BREAKING: Milbank Leads The Associate Bonus Race – Above the Law

Woohoo!
Milbank
is
not
messing
around
with
associates’
money.
Fresh
off
the

market-leading
summer
bonuses

(months
later
associates
at
other
firms
are
still
waiting
patiently
for
their
cash),
the
firm
is
leading
on
bonuses
again.
Today,
Milbank
became
the
first
major
Biglaw
firm
to
announce
their
year-end
bonuses.
And
they
are
sure
to
improve
the
spirits
of
associates
there.

The
following
bonus
scale,
which
mirrors
last
year’s,
was
announced
at
the
firm:

Screenshot 2024-11-11 at 5.18.12 PM

The
timing
of
the
announcement
is
in
line
with
what
the
firm
did
last
year
(November
7,
2023
),
but
it
took
three
weeks
for
Cravath
to
announce
their
own
bonuses.
So
the
industry
might
have
a
little
bit
longer
to
wait
for
more
bonus
news.

Associates
in
good
standing
at
Milbank
will
be
get
their
bonuses
by
December
31st.

So,
what’s
going
on
at
at
your
firm?
If
your
firm
announces
year-end
bonuses
(or
FINALLY
matches
those
summer
ones),
please
let
us
know
ASAP,
so
we
can
shout
the
news
from
the
rooftops

let’s
get
the
bonus
party
started.

Remember
everyone,
we
depend
on
your
tips
to
stay
on
top
of
important
bonus
updates,
so
when
your
firm
matches,
please
text
us
(646-820-8477)
or email
us
 (subject
line:
“[Firm
Name]
Matches”).
Please
include
the
memo
if
available.
You
can
take
a
photo
of
the
memo
and
send
it
via
text
or
email
if
you
don’t
want
to
forward
the
original
PDF
or
Word
file.

And
if
you’d
like
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s
Bonus
Alerts
(which
is
the
alert
list
we
also
use
for
salary
announcements),
please
scroll
down
and
enter
your
email
address
in
the
box
below
this
post.
If
you
previously
signed
up
for
the
bonus
alerts,
you
don’t
need
to
do
anything.
You’ll
receive
an
email
notification
within
minutes
of
each
bonus
announcement
that
we
publish.
Thanks
for
all
of
your
help!

Read
the
full
memo
below.

IMG_0020




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].


Bonus Time

Enter
your
email
address
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s

Bonus
&
Salary
Increase
Alerts
.


Mavetera Backtracks On WhatsApp Group Licensing Policy, Calls Her Statement “Malicious Fake News”


Tatenda
Mavetera

The
statement,
which
went
viral
last
week,
outlined
that
WhatsApp
group
administrators
would
need
to
secure
licenses
and
appoint
data
protection
officers.
Reads
the
statement:

The
time
is
ticking
for
organisations
that
collect
first-party
data,
as
you
are
required
by
law
to
have
a
data
protection
licence
and
the
licence
fees
range
from
US$50
to
US$2500.


Furthermore,
a
data
protection
officer
(DPO)
who
is
trained
and
certified
by
POTRAZ
should
be
appointed
by
such
a
licensee
and
the
appointment
should
be
communicated
to
POTRAZ.

Even
churches
that
collect
personal
data
ought
to
have
such
a
licensee
and
appoint
a
DPO.
WhatsApp
group
admins
are
not
spared
too,
if
your
groups
are
meant
for
business,
you
should
as
well
get
a
licence.
Failure
to
comply
attracts
penalties.

However,
in
a
post
on
X
on
Saturday,
Mavetera
labelled
the
viral
LinkedIn
post
as
“malicious
fake
news,”
saying
this
requirement
is
not
applicable
to
players
who
do
not
collect
and
process
Personally
Identifiable
Information
(PII)
for
commercial
or
business
use.
Wrote
Mavetera:

False
claim
of
USD
2500
penalties
for
WhatsApp
Group
Administrators

I
would
like
distance
myself
from
the
malicious
fake
news
of
intentions
by
government
to
licence
or
penalise
WhatsApp
Groups
or
Administrators
of
any
social
media
platform/s
USD
2500.

This
claim
is
not
applicable
especially
to
players
who
do
not
collect
and
process
Personally
Identifiable
Information
(PII)
for
commercial
or
business
use.

Personally
identifiable
information
(PII)
is
any
type
of
data
that
can
be
used
to
identify
someone,
from
their
name
and
address
to
their
phone
number,
passport
information
and
I.D.
number.

The
public
is
encouraged
to
disregard
this
notice
with
the
uttermost
discontent
it
deserves
as
it
is
inconsistent
with
our
legal
provisions
as
espoused
in
Statutory
Instrument
(SI)
155
of
the
2024
Cyber
and
Data
Protection
(Licencing
of
Data
Controllers
and
Appointment
of
Data
Protection
Officers)
Regulations.

On
my
LinkedIn
post,
I
never
expressed
any
intentions
to
licence
or
penalise
WhatsApp
groups
or
Administrators
of
any
social
media
platform/s
which
do
not
collect
and
process
(Personally
Identifiable
Information
(PII)
for
commercial
or
business
use.

I
wish
to
assure
the
public
of
the
government’s
commitment
through
the
Ministry
of
Information
Communication
Technology
Postal
and
Courier
Services
to
accelerate
cyber
and
data
democratisation
and
security
to
ensure
that
No
One
and
No
Place
is
Left
Offline.

This
is
in
line
with
our
overarching
mandate
to
the
constitution
to
promote
access
to
information
for
all
in
a
safe
and
secure
environment.

Journalist
Hopewell
Chin’ono
then
asked
Mavetera
whether
she
was
implying
that
the
LinkedIn
account
which
posted
the
controversial
statement
did
not
belong
to
her.
In
response,
Mavetera
said:

Chin’ono
expressed
dissatisfaction
with
the
response,
suggesting
that
Mavetera
should
have
a
professional
communications
officer
to
ensure
that
policy
matters
are
communicated
clearly
and
accurately. He
wrote:

So
don’t
say
it
was
a
false
claim;
you
said
it,
but
you
are
now
coming
back
with
clarification.

When
you
say
it
was
false,
you
insinuate
that
the
media
lied
when,
in
fact,
it
was
you
who
put
out
the
wrong
information.

My
advice
is
to
have
a
professional
communications
officer;
they
are
trained
for
that
kind
of
work.

You
can’t
be
walking
back
on
your
statements
when
you
are
a
cabinet
minister.

It
embarrasses
the
government,
the
country,
and
the
person
who
appointed
you.

You
should
have
said,
“I
am
sorry,
I
got
things
wrong,
this
is
the
true
position.”

Post
published
in:

Featured

Goromonzi farm robbery suspect arrested after CCTV captured images splashed on social media

HARARE

Police
have
arrested
a
57-year-old
suspect
linked
to
a
recent
armed
robbery
incident
in
which
cash
and
valuable
items
were
seized
from
a
Goromonzi
farm
by
men
whose
images
were
captured
on
CCTV
during
the
heist
and
later
circulated
on
social
media.

The
suspects,
some
wearing
balaclavas,
pounced
on
Pircy
farm
in
the
Mashonaland
East
farming
community
outside
Harare
3
November
this
year
and
held
the
farm
owners
captive
for
some
time
during
the
night.

They
went
on
to
seize
US$3,000
cash
and
various
clothes,
two
speakers,
three
cell
phones,
laptops,
jewellery,
groceries
and
three
firearms.

The
stolen
property
was
estimated
to
be
worth
US$1,000,
according
to
a
police
statement.


Coupled
with
images
of
the
suspects,
police
launched
an
appeal
for
possible
leads
to
the
arrest
of
the
suspects.

In
a
statement
on
Sunday,
police
spokesperson
Commissioner
Paul
Nyathi
confirmed
the
arrest
of
Sarezi
Shonhiwa
following
a
tip-off
by
the
public.

Shonhiwa
was
arrested
at
Zin’anga
Village,
Seke
on
Saturday
by
detectives
from
CID
Homicide,
Harare.

“The
suspect
admitted
to
being
one
of
the
suspects
and
implicated
Godfrey
Mapanzure,
Brian
Chiyanwa,
Tawanda
Manokore
and
Mhofu
(no
further
particulars
known)
as
his
accomplices.

“Investigations
by
the
detectives
revealed
that
Godfrey
Mapanzure
and
Tawanda
Manokore
were
arrested
on
9
November
2024
in
connection
with
a
case
of
armed
robbery
which
occurred
in
Mutorashanga,”
Nyathi
said.

He
added,
“Sarezi
Shonhiwa
and
his
accomplices
are
also
clearing
another
case
of
armed
robbery
which
occurred
on
26
October
2024
along
Christon
Bank
Road,
Christon
Bank,
where
a
Toyota
Rav
4
vehicle,
registration
number
AEE
6525,
a
Star
pistol,
five
cell
phones
and
USD
760.00
cash
were
stolen.”

Nyathi
thanked
the
public
for
volunteering
information
that
led
to
the
arrest
of
the
suspects
and
further
appealed
for
assistance
that
could
lead
to
the
rest
of
the
suspects.

Minister denies plans to impose licences on WhatsApp group admins

HARARE

Information
Communication
Technology
(ICT)
Minister,
Tatenda
Mavetera
has
distanced
herself
from
recent
media
claims 
she
plans,
on
behalf
of
government,
to
impose
mandatory
licence
requirements
on
WhatsApp
group
administrators
and
consequent
fines
of
US$2,500
for
non-compliance.

In
a
statement
she
posted
on
her
X
handle
Saturday,
Mavetera
said
such
penalties
would
only
apply
to
platforms
or
administrators
who
collect
Personally
Identifiable
Information
(PII)
for
business
or
commercial
use.

PII
includes
any
data
that
could
be
used
to
identify
individuals,
such
as
names,
phone
numbers,
or
identification
numbers.

Mavetera
urged
the
public
to
disregard
the
claims,
emphasizing
that
they
were
inconsistent
with
Zimbabwe’s
legal
framework,
particularly
the
Cyber
and
Data
Protection
(Licensing
of
Data
Controllers
and
Appointment
of
Data
Protection
Officers)
Regulations
under
Statutory
Instrument
(SI)
155
of
2024.


“I
would
like
to
distance
myself
from
the
malicious
fake
news
about
the
government’s
intentions
to
license
or
penalize
WhatsApp
groups
or
administrators
of
any
social
media
platform
with
fines
of
up
to
USD2,500,”
Mavetera
said.

“This
claim
is
not
applicable,
especially
to
players
who
do
not
collect
or
process
Personally
Identifiable
Information
(PII)
for
commercial
or
business
use.
Personally
Identifiable
Information
(PII)
is
any
data
that
can
be
used
to
identify
someone,
from
their
name
and
address
to
their
phone
number,
passport
information,
and
ID
number.

“I
have
never
expressed
any
intentions
to
license
or
penalize
WhatsApp
groups
or
administrators
of
any
social
media
platform
that
do
not
collect
and
process
PII
for
commercial
or
business
use.”

Reports
of
a
government
plan
to
introduce
licence
requirements
on
private
WhatsApp
groups
were
met
with
outrage
from
the
public
which
accused
the
state
of
attempts
to
criminalise
and
commodify
free
speech.

Bailiffs attach Gappah properties after she lost defamation battle with Mahere

HARARE

Bailiffs
have
attached
the
property
of
author
Petina
Gappah
worth
US$14,700
after
she
lost
a
defamation
lawsuit
against
lawyer
Fadzayi
Mahere.

Mahere
was
awarded
US$18,000
in
damages
by
the
Harare
High
Court
in
August
after
Gappah,
writing
on
X,
formerly
Twitter,
made
a
series
of
defamatory
statements
including
that
the
former
Mt
Pleasant
MP
did
not
qualify
for
enrolment
at
the
University
of
Zimbabwe
but
was
accepted
only
because
her
father,
then
a
permanent
secretary
in
government,
exerted
his
influence;
that
she
wrote
the
essay
that
enabled
Mahere
to
be
admitted
into
Cambridge
University
for
her
Master’s
Degree
and
that
Mahere
tried
to
seduce
her
ex-partner.

Gappah
issued
a
public
statement
and
apology
in
May
saying
she
wished
to
“fully
and
unequivocally
retract
all
the
statements”
she
made
about
Mahere
and
offered
to
donate
to
a
charity
of
Mahere’s
choosing
“in
order
to
bring
a
conclusive
end
to
the
legal
action.”

Mahere
said
the
apology
was
not
genuine
and
pressed
on
with
her
claim
of
US$50,000,
before
a
judge
awarded
her
US$18,000.


Documents
seen
by
ZimLive
show
that
the
Sheriff
visited
Gappah’s
Highlands
property
and
attached
several
items
including
a
refrigerator
and
dining
suite
on
November
6.
The
value
of
the
property
fell
short
of
US$18,000.

It
is
the
latest
chapter
in
a
“long,
arduous
and
acrimonious”
legal
battle
between
the
two
lawyers,
as
Justice
Joseph
Martin
Mafusire
observed
in
his
judgement.

Justice
Mafusire
found
that
Gappah’s
defence
to
the
“vile
and
persistent”
defamation
was
laced
with
“bitterness
and
malice”
as
he
ruled
in
Mahere’s
favour.

Gappah,
an
international
trade
lawyer,
is
the
author
of
two
novels, Out
of
Darkness,
Shining
Light
;
and The
Book
of
Memory
;
and
two
short
story
collections, Rotten
Row
 and An
Elegy
for
Easterly
.

Former
Mt
Pleasant
MP
Mahere
is
an
advocate
in
Zimbabwe’s
superior
courts
and
a
former
spokesperson
of
the
Citizens
Coalition
for
Change.

Kariba records cholera cases


Gumbochuma
confirmed
that
the
district’s
medical
team
is
actively
responding
to
the
emergency,
providing
treatment
to
those
affected.

In
a
statement
delivered
to
community
leaders,
Gumbochuma
emphasized
the
importance
of
hygiene
practices
during
this
crisis.

“We
urge
our
people
to
practice
best
hygiene
standards
and
to
visit
the
nearest
clinic
whenever
they
feel
unwell,”
he
said.

This
call
for
vigilance
comes
as
health
officials
work
to
contain
the
outbreak
and
prevent
further
infections.
In
light
of
the
situation,
the
District
Civil
Protection
has
appealed
for
assistance
from
corporates,
NGOs,
individuals,
and
religious
organizations.

“Let’s
all
remain
calm
during
this
trying
time,”
Gumbochuma
urged,
highlighting
the
community’s
resilience
and
the
need
for
collective
action.
The
district
has
identified
several
immediate
needs
to
support
the
ongoing
response
efforts,
including
food
for
the
camp,
tents
for
temporary
shelter,
detergents
to
maintain
hygiene,
fuel
for
the
Emergency
Health
Teams
(EHTs)
and
district
medical
personnel,
and
borehole
leather
cups
and
accessories.
Gumbochuma
expressed
gratitude
for
any
contributions.

“Any
other
items
that
can
be
of
assistance
will
be
greatly
appreciated.”

As
the
district
continues
to
battle
this
public
health
challenge,
the
cooperation
and
support
of
the
community
will
be
crucial
in
ensuring
the
safety
and
well-being
of
all
residents
of
Gache
Gache.



Newsday

Post
published
in:

Featured

Wait, Is The Fifth Circuit The Reasonable One Here? – See Also – Above the Law




<br /> Wait,<br /> Is<br /> The<br /> Fifth<br /> Circuit<br /> The<br /> Reasonable<br /> One<br /> Here?<br /> –<br /> See<br /> Also<br /> –<br /> Above<br /> the<br /> Law


























From Cost Center To Command Center: How Legal Ops Leads With Resilience – Above the Law


Legal
Operations
has
always
been
the backbone
of
business
resilience,
establishing
the
governance
structures
and
workflows
that
keep
organizations
running
smoothly,
no
matter
the
challenges.


As
disruptions

from
cybersecurity
risks
to
economic
uncertainty

become
more
frequent
and
complex,
Legal
Ops
teams
are
well-positioned
to
lead
the
development
of
sustainable,
resilient
frameworks
that
support
long-term
continuity
and
growth.


From
Cost
Center
to
Strategic
Partner
Through
Collaboration


Legal
departments
have
profoundly
shifted from
being
perceived
as
cost
centers
to
becoming strategic
business
partners that
drive
operational
efficiency.


According
to



Thomson
Reuters’ 
2024
State
of
the
Corporate
Law
Department
 report
,
this
transition
requires
a
focus
on technology
adoption,
risk
management,
and
internal
efficiencies that
align
legal
efforts
with
broader
business
priorities
.
Legal
Ops
professionals
are
leading
this
transformation,
ensuring
resilience
is
not
a
reactive
response
to
crises
but
an embedded
part
of
daily
operations.


One
key
element
in
this
evolution
is
breaking
down silos both
within
and
between
departments.
In
many
organizations,
fragmented
planning
leads
to
disconnected
resilience
strategies,
limiting
the
ability
to
respond
effectively
to
disruptions.
Legal
Ops,
however,
operates
at
the intersection
of
people,
processes,
and
technology,
making
it
uniquely
suited
to align
business
units.
By
coordinating
with
IT,
finance,
procurement,
and
external
partners,
Legal
Ops
creates a
unified
approach to
resilience.


At
UpLevel
Ops,
we’ve
seen
the
value
of cross-functional
steering
committees,
where
Legal
Ops
plays
a
central
role
in
aligning
departmental
efforts
around
shared
objectives.
Legal
Ops
professionals
also
act
as translators,
transforming
complex
legal
and
regulatory
frameworks
into
clear,
actionable
steps
that
other
business
units
can
quickly
implement.
This
collaborative
leadership
ensures
that
resilience
strategies
are
not
simply
theoretical
plans
but
practical,
coordinated
efforts
that
drive business
continuity
and
growth.


Research
shows
that
legal
teams
driving
this
transformation
can
create
measurable
value

beyond
cost
control

by
focusing
on
efficiency
metrics,
such
as
faster
contract
turnarounds,
improved
compliance
monitoring,
and
reduced
reliance
on
outside
counsel
​​.


This
shift
from
a
cost-based
model
to
a
value-driven
approach
ensures
that
Legal
is
viewed
not
as
a
passive
support
function
but
as
a critical
enabler
of
business
strategy
and
driver
of
efficiency. 


Managing
Third-Party
and
Outside
Counsel
Risks
for
Operational
Continuity


As
businesses
increasingly
rely
on
vendors
and
external
partners,
third-party
risk
management has
emerged
as
a
critical
component
of
resilience.
Disruptions
within
a
vendor’s
operations
can
create
ripple
effects,
impacting
business
continuity. Legal
Ops
professionals are
uniquely
equipped
to
manage
these
risks,
ensuring
vendors
adhere
to compliance
standards,
meet
disruption
tolerance
thresholds,
and
align
with
strategic
business
goals.


Outside
Counsel
(OC)
management
is
having
a
moment.
Once
viewed
as
a
back-office
function,
it’s
gaining
attention
as
a
strategic
priority
for
Legal
Ops.
Managing
external
law
firms
is
no
longer
about
cost
control

it’s
about
ensuring
performance,
efficiency,
and
seamless
service
delivery
that
aligns
with
broader
departmental
and
business
goals.


Legal
Ops
plays
a critical
role in
actively
overseeing
these
relationships
in
today’s
landscape.
Without
proper
management,
outside
counsel
engagements
can
quickly
spiral,
leading
to unexpected
budget
overruns,
operational
delays,
and
inconsistent
legal
support just
when
it’s
needed
most.
The
growing
complexity
of
legal
work
and
increased
reliance
on
external
firms
make proactive
OC
management
essential for
maintaining
financial
control
and
operational
continuity.


At
UpLevel
Ops,
we’ve
found
that
a
well-designed
outside
counsel
management
program
can
make
all
the
difference.
This
includes
defining
alternative
fee
arrangements
(AFAs)
to
control
costs,
conducting
regular
billing
audits
to
avoid
surprises,
and
establishing
backup
relationships
to
ensure
service
continuity
if
primary
firms
are
unavailable.
Beyond
financial
controls,
Legal
Ops
can
also
improve
the
collaboration
between
in-house
teams
and
law
firms,
fostering
stronger
relationships
and
aligning
external
support
with
business
priorities. 


Rather
than
taking
a
reactive
approach,
Legal
Ops
leaders
proactively
engage
vendors
and
outside
counsel
in
joint
planning
sessions.
These
meetings
are
essential
to
align
expectations
and
simulate
potential
disruptions

such
as
unexpected
litigation
or
compliance
crises.
By
identifying
risks
early
and
building
collaborative
playbooks,
Legal
Ops
ensures
vendors
and
law
firms
are
ready
to
deliver
when
needed.


This strategic
approach
to
vendor
and
outside
counsel
management mitigates
risks
and
builds
resilience.
By
aligning
external
partners
with
the
company’s
operational
and
financial
goals,
Legal
Ops
ensures
that
the
organization
can
maintain
continuity,
even
in
the
face
of
unforeseen
disruptions.


Building
Resilience
Through
Technology
and
AI


Technology
lies
at
the
heart
of
modern
resilience
frameworks.
Legal
Ops
is
uniquely
positioned
to
drive
the
adoption
of
generative
AI
(GAI)
and
other
emerging
technologies,
thanks
to
its
role
at
the
intersection
of
people,
processes,
and
technology.
Several
of
our
clients’
Legal
teams
already
use
AI-powered
tools

such
as
automated
FAQs,
e-billing
platforms,
and
contract
lifecycle
management
systems

to
streamline
operations
and
free
up
resources
for
more
strategic
tasks
.


GAI
offers
immense
potential
to
further
enhance
resilience.
By automating
routine
processes,
AI
tools
allow
legal
professionals
to
focus
on
high-value
work,
such
as
managing
complex
litigation
or
regulatory
compliance.
Real-time
AI
insights
also
help
teams anticipate
and
mitigate
risks before
they
become
disruptive.
For
example,
automated
systems
can
monitor
regulatory
changes
or
security
alerts,
providing
early
warnings
that
enable
proactive
action.


Thomson
Reuters
reports
that
departments
integrating
AI
tools
reduce
their
reliance
on
outside
counsel,
lower
legal
spend,
and
improve
internal
efficiency
.
Legal
Ops
leaders
are
critical
to
successfully
adopting
and
integrating
these
technologies,
ensuring
that
AI
initiatives
align
with
business
goals
and
deliver
measurable
value.
This
focus
on
technology-driven
resilience
makes
Legal
Ops
a
powerful
force
that
enables
organizations
to adapt
and
thrive in
uncertain
times.


Resilience
Is
a
Continuous
Journey


Legal
operations
has
always
been
a
key
driver
of
business
continuity,
creating
systems
and
frameworks
that
allow
organizations
to
operate
efficiently,
even
in
challenging
conditions.
As
risks
grow
more
complex,
Legal
Ops
is
uniquely
positioned
to
lead
the
development
of
sustainable
resilience
strategies
that
align
with
business
priorities.
By
focusing
on
collaboration,
technology
integration,
and
proactive
vendor
management,
Legal
Ops
ensures
resilience
becomes
a
core
part
of
daily
operations

not
just
a
response
to
disruptions.


Resilience
isn’t
about
surviving
disruptions

it’s
about
embracing
change
and
using
it
as
an
opportunity
to
build
better
systems.
The
legal
departments
that
succeed
will
continuously
refine
their
processes,
align
with
business
goals,
and
leverage
technology
to
stay
ahead
of
evolving
risks.
Remember
that
resilience
isn’t
a
destination

it’s
an
ongoing
journey
that
requires
a
commitment
to
operational
excellence.





SCorey Mar 2024Stephanie
 Corey is
a
co-founder
and
CEO
of
UpLevel
Ops. Stephanie also
co-founded
LINK
(Legal
Innovators
Network),
a
legal
operations
organization
exclusively
for
experienced,
in-house
professionals.
She
previously
founded
the
legal
operations
trade
organization
CLOC
(Corporate
Legal
Operations
Consortium)
and
is
a
former
executive
member.
Please
feel
free
to contact
and
connect
with
her
on
LinkedIn
.