The 100 Largest Law Firms In Pennsylvania (2024) – Above the Law

There
are
many
different
and
exciting
ways
to
rank
law
firms.
How
prestigious
are
they?
How
much
money
are
they
making?
How
much
take-home
cash
do
partners
earn?
How
big
are
they?

Yes,
size
continues
to
matter
when
it
comes
to
Biglaw,
and
thankfully,
the

Legal
Intelligencer

recently
unleashed
its
annual
PA
Law
100,
a
ranking
of
the
largest
law
firms
in
Pennsylvania
covering
the
previous
calendar
year.
If
you’ve
ever
wondered
about
headcounts,
this
is
the
ranking
for
you.

The
top
10
biggest
firms
(numbers
show
attorneys
in
PA)
are
not
surprising
for
those
who
practice
in
the
region.
Let’s
take
a
moment
to
gawk
at
the
Keystone
State’s
Biglaw
behemoths:

  1. Cozen
    O’Connor:
    296
  2. Reed
    Smith:
    284
  3. Morgan
    Lewis
    &
    Bockius:
    280
  4. Fox
    Rothschild:
    241
  5. Buchanan
    Ingersoll
    &
    Rooney:
    234
  6. Marshall
    Dennehey:
    229
  7. Duane
    Morris:
    216
  8. Blank
    Rome:
    197
  9. Troutman
    Pepper
    Hamilton
    Sanders:
    190
  10. Eckert
    Seamans
    Cherin
    &
    Mellott:
    181

Congratulations
to
Cozen
for
employing
more
lawyers
in
Pennsylvania
than
any
other
firm.
This
firm
wins
the
award
for
putting
the
“big”
in
Biglaw
in
the
Birthplace
of
America.

Head
to
the

Legal
Intelligencer

if
you’re
curious
about
the
firms
ranked
16-100.


The
2024
Pa
Law
100

[Legal
Intelligencer]

Pa
100:
Largest
Law
Firms

[Legal
Intelligencer]



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on BlueskyX/Twitter,
and Threads, or
connect
with
her
on LinkedIn.

Quantum Computing Is Coming And Lawyers Aren’t Ready – Above the Law

The
profession
that
can’t
figure
out

how
to
avoid
citing
fake
cases

from
artificial
intelligence
will
soon
deal
with
a
technology
far
more
revolutionary.
This
month,

Google
unveiled
its
new
Willow
chip
,
heralding
a
significant
leap
in
quantum
computing.
Dare
we
say
a

Quantum
Leap
?
No,
we
dare
not.

Still,
this
is
a
science
that
confused
the
hell
out
of
Einstein
so
we
just
can’t
wait
to
see
how
lawyers
screw
this
one
up!

Quantum
computing
replacing
binary
ones-and-zeroes
computing
with
qubits
that
can
simultaneously
behave
as
ones
and
zeroes.
It’s
the
technological
equivalent
of
being
able
to
answer
“it
depends”
and
we
all
know
how
important
that
is
for
legal
reasoning.
Being
able
to
use
a
qubit
to
exist
as
0-0,
0-1,
1-1,
and
1-0
all
at
the
same
time
opens
the
door
to
an
exponential
explosion
in
computing
power
as
qubits
are
stacked
atop
each
other.
Google’s
announcement
claimed
that
Willow
took
5
minutes
to
complete
a
computation
that
today’s
fastest
supercomputer
would
crack
in
10
septillion
years.

Let’s
round
it
up
to
6
minutes
and
bill
it
as
“0.1

further
work.”

That’s
why
it
feels
like
the
next
big
thing
for
the
profession

starting
as
early
as
2025

will
be
quantum
computing.
Generative
AI
enjoyed
a
couple
years
in
the
spotlight
and
we
all
had
a
lot
of
fun.
It
drove
every
legal
technology
conversation
as
we
aired
all
our
daydreams
about
AI’s
potential
to
radically
alter
the
profession.
Even
though
its
current,
far
from
“smart”
iteration
is
likely

as
good
as
it
gets
,
it’s
still
a
powerful
tool
for
automating
rote
tasks
and
big
data
crunching

abilities
that
could

end
the
stranglehold
of
the
billable
hour

(video).
But
it’s
not
a
robot
lawyer
and
won’t
be
without
revolutions
in
other
fields
of
tech.

However,
quantum
computing
could
go
a
long
way
toward
accelerating
AI.
Even
without
harnessing
dilithium
crystals
to
provide
the
levels
of
power
needed
to
move
AI
beyond
its
“glorified
Clippy”
stage,
quantum
computing
can
supercharge
the
algorithms
behind
AI
tech.
As
Foreign
Policy
columnist
Vivek
Wadhwa
and
director
of
the
Stanford
Center
for
Responsible
Quantum
Technology
Mauritz
Kop

noted
in
2022
,
“artificial
intelligence
is
as
self-aware
as
a
paper
clip”
but
quantum
computing
could
allow
large
language
models
to
utilize
exponentially
more
parameters
and
learn
it
all
faster
and
using
less
energy.

That
said,
the
impact
this
technology
has
on
lawyers
will
be
felt
more
in
cybersecurity
than
AI.
Cybersecurity
was
already
set
to
be
a
hot
topic
for
lawyers
in
2025
with
a
new
administration
committed
to
starting
a
trade
war
with
America’s
most
technologically
advanced
adversaries
while
simultaneously
threatening
to

walk
away
from
global
cyber
commitments
,

slash
funding
for
the
Cybersecurity
and
Infrastructure
Security
Agency
,
and
place
Homeland
Security
under
the
stewardship
of

the
only
governor
who
turned
down
free
cybersecurity
money
.

But
she
can

protect
America
from
adorable
puppies
,
so
there’s
that.

As
if
the
U.S.

and
by
extension,
the
Western
corporate
world

wasn’t
exposed
enough,
advances
in
quantum
computing
would
allow
hackers
to
brute
force
blow
through
existing
security
protocols.
Eventually,
quantum
computing
will
also
allow
unbreakable
security
when
the
tech
creates
ever
changing
and
improbably
dense
encryptions
to
stay
ahead.

Unfortunately,
the
damage
may
already
be
done
without
you
knowing
it.

Hacking
entities
are
suspected
of
engaging
in
hack
now,
decrypt
later

tactics,
gathering
well-secured
data
now
in
the
hope
of
cracking
it
open
once
burgeoning
technology
delivers
that
power.
Law
firms
have
long
been
viewed
as
a
soft
underbelly
of
security

see
Panama
Papers

but
quantum
computing
risks
turning
even
the
most
responsible
firms
into
targets
when
today’s
top-of-the-line
security
is
able
to
be
cracked
within
minutes.

Beyond
data
privacy,
quantum
computing

opens
a
can
of
intellectual
property
worms
:

The
rapid
processing
speed
of
quantum
computers
could
facilitate
the
infringement
of
intellectual
property
rights
by
allowing
the
copying
and
modification
of
large
amounts
of
data
almost
instantaneously.
Lawyers
must
be
alert
to
the
evolution
of
intellectual
property
laws
and
work
on
new
legal
strategies
to
protect
their
clients’
rights
in
this
new
technological
environment.

And
if
you
thought
the
ownership
of
a
code
only
prompted
by
a
human
but
created
by
existing
AI
raised
IP
concerns,
wait
until
a
quantum-powered
algorithm
is
inventing
new
pharmaceuticals.

Kop
sees
an
urgent
need
for
drafting
legal
and
regulatory
frameworks
before
this
technology
is
fully
realized…

which
isn’t
that
far
off
:

And
many
of
the perils
and
risks
 are
unknown
because
they
are
beyond
our
current
imagination.
Breaking
cryptography
and
classical
data
security,
that’s
the
one
“use
case”
people
are
most
afraid
of
right
now.
We
call
that
Q-Day”,
the
day
when
quantum
computers
suddenly
break
the
Internet.
And
we
are
looking
at
a
time
frame
of
just
three
years
for
that,
so
there
is
tremendous
urgency
here
to
get
things
right,
both
on
the
software
and
hardware
side
of
things.
And
then
there
are
huge
risks
associated
with
authoritarianism
and
state
surveillance,
because
quantum
is
ubiquitous
and
potentially
dual
use.
Quantum
Artificial
Intelligence
(QAI)
will
be
like
AI
on
steroids.
It’s
a dictator’s
dream
.

“Three
years,”
“break
the
internet,”
and
“dictator’s
dream”
amount
to
a
troubling
game
of
Mad
Libs.

Kop
said
that
in
April
when
quantum
computing
was
still
held
in
check.
Google’s
saying
it’s
gotten
quantum
errors

the
drift
into
wrongness
that
can
happen
as
all
this
spooky
action
heaps
upon
itself

below
threshold,
meaning
the
more
qubits
they’re
adding,
the
fewer
errors
they’re
getting.

Will
2025
be
the
year
of
quantum?
It
might
still
be
slightly
early.
But
Kop’s
warning
that
legal
needs
to
get
on
top
of
this
technology
before
it
reaches
full
realization
means
2025
should
be
the
year
of
quantum
for
the
legal
industry.


Earlier
:

For
The
Love
Of
All
That
Is
Holy,
Stop
Blaming
ChatGPT
For
This
Bad
Brief


Generative
AI…
What
If
This
Is
As
Good
As
It
Gets?




HeadshotJoe
Patrice
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
Feel
free
to email
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments.
Follow
him
on Twitter or

Bluesky

if
you’re
interested
in
law,
politics,
and
a
healthy
dose
of
college
sports
news.
Joe
also
serves
as
a

Managing
Director
at
RPN
Executive
Search
.

Another Boutique Firm Goes Above Market! – Above the Law

The
firms
in
the
Am
Law
100
may
have
large
headcounts,
but
the
only
numbers
that
really
matter
are
on
your
check!
There
are
some
great
boutiques
out
there
shelling
out
Biglaw
money,
and
Hueston
Hennigan
is
one
of
’em!

The
trial
boutique
awarded
all
bonus-eligible
associates
a
higher-than-market
bonus,
with
some
associates
receiving
two
to
three
times
the
market
bonus
for
their
class!
Here’s
the
market
scale
for
context:

Winston Bonus Grid 2024

The
Southern
California-based
law
firm
is
making
a
name
for
itself

by
earning
massive
wins
for
their
clients

and
passing
the
good
fortune
on
to
their
employees.

We
like
hearing
about
bonuses
almost
as
much
as
you
enjoy
spending
them.
As
soon
as
your
firm’s
memo
comes
out,
please
email
it
to
us
(subject
line:
“[Firm
Name]
Bonus”)
or
text
us
(646-820-8477).
Please
include
the
memo
if
available.
You
can
take
a
photo
of
the
memo
and
send
it
via
text
or
email
if
you
don’t
want
to
forward
the
original
PDF
or
Word
file.

And
if
you’d
like
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s
Salary
&
Bonus
Alerts,
please
scroll
down
and
enter
your
email
address
in
the
box
below
this
post.
If
you
previously
signed
up
for
the
bonus
alerts,
you
don’t
need
to
do
anything.
You’ll
receive
an
email
notification
within
minutes
of
each
bonus
announcement
that
we
publish.



Chris
Williams
became
a
social
media
manager
and
assistant
editor
for
Above
the
Law
in
June
2021.
Prior
to
joining
the
staff,
he
moonlighted
as
a
minor
Memelord™
in
the
Facebook
group Law
School
Memes
for
Edgy
T14s
.
 He
endured
Missouri
long
enough
to
graduate
from
Washington
University
in
St.
Louis
School
of
Law.
He
is
a
former
boatbuilder
who
cannot
swim, a
published
author
on
critical
race
theory,
philosophy,
and
humor
,
and
has
a
love
for
cycling
that
occasionally
annoys
his
peers.
You
can
reach
him
by
email
at [email protected] and
by
tweet
at @WritesForRent.


Bonus Time

Enter
your
email
address
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s

Bonus
&
Salary
Increase
Alerts
.


Generative AI At Work: Boosting e-Discovery Efficiency For Corporate Legal Teams – Above the Law

Generative
AI
is
revolutionizing
the
legal
industry
by
driving
critical
efficiencies
in
long-established
processes.
Doing
more
with
less
has
historically
been
a
challenge
for
in-house
counsel,
and
teams
are
eager
for
new
solutions,
particularly
in
e-discovery.
As
documented
in
a
new
IDC
Research
Study
commissioned
by
Relativity,
Generative
AI
in
Legal
2024,
50%
of
respondents
have
reported
that
their
AI
use
has
increased
over
the
past
two
years
and
respondents
reported
that
48%
of
their
day-to-day
AI
use
involves
generative
AI.

Knowing
where
to
start
with
generative
AI
can
feel
overwhelming,
especially
with
so
many
potential
applications.
To
help
narrow
the
options
and
derive
the
greatest
value,
in-house
teams
need
to
prioritize
solutions
that
will
have
the
most
impact
on
how
they
work.
For
teams
ready
to
apply
generative
AI
directly
to
e-discovery,
first-pass
review
has
proven
a
great
area
to
start.


Why
First-Pass
Review

During
a
recent
industry
event,
in-house
e-discovery
leaders
highlighted
three
key
reasons
for
why
first-pass
review
is
an
ideal
starting
place:

  • Optimize
    review
    workflows:
    Teams
    can
    determine
    their
    generative
    AI
    workflow
    and
    keep
    human
    reviewers
    in
    the
    loop.
    Generative
    AI-powered
    technology
    can
    be
    used
    for
    first-pass
    review,
    followed
    by
    a
    second
    pass
    by
    human
    reviewers
    to
    confirm
    documents
    are
    responsive.
  • Save
    time
    and
    money:
    Generative
    AI
    can
    analyze
    thousands
    of
    documents
    per
    hour,
    quickly
    identifying
    the
    most
    relevant
    content.
  • Standardize
    document
    evaluation:
    Generative
    AI
    provides
    a
    consistent
    determination
    every
    time,
    unlike
    human
    reviewers
    who
    might
    code
    the
    same
    document
    differently.
    It
    doesn’t
    get
    exhausted
    through
    long
    documents
    and
    performs
    a
    full
    assessment
    every
    time.

In
the
end,
experimentation
is
key
to
learning
quickly
and
getting
the
most
out
of
generative
AI-
powered
solutions.
From
automating
routine
tasks
to
taking
on
parts
of
the
EDRM,
continuous
testing
and
refinement
finding
will
help
you
find
the
most
effective
use
case
for
your
organization.

Callout box


Trust
But
Verify 

As
with
any
new
technology
or
process
change,
corporate
legal
teams
should
approach
generative
AI
with
the
same
caution,
identifying
inherent
risks
and
verifying
outputs.
When
evaluating
the
results
of
generative
AI,
teams
can
depend
on
the
same
best
practice
metrics
used
in
e-discovery
for
the
last
20
years:
recall,
precision,
elusion
rate
and
more.
By
adhering
to
these
metrics
for
accuracy,
teams
can
easily
gauge
the
performance
of
their
prompt
input
and
compare
results
to
current
workflows.

Generative
AI
does
introduce
new
types
of
risks,
but
these
risks
can
be
mitigated
with
appropriate
technology
parameters.
For
example,
Relativity
addresses
the
risk
of
hallucinations
through
a
chain-of-thought
approach,
requiring
that
generative
AI
validate
its
citations
in
the
source
document
it
is
analyzing.

When
it
comes
to
security
and
privacy
with
generative
AI,
organizations
need
to
deploy
strategies
to
prevent
employee
misuse.
Public
models
like
ChatGPT
are
constantly
learning,
and
employees
can
easily
input
proprietary
data
into
prompts
that
become
part
of
the
training
data
set
for
future
outputs.


Relativity

At
Relativity,
generative
AI
solutions
are

built
with
privacy
and
security

at
their
core
using
a
secure
integration
with
Microsoft
Azure’s
OpenAI
services.
All
data
input
into
Relativity
aiR
for
Review
stays
within
the
confines
of
RelativityOne,
and
no
data
is
stored
or
retained
by
Azure
OpenAI.
Additionally,
all
AI
innovation
rests
upon
Relativity’s

AI
Principles
,
which
guide
our
everyday
decision-making
to
ensure
we’re
creating
technology
that’s
clear,
fair,
and
gives
our
customers
the
utmost
control.


Starting
your
Journey 

Like
any
journey,
the
beginning
is
the
hardest
part.
Here
are
some
tips
to
get
started:


  • Identify
    effective
    use
    cases
    :
    Determine
    where
    you
    are
    spending
    the
    most
    resources
    and
    your
    appetite
    for
    generative
    AI
    to
    help
    address
    challenges.
    For
    ideas,
    check
    out
    the
    AI
    Advantage
    Webinar
    Series
    to
    hear
    from
    your
    peers.

  • Recognize
    the
    opportunity
    :
    Generative
    AI
    offers
    a
    unique
    chance
    to
    differentiate
    yourself
    as
    a
    leader
    and
    set
    your
    company
    apart
    from
    the
    competition. Those
    that
    started
    early
    are
    already
    logging
    many
    successes
    and
    savings.

  • Experiment
    and
    learn
    fast
    :
    The
    more
    you
    use
    your
    models
    and
    train
    them
    on
    your
    data,
    the
    more
    powerful
    and
    accurate
    they
    will
    become
    to
    you.
    Likewise,
    the
    faster
    you
    start
    prompting,
    the
    faster
    you
    can
    determine
    what
    prompts
    deliver
    the
    best
    results.
    Most
    importantly,
    technology
    companies
    are
    innovating
    on
    these
    products
    faster
    than
    ever
    and
    the
    earlier
    you
    sign
    on,
    the
    more
    you
    can
    define
    changes
    to
    products.

  • Collaborate
    for
    success
    :
    Partner
    with
    internal
    and
    external
    teams
    to
    identify
    avenues
    for
    enhanced
    productivity.
    For
    example,
    external
    teams
    can
    use
    generative
    AI
    to
    save
    you
    money
    on
    billable
    hours.
    Or,

    complete
    jobs
    in
    a
    fraction
    of
    the
    time
    .

The
next
step
to
implementing
generative
AI
into
your
e-discovery
workflows
is
simple:

set
up
time
with
the
Relativity
team

to
find
the
right
solution
or
partner
for
your
business.

Profile Raising 101 For Busy Lawyer Mothers  – Above the Law


Ed.
note
:
This
is
the
latest
installment
in
a
series
of
posts
on
motherhood
in
the
legal
profession,
in
partnership
with
our
friends
at 
MothersEsquire.
Welcome
Susan
Peters
to
our
pages.
Click



here


if
you’d
like
to
donate
to
MothersEsquire.

You
worked
incredibly
hard
to
get
to
this
place
professionally
and
develop
your
skills.
For
2025,
make
it
a
priority
to
raise
your
profile
and
get
more
work
that
you
want!

As
a
former
litigator
turned
public
relations
and
communications
professional,
my
advice
is
to
promote
yourself
at
all
stages
of
your
career,
whether
you
are
a
brand-new
lawyer
or
have
been
practicing
for
a
while.

Profile
raising
is
key
for
lawyers
looking
to
cement
long-term
success,
build
influence,
and
position
themselves
as
leaders
in
their
field.

Lawyers,
especially
busy
mother
attorneys
ask
me
all
the
time:
Why
should
I
care
about
self-promotion?
Why
do
this
with
what
little
free
time
I
have?
Isn’t
my
work
product
good
enough?
Sadly,
the
answer
is
no

profile
raising
is
crucial
for
women
for
many
reasons.

There
is
a
huge

gender
gap
in
self-promotion
,
which
incredibly
begins
as
early
as
sixth
grade,
and
a
study
finds
that
female
workers’
deep
discomfort
over
touting
their
skills
and
experience
adds
to
gender
gap
in
promotions
and
pay.
We
have
to
fix
this!


Why
Should
I
Promote
Myself?
Some
Key
Considerations

Lawyers
with
strong,
visible
profiles
are
more
likely
to
attract
new
clients.
A
well-established
public
presence
signals
expertise
and
trustworthiness,
making
clients
more
comfortable
in
choosing
them
for
legal
representation.

Profile
raising
helps
lawyers
manage
and
shape
their
public
image.
By
actively
engaging
in
thought
leadership,
commenting
on
newsworthy
topics,
social
media,
or
public
speaking,
lawyers
control
how
they
are
perceived
by
the
public,
peers
and
clients.

In
a
crowded
legal
market,
raising
your
profile
distinguishes
you
and
sets
you
apart
from
the
competition.
Being
known
for
a
particular
expertise
or
leadership
in
the
industry
often
gives
you
a
competitive
edge
in
securing
high-profile
cases
and
clients.

Additionally,
a
well-known
lawyer
can
leverage
their
public
profile
to
build
a
wider
network
of
peers,
clients
and
industry
contacts.
These
relationships
can
lead
to
collaborations,
referrals
and
new
business
opportunities.

A
strong
profile
also
makes
lawyers
attractive
for
media
interviews
(the
fun
stuff!)
and
speaking
engagements.
This
helps
further
elevate
your
status
as
a
thought
leader.
Lastly,
lawyers
with
elevated
profiles
are
more
likely
to
receive
referrals
from
colleagues,
clients,
and
other
industry
professionals
who
recognize
their
expertise
and
trust
their
reputation.


Some
Suggested
Tactics
On
How
To
Do
It 

I
am
often
asked
what
are
the
most
effective
ways
to
raise
my
profile
with
the
least
amount
of
time
and
effort.
While
everyone
is
different
and
excels
in
different
areas,
some
of
my
top
suggestions:



Thought
Leadership
and
Content
Creation

One
of
the
most
impactful
ways
to
raise
your
profile
is
through
thought
leadership.
Writing
articles,
blogs,
or
op-eds
on
topics
relevant
to
your
practice
areas
allows
you
to
showcase
your
expertise
and
become
a
go-to
source
for
the
media.
Publishing
in
industry
or
legal
publications
or
contributing
to
platforms
like
LinkedIn
can
position
you
as
authoritative
voices
in
your
field.

Have
limited
time?
Focus
on
topics
that
align
with
your
daily
work
or
cases
that
you
are
currently
handling.
This
makes
content
creation
less
time-consuming
but
still
highly
relevant.



Speaking
Engagements

Speaking
at
conferences,
panels,
and
webinars
offers
a
direct
way
to
demonstrate
your
knowledge
and
build
your
professional
reputation.
If
you
are
newer
to
practicing
or
nervous
about
getting
started,
look
for
smaller,
local
engagements
or
virtual
events,
which
require
less
travel
and
time
commitment.
Bar
associations,
legal
organizations,
and
women-focused
networks
can
often
offer
great
opportunities.
Preparing
a
few
key
presentations
on
familiar
topics
allows
you
to
reuse
and
refine
your
material,
reducing
the
prep
time
needed
for
each
new
event.



Awards
And
Recognitions

Actively
pursue
professional
awards
and
recognitions!
Sometimes
women
are
more
shy
or
nervous
about
submitting
for
these,
but
you
should
not
be!
These
accolades
offer
third-party
validation
of
your
skills
and
achievements.
Either
you
or
your
marketing
professional 
should
identify
relevant
awards
and
submit
nominations
for
yourself
(and
others).



Social
Media 

Social
media,
particularly
LinkedIn,
provides
an
excellent
platform
to
share
your
insights,
successes,
and
opinions.
By
consistently
engaging
with
relevant
content
and
sharing
professional
milestones,
women
lawyers
can
build
a
robust
digital
footprint
that
amplifies
their
personal
brand
with
minimal
time
invested.



Networking 

Networking
is
critical
for
elevating
your
profile.
However,
this
doesn’t
mean
that
you
must
attend
every
event

that
leads
to
burnout
and
overextension.
Be
strategic

choose
key
industry
events,
join
niche
groups
(like

MothersEsquire
),
and
cultivate
a
small
but
powerful
network
of
mentors,
peers,
and
influencers
in
your
area
of
law.

Depending
on
what
stage
you
are
at
in
your
career,
it
is
important
to
stay
connected
and
visible.
These
groups
foster
a
sense
of
belonging
in
a
profession
that
can
feel
isolating,
especially
for
mothers
juggling
multiple
roles.

Balancing
a
legal
career
and
motherhood
comes
with
unique
challenges,
such
as
managing
demanding
schedules,
client
expectations,
and
family
obligations.
Networking
with
peers
who
also
cope
with
and
understand
these
struggles
gives
much-needed
emotional
support
and
camaraderie.
These
groups
also
create
a
unique
safe
space
to
share
experiences,
offer
advice,
and
celebrate
successes.

In
our
group,
discussions
often
come
up
on
topics
of
importance
to
lawyer
moms
such
as
navigating
parental
leave
policies,
maintaining
work-life
balance,
or
dealing
with
bias
in
the
workplace.
Members
are
really
generous
about
sharing
their
resources
like
tips
on
time
management,
childcare
solutions,
or
strategies
for
returning
to
work
after
maternity
leave.
It
is
also
a
great
resource
for
referrals,
as
members
regularly
solicit
recommendations
for
lawyers
serving
the
specific
practice
area
and
jurisdiction
that
they
need.

MothersEsquire
has
been
a
great
group
for
networking
and
has
allowed
me
to
connect
with
lawyer
mothers
at
all
different
stages
of
their
careers,
from
law
school
students
to
mothers
with
adult
kids
out
of
college.

By
combining
these
tactics
and
sometimes
getting
out
of
your
comfort
zone
a
bit,
you
can
meaningfully
raise
their
profiles,
even
within
the
constraints
of
a
busy
legal
career
and
often-hectic
family
life.




Susan_PetersSusan
Peters
is
the
founder
of

Greybridge
PR
,
which
provides
public
relations
and
communications
assistance
for
legal
and
professional
service
firms.
She
was
a
litigator
in
New
York
City
for
over
eight
years
before
switching
careers. 
She
is
also
a
member
of
the
board
of
MothersEsquire.

Biglaw Partners Are Entering Their ‘Free Agency’ Era – Above the Law



Ed.
note
:
Welcome
to
our
daily
feature,

Quote
of
the
Day
.


Perhaps
the
most
transformative
change
in
the
profession
in
recent
years
has
been
the
advent
of
free
agency
among
partners
and
even
among
certain
clients.
Partners
no
longer
presumptively
stay
with
their
firms
for
life.
Clients,
too,
switch
firm
loyalties
with
increasing
frequency.
These
are
today’s
market
realities.





Brad
Karp
,
chair
of
Paul
Weiss,
in
comments
given
to
the

American
Lawyer
,
on
the
trend
of
partners’
free
agency,
which
has
changed
the
face
of
what
recruiting
looks
like
across
the
legal
landscape.



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on BlueskyX/Twitter,
and Threads, or
connect
with
her
on LinkedIn.

Far-Right Group Weaponizing Ethics Complaints Against Federal Judges. Again. – Above the Law

The
Article
III
Project
(A3P)
is
back
on
its
bullshit.
The
right-wing
group
was
founded
by
Mike
Davis
(who
is
not
a
fan
of

Brown
v.
Board

and
thinks
it’s
time
for

Americans
to
“arm
up”
against
the
“Black
underclass”
).
Their

mission

is
to
bring
“brass
knuckles
to
fight
leftist
lawfare”
and
are

fresh
off
a
victory

getting
Judge
Michael
Ponsor
rebuked
for
(accurately)
calling
Samuel
Alito’s

flying
of
flags

favored

by
insurrectionists

“improper”
and
“dumb.” 
Now
they’re
taking
the
fight
to
Fourth
Circuit
Judge
James
Wynn
Jr.

Wynn
recently
decided
to

rescind
his
decision

to
take
senior
status
(as
did

two
district
court
judges
).
That
is
something
federal
judges
can
do!
And
if
it’s
all
judges
appointed
by
Democratic
presidents,
<shrug>.
Still
something
they’re
allowed
to
do!
Sure,
some
Republicans
will
be
butthurt
over
it,
calling
it
the
politicization
of
the
judiciary
because

irony
is
well
and
truly
dead
.
You
don’t
have
to
like
it,
but
you
know,
that’s
the
system
we
have.

But
A3P
is
going
to
try
and
make
it
a
thing.

As

reported
by

Law
&
Crime,
the
far-right
group
filed
an

ethics
complaint

against
Wynn.
According
to
A3P:

“The
complaint
raises
serious
concerns
about
violations
of
the
Code
of
Conduct
for
United
States
Judges
following
Judge
Wynn’s
abrupt
decision
to
withdraw
his
earlier
announcement
of
retirement
in
December
2024,
immediately
following
the
outcome
of
the
2024
presidential
election,”
A3P
said
in
its
statement.
“A3P’s
complaint
makes
clear
that
this
sudden
reversal
was
politically
motivated
and
undermines
public
trust
in
the
judiciary.”

Let
me
see
if
I
got
this:
displaying
a
symbol
of
insurrection,
not
political.
Choosing
not
to
take
senior
status?
Political.
Gotcha.

There
is
absolutely
a
problem
with

the
public’s
trust
in
the
judiciary
,
but
this
ISN’T
THE
ROOT
OF
THE
ISSUE.
There’s
the
whole
Alito
thing
(and
the
fact
he
refused
to
recuse
himself
from
hearing
January
6th-related
cases
even
after
this
fact
went
public).
The
grift
Clarence
Thomas
appears
to
be
running
from
the
High
Court
(there were so,
so, so many revelations
about
the luxury
gifts
 Thomas received and repeatedly failed
to disclose).
The

stolen

Supreme
Court
seat.
The
way
the
Court
actively

thumbs
its
nose
at
the
notion
of
being
held
accountable

to
even
the
most
basic
of
ethical
standards.
*These*
are
the
problems,
dude.
Not
Wynn’s
(non)retirement.




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].

‘United Healthcare’ Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images Which Is Bizarre & Wildly Inappropriate – Above the Law

We
KNOW
Getty
owns
this
picture
though
that
might
not
stop
UHC.
(Photo
by
Jeff
Swensen/Getty
Images)

Someone
purporting
to
be
United
Healthcare
is
filing
DMCA
requests
to
scrub
the
internet
of
artists’
depictions
of
the
surveillance
video
of
Luigi
smiling,
parody
merchandise
of
“Deny,
Defend,
Depose,”
and
other
merchandise
showing
the
alleged
shooter.

If
it
is
really
the
health
insurer
filing
these
notices,
it
wildly
oversteps
any
legal
rights
the
company
might
have,
but
if
there’s
any
company
willing
to
preemptively
breach
the
law
and
dare
the
other
side
to
spend
their
limited
resources
trying
to
protect
their
rights
it
would
be
a
health
insurer.


404
Media
reports

that
a
number
of
DMCA
takedown
requests
from
“United
Healthcare”
have
hit
artists
depicting
the
newsworthy
event.
The
publication
reached
out
to
the
company
to
confirm
that
it’s
behind
the
filings
but
didn’t
hear
back.

For
those
keeping
score
at
home,
the
DMCA
provides
that
a

copyright
owner

must
inform
an
internet
entity
that
their
intellectual
property
is
being
abused
and
the
service
provider
then
has
an
opportunity
to
expeditiously
remove
the
material
and
avoid
possible
liability.
That
said,
the
DMCA
only
provides
a
shield
against
legal
action
and
if
the
copyright
claim
is

to
use
the
precise
legal
term

“utter
bullshit,”
they
don’t
have
to
comply.
Unfortunately,
hosts
routinely
err
on
the
side
of
caution
and
remove
content
when
there’s
zero
cognizable
claim.

If
this
is
someone
acting
on
behalf
of
United
Healthcare,
what
an
irony
to
lodge
a
falsified
claim
without
it
getting
denied.

From
404:

An
entity
claiming
to
be
United
Healthcare
is
sending
bogus
copyright
claims
to
internet
platforms
to
get
Luigi
Mangione
fan
art
taken
off
the
internet,
according
to
the
print-on-demand
merch
retailer
TeePublic.
An
independent
journalist
was
hit
with
a
copyright
takedown
demand
over
an
image
of
Luigi
Mangione
and
his
family
she
posted
on
Bluesky,
and
other
DMCA
takedown
requests
posted
to
an
open
database
and
viewed
by
404
Media
show
copyright
claims
trying
to
get
“Deny,
Defend,
Depose”
and
Luigi
Mangione-related
merch
taken
off
the
internet,
though
it
is
unclear
who
is
filing
them.

It’s
a
bizarre
and
grimly
ironic
turn
if
United
Healthcare
wanted
to

own

the
words
“Deny,
Defend,
Depose.”
The
takedown
request
for
that
piece
objects
to
the
artist
styling
the
“D”
with
elements
of
the
United
Healthcare
logo…
which
would
be
the
very
definition
of
protected
parody.
The
404
story
has
images
if
you
want
to
see
what
these
all
look
like.

Beyond
tying
itself
to
the
gunman’s
catchphrase,
the
idea
of
UHC
trying
to
own
any
and
all
fixations
of
the
alleged
shooter’s
likeness
would
be
a
wild
leap.
An
artists’
depiction
of
Mangione
could

only

belong
to
the
artist
(Mangione
might
be
able
to
assert
some
rights
to
his
likeness

a
dubious
claim
under
the
circumstances
and
in
light
of
the
First
Amendment

but
in
no
case
would
UHC
have
such
a
claim).

“What
is
the
circumstance
under
which
United
Healthcare
might
come
to
own
the
copyright
to
a
watercolor
painting
of
the
guy
who
assassinated
their
CEO?”
tech
rights
expert
and
science
fiction
author
Cory
Doctorow
told
404
Media
in
a
phone
call.
“It’s
just
like,
it’s
hard
to
imagine”
a
lawyer
thinking
that,
he
added,
saying
that
it’s
an
example
of
“copyfraud.”

It
is
illegal
to
file
DMCA
notices
if
you
don’t
own
the
copyright
(or
at
least
have
a
good
faith
belief
that
you
do).
The
idea
that
UHC
now
owns
every
depiction
of
the
guy
accused
of
killing
their
employee
is
laughably
frivolous
and
one

hopes

that
its
legal
department
understands
this
and
these
requests
are
coming
from
a
third
party
troll
impersonating
the
carrier.

An
independent
journalist
posting
a
photo
of
Mangione
with
his
family
also
received
a
DMCA
request

from
a
lawyer
claiming
to
represent
a
family
member
holding
the
copyright

even
though
the
image
was
“originally
posted
on
the
campaign
website
of
Maryland
assemblymember
Nino
Mangione.”
That
site
apparently
deleted
the
image
and
turned
around
to
threaten
anyone
using
it
now
which
is…
not
how
fair
use
works.
But
at
least
this
request
can
claim
they
have
a
“good
faith”
claim,
though
the
system
probably
shouldn’t
reward
people
for
trying
to
retroactively
claim
rights
after
they
try
to
memory-hole
their
internet
history.

But
the
disturbing
thread
running
through
all
these
requests
is
how
easy
it’s
become
for
copyright
trolls
to
leverage
the
DMCA
to
intimidate
providers
into
accepting
facially
invalid
requests.
The
statute
has
given
way
to
a
sort
of
asymmetrical
warfare
over
IP
where
bad
faith
actors
can
pepper
sites
with
ownership
claims
and
trust
that
their
targets
will
back
down
rather
than
deal
with
the
litigation
risk.
As
404’s
coverage
notes,
this
doesn’t
bode
well
in
a
country
about
to
inaugurate
an
administration
openly
encouraging
retribution
against
journalists
in
an
effort
to
silence
criticism.

This
sure
looks
like
a
company
(and
a
local
politician)
trying
to
use
copyright
law
as
a
“square
peg-round
hole”
solution
to
erasing
any
humanizing
or
sympathetic
depiction
of
Mangione.
And
unfortunately,
everyone
seems
to
be
obeying
in
advance.


Copyright
Abuse
Is
Getting
Luigi
Mangione
Merch
Removed
From
the
Internet

[404
Media]




HeadshotJoe
Patrice
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
Feel
free
to email
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments.
Follow
him
on Twitter or

Bluesky

if
you’re
interested
in
law,
politics,
and
a
healthy
dose
of
college
sports
news.
Joe
also
serves
as
a

Managing
Director
at
RPN
Executive
Search
.

How Did Provider Groups React to Congress’ End-of-Year Healthcare Package? – MedCity News

This
week,
Congress
released
a

stopgap
funding
bill

that
included
a
significant
healthcare
package. 

Provider
groups
are
reacting
favorably
to
the
package,
mainly
due
to
provisions
that
go
after
pharmacy
benefit
managers,
extend
telehealth
flexibilities
and
increase
payments
to
hospitals
and
physicians.


PBM
reform

The
legislation
proposes
changes
that
would
reign
in
pharmacy
benefit
managers’
business
practices.
Specifically,
it
would
require
PBMs
to
pass
through
100%
of
drug
rebates
and
discounts
to
employers
or
health
plans,
as
well
as
prohibit
PBMs
from
linking
their
compensation
to
a
drug’s
Medicare
list
price.
The
package
also
seeks
to
eliminate
spread
pricing
in
Medicaid

which
occurs
when
PBMs
keep
a
portion
of
the
amount
paid
to
them
for
drugs.

These
proposed
changes

which
are
slated
to
take
effect
in
2028

have
been
received
well
by
the

American
Pharmacists
Association
.

“For
years,
APhA
has
advocated
for
these
long
overdue
reforms
to
begin
to
stop
PBMs’
harmful
business
practices
that
have
robbed
many
communities
of
the
necessary
health
care
services
they
have
come
to
rely
upon,”
APhA
CEO
Michael
Hogue,
PharmD,
said
in
a
statement.


Extended
telehealth
flexibilities

Congress
is
seeking
to
extend
Medicare
telehealth
flexibilities
through
the
end
of
2026.

This
extension
would
allow
patients
to
continue
receiving
telehealth
services
from
their
homes,
permit
the
use
of
audio-only
communication
for
certain
services,
and
enable
rural
health
clinics
and
federally
qualified
health
centers
in
providing
virtual
care.

Chip
Kahn,
CEO
of
the

Federation
of
American
Hospitals
,
released
a
statement
applauding
these
measures.

“Congress’
health
package
hits
the
spot

it
protects
rural
health
care
and
assures
seniors
continued
telehealth
services
while
preventing
cuts
to
hospitals
serving
the
most
vulnerable.
Together,
these
provisions
will
sustain
critical
patient
care
at
the
right
time,
in
the
right
setting,”
he
stated.


Changes
to
payment
and
reimbursement

Congress’
package
would
delay
next
year’s
Medicaid
disproportionate
hospital
share
pay
cuts
until
2027.
It
would
also
temporarily
boost
the
Medicare
physician
fee
schedule
by
2.5%
for
2025,
which
would
offset
the
2.83%
payment
reduction
that
CMS
recently
finalized
for
next
year.

Stacey
Hughes,
executive
vice
president
of
the
American
Hospital
Association,
celebrated
these
provisions
in
a
statement.

“The
AHA
appreciates
the
House
and
Senate
working
together
on
this
bipartisan
healthcare
package
and
urges
Congress
to
pass
this
health
care
package
that
will
ensure
hospitals
and
health
systems
can
continue
to
care
for
their
patients
and
communities,”
she
said.


Photo:
MikeyLPT,
Getty
Images

Biglaw Firm Matches Milbank And Rewards Associates For Racking Up Hours – Above the Law

It
pays
to
keep
your
head
down
and
work.
Not
only
can
it
keep
you
out
of
unnecessary
drama,
but
it
pays
to
do
so!
Sheppard
Mullin
recently
announced
bonuses
and
the
cash
they’re
throwing
out
reflects
an
appreciation
for
hard
work.

The
Biglaw
firm
reported
$1,120,922,000
in
gross
revenue
in
and
profits
per
equity
partner
of
$2,325,000
in
2023,
according
to
the
most
recent
Am
Law
100
ranking.
And,

unlike
at
HoLove
,
they’re
handing
out
special
bonuses!
Here’s
the
scale:

Screen Shot 2024-12-19 at 1.35.24 PM

The
difference
that
50
hours
can
make!
Congratulations
to
everyone
who
made
the
2000-hour
cut-off
and
an
additional
10%
to
20%
praise
to
those
who
went
above
and
beyond.
For
everyone
else,
better
luck
next
year.
Don’t
pout
too
much

just
being
an
attorney
at
Sheppard
Mullin
means
that
you’re
still
one
of
the
top
earners
in
the
country.

We
like
hearing
about
bonuses
almost
as
much
as
you
enjoy
spending
them.
As
soon
as
your
firm’s
memo
comes
out,
please
email
it
to
us
(subject
line:
“[Firm
Name]
Bonus”)
or
text
us
(646-820-8477).
Please
include
the
memo
if
available.
You
can
take
a
photo
of
the
memo
and
send
it
via
text
or
email
if
you
don’t
want
to
forward
the
original
PDF
or
Word
file.

And
if
you’d
like
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s
Salary
&
Bonus
Alerts,
please
scroll
down
and
enter
your
email
address
in
the
box
below
this
post.
If
you
previously
signed
up
for
the
bonus
alerts,
you
don’t
need
to
do
anything.
You’ll
receive
an
email
notification
within
minutes
of
each
bonus
announcement
that
we
publish.



Chris
Williams
became
a
social
media
manager
and
assistant
editor
for
Above
the
Law
in
June
2021.
Prior
to
joining
the
staff,
he
moonlighted
as
a
minor
Memelord™
in
the
Facebook
group Law
School
Memes
for
Edgy
T14s
.
 He
endured
Missouri
long
enough
to
graduate
from
Washington
University
in
St.
Louis
School
of
Law.
He
is
a
former
boatbuilder
who
cannot
swim, a
published
author
on
critical
race
theory,
philosophy,
and
humor
,
and
has
a
love
for
cycling
that
occasionally
annoys
his
peers.
You
can
reach
him
by
email
at [email protected] and
by
tweet
at @WritesForRent.


Bonus Time

Enter
your
email
address
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s

Bonus
&
Salary
Increase
Alerts
.