multimillion-dollar deals to procure essential supplies to fight the pandemic.

Last April, Tabani Moyo, director of the Zimbabwe office of Media Institute Southern Africa (MISA), said constitutional rights are on trial as journalists and media workers are being persecuted. He said the government of Zimbabwe must uphold the country’s Constitution and see to it that those that violate it are held accountable.

MISA promotes and defends media freedom and freedom of expression across the Southern Africa Development Community (SADC) region.

Lockdown politics: reflections from Zimbabwe – The Zimbabwean

Last week, the blog looked at the COVID-19 situation in Zimbabwe. The situation continues to get worse. On 9 January, there were 20499 reported cases and 483 deaths – 6000 more cases and over 100 more deaths in just a week. It looks like the South African ‘new variant’ is taking hold. Another very severe lockdown was imposed on 2 January, with strict movement restrictions, many businesses closed and a curfew.

However, like many other African settings, as discussed last week, so far at least the rural areas in particular seem not to have significant coronavirus incidence, with reported cases concentrated in urban areas. So are widespread, national lockdowns justified? Should governments persist with the harsh lockdowns that are perhaps best designed for different Western, urban settings with different social and economic profiles?

This is a difficult one. We don’t know if the early action by African states – including Zimbabwe – prevented a massive early spread, and it would be foolhardy to experiment with releasing lockdowns to boost the economy if it resulted in a massive transmission of disease during a second wave. And especially so in settings where health systems are deeply inadequate.

The Swedish experiment of a light lockdown has faltered badly in recent months, and the haphazard approach of the UK government to pandemic control measures has resulted in a huge and unnecessary death rate, even with a top quality health service.

Hardships, but innovations and transformations

What then are the downsides of the current approach of strictly following international public health guidelines? As we have documented in the blog series since March last year, the impacts of lockdowns on rural populations across our sites have been harsh. And the new lockdown in Zimbabwe is already biting hard.

This is a pattern seen across Africa as many studies have now shown. Reduced market access, lack of mobility for labour and work, school closures meaning kids don’t get an education… and so on. The story is now familiar. There have been many surveys of the impacts and the considerable costs of lockdowns. Lockdowns particularly hit those reliant on formal markets and those requiring mobility for their livelihoods.

Yet, as our field reports during 2020 have shown, in a largely informal economy, where exchanges are local, there has been an impressive resilience in rural areas and small towns in Zimbabwe so far. Without wanting to dismiss extreme hardships, falling perhaps especially on women and young people, the adaptations and innovations we saw over the past 9-10 months across our sites have been impressive.

Whether in terms of marketing, health care, off-farm income earning, trading or artisanal mining, a new array of new activities have sprung up so that people can survive during lockdowns. Compared to the formal phone surveys that many researchers are fond of, asking not just about what has changed from the status quo, and so highlighting the costs, we have also been asking what has emerged, highlighting innovations and opportunities too.

Our qualitative work across multiple sites in Zimbabwe shows not just how the existing agro-food and livelihood system suffered, but how it also was transformed – by necessity, and through skill and ingenuity. Reading back across our accounts from March 2020 onwards it is interesting how the tenor of the commentary changed: from negative impacts to positive opportunities, even in very tough circumstances.

Authoritarian reactions

A common argument about the downsides of lockdowns is that they provide space for authoritarian states to exert control on restive populations under the guise of public health measures. The Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition has recently produced a significant report (and video) on the shocking abuses that have occurred in Zimbabwe (and across SADC) over the past year, with heavy lockdowns and restrictions on movement seemingly being used as a pretext for arrests and violence, directed particularly against the opposition.

The ‘closing of civic space’ is very apparent in Zimbabwe, and was heightened especially in the build-up to the proposed 31 July uprising. While this never happened in the ways envisaged, the clamp-down was severe, affecting everyone, but especially journalists (arrested and imprisoned) and opposition leaders (sexually assaulted and imprisoned). This pattern continues, with new arrests during the past week, and some still imprisoned.

The argument in the Crisis Coalition reports is that lockdown measures were ‘excessive and disproportionate’, with state and security services using lockdowns to boost their control against rising opposition and internal faction fighting. It is implied that lockdowns should be released with ‘civic space’ restored. In other words, it is suggested that lockdowns are manipulated, becoming simply a political tool.

Many public health officials would however disagree, and especially now. With great hardship and without resources, they have been implementing the measures in good faith, with the genuine fear that the pandemic will take hold, and that only strict public health measures will hold it at bay. Public freedoms are always curtailed in a health emergency for the greater, longer-term good, they argue. Lockdowns are therefore essential, even if private civic freedoms are curtailed.

Lockdown politics

This of course is a tension seen in many countries, with anti-lockdown protests in favour of ‘freedom’ a common occurrence. However, in Zimbabwe, the context is particular. A more sophisticated reflection on these tensions is necessary.

It is always about politics, and political assessment of trade-offs. In the UK, for example, the discussion has been about opening up to boost the economy and people’s jobs and livelihoods, while protecting health through a complex and confusing set of public health measures. In Zimbabwe, the state had similar concerns, as the already dire state of the economy was made worse by the pandemic, and fears of public unrest and opposition mobilisation were raised.  Yet, actually, those economies with stricter public health measures have actually fared better economically over the pandemic, particularly in east and southeast Asia.

Lockdowns are of course no excuse for human rights abuses and illegal activities. These have been seen in many places, as the ‘emergency’ rhetoric of a pandemic provides the pretext for authoritarian measures, as well as corrupt practices. The rush to acquire personal protective equipment (PPE) at the beginning of the pandemic saw procurement practices abused massively across the world.

In Zimbabwe, media exposes resulted in the sacking of the health minister and fingers pointed to the very top, while in the UK the extent of involvement of senior politicians and associates in the Conservative party in getting favourable government contracts is only now becoming clear. This is now subject to a number of lawsuits, although still remarkably little mainstream media commentary, despite apparently extreme forms of corruption.

Pandemics are windows onto society

A pandemic exposes the worst and best of any society, and Zimbabwe is no exception. The failure of governance, the abuse of power and the authoritarian approach to politics has been laid bare, along with the tragic lack of capacity in the health service and the neglect of key workers, notably doctors and nurses who have been underpaid for years. But, at the same time, the way public health workers have worked tirelessly across the country sharing messages about keeping a distance, washing hands and so on has been impressive; in many cases involving people who are barely paid a living wage. The commitment of medical professionals is also amazing. Despite the terrible working conditions, they have insistently argued for solid public health measures and may have helped offset something worse. And, in response, the extraordinary resilience, as well as the improvisation, ingenuity and innovation, that people have shown over these months continues to impress.

Over the coming months, we will continue to monitor the situation across our Zimbabwe sites and report back via the blog, as the unpredictable life-cycle of a pandemic reveals much about the struggles of daily life and the political, cultural, social and economic responses to adversity in rural settings, which remains the on-going focus of this blog.

This post was written by Ian Scoones and first appeared on Zimbabweland.

Post published in: Featured