Former Biglaw Partner Writes Biting Novel Dishing On What’s Wrong With The Profession – Above the Law

Join
me
as
I
chat
with

Luba
Shur
,
author
of
the
forthcoming
novel

Rule
23
,
about
her
journey
from
law
to
novelist.
Discover
her
insights
on
legal
ethics,
the
myth
of
class
actions,
and
how
she
balances
writing
with
a
legal
career.
A
must-listen
for
aspiring
lawyer-authors!


Highlights

  • Intersection
    of
    reality
    and
    fantasy
    in
    career
    choice
  • Early
    reading
    and
    legal
    career
    expectations
  • Surprising
    twists
    and
    interesting
    outcomes
    in
    legal
    career
  • Balancing
    writing
    and
    legal
    career
  • Rule
    23
    as
    a
    skewer
    of
    legal
    profession
    dysfunction
  • Inspiration
    behind
    the
    character
    Vera
  • Creating
    compelling
    flawed
    characters
  • Challenges
    of
    legal
    ethics
    and
    ambition
  • Significance
    of
    mentorship
    and
    legal
    education
    critique
  • Reality
    of
    Rule
    23
    and
    litigation
    process
  • Future
    writing
    projects
    exploring
    startup
    culture
  • Advice
    for
    balancing
    legal
    careers
    with
    writing

The
Jabot
podcast
is
an
offshoot
of
the
Above
the
Law
brand
focused
on
the
challenges
women,
people
of
color,
LGBTQIA,
and
other
diverse
populations
face
in
the
legal
industry.
Our
name
comes
from
none
other
than
the
Notorious
Ruth
Bader
Ginsburg
and
the
jabot
(decorative
collar)
she
wore
when
delivering
dissents
from
the
bench.
It’s
a
reminder
that
even
when
we
aren’t
winning,
we’re
still
a
powerful
force
to
be
reckoned
with.

Happy
listening!




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].

J&J Backs Down From 340B Rebates, But Maintains They’re ‘Legally Permissible’ Per Statute – MedCity News

The
federal
340B
program
has
become
a
thorn
in
the
side
of
pharmaceutical
companies,
who
point
to
the
drug
discount
program’s
sprawling
growth
amid
what
they
contend
is
lack
of
oversight.
After
initially
proposing
changes
to
the
way
the
company
offers
drugs
under
this
program,
Johnson
&
Johnson
has
backed
down,
averting
further
confrontation
with
federal
officials
and
hospitals
on
the
matter.
For
now.

When
the
340B
program
was
established
in
1992,
the
intent
was
to
help
underserved
communities.
Under
the
program,
eligible
hospitals
and
clinics
serving
low-income
and
uninsured
patients
may
purchase
outpatient
prescription
medications
at
discounts
of
up
to
50%.
In
August,
J&J
proposed
a
major
change.
Starting
on
Oct.
15,
entities
covered
under
340B
would
have
to
pay
full
price,
then
make
a
claims
submission
for
a
rebate.
This
proposal
would
apply
to
two
drugs,
the
plaque
psoriasis
medication
Stelara
and
the
blood
thinner
Xarelto.

The
Health
Resources
and
Services
Administration
(HRSA),
which
administers
the
340B
program,
told
J&J
the
proposed
changes
are

“inconsistent”
with
the
statute

and
would
need
approval
before
they
could
take
effect.
In
a

Sept.
27
letter

to
J&J,
HRSA
Administrator
Carole
Johnson
noted
that
the
company
had
not
requested
such
approval
and
proceeding
with
the
rebate
change
would
violate
the
340B
statute.
The
administrator
added
that
implementations
of
the
rebates
would
lead
to
termination
of
the
company’s
pharmaceutical
pricing
agreement
and
a
referral
to
the
Department
Health
and
Human
Services’
Office
of
the
Inspector
General.

In
a
letter
of
response,
J&J
maintained
that
the
statute
allows
for
rebates
as
a
mechanism
for
drug
manufacturers
to
offer
the
340B
price
to
covered
entities.
Furthermore,
the
company
said
its
rebate
proposal
will
target
duplicate
discounts,
transactions
in
which
a
covered
entity
receives
a
340B
discount
and
then
submits
a
claim
for
a
Medicaid
rebate

a
violation
of
the
statute.
J&J
says
audits
to
uncover
such
duplicates
have
not
solved
the
problem.

“As
HRSA
knows,
J&J’s
efforts
to
identify
and
address
program
abuse
through
HRSA-approved
audits
of
covered
entities
have
been
thwarted;
nearly
all
of
the
entities
for
whom
HRSA
approved
J&J
audit
requests
have
violated
federal
law
by
refusing
to
cooperate,”
the
company’s
letter
said.
“Some
have
gone
so
far
as
to
file
suit
against
HRSA
to
invalidate
the
audit
approvals.
Plainly,
audits
alone
are
not
a
viable
means
for
J&J
to
obtain
information
necessary
to
detect
unlawful
duplicate
discounts
and
diversion
as
they
occur.”

Nevertheless,
J&J
said
HRSA’s
threat
to
terminate
the
company’s
participation
in
the
program
would
have
the
effect
of
cutting
off
millions
of
Medicare
and
Medicaid
patients
from
necessary
medicines.
The
company’s
commitment
to
these
patients
leaves
it
“no
choice
but
to
forego
implementation
of
the
rebate
model
pending
resolution
of
these
issues.”
J&J
hints
that
litigation
could
be
a
next
step.
The
company
says
it
continues
to
believe
its
rebate
model
is
“legally
permissible”
and
“sorely
needed”
for
drugmakers
to
comply
with
requirements
of
both
the
Inflation
Reduction
Act
and
the
340B
statute.

“J&J
reserves
all
of
its
legal
rights
with
respect
to
this
matter,”
the
company
said.

In
other
regulatory
news,
we
have
FDA
decisions
for
drugs
(mostly
approvals),
some
clinical
holds,
and
one
product
withdrawal.
Here’s
a
recap
of
recent
regulatory
developments:


Regulatory
Decisions


—Exact
Sciences’

Cologuard
Plus
now
has
FDA
approval
.
The
product
is
a
next-generation
version
of
Cologuard,
the
company’s
non-invasive
colorectal
cancer
test.

Cologuard
Plus
offers
greater
sensitivity
for
colorectal
cancer
and
advanced
precancerous
lesions.
Like
Cologuard,
Cologuard
Plus
is
approved
for
use
in
adults
age
45
and
older
who
are
at
average
risk
of
colorectal
cancer.
Exact
Sciences
said
it
expects
to
launch
this
new
test
in
2025.


—Partners
Fresenius
Kabi
and
Formycon
received

FDA
approval
for
Otulfi
,
a
biosimilar
referencing
the
Johnson
&
Johnson
biologic
drug
Stelara.

The
regulatory
decision
for
Otulfi
covers
all
of
the
approved
uses
of
Stelara,
which
include
Crohn’s
disease,
ulcerative
colitis,
moderate-to-severe
plaque
psoriasis,
and
active
psoriatic
arthritis.
Separately,
the

European
Union
approved
Otulfi

in
late
September.
Otulfi
will
jostle
for
market
share
with
Pyzchiva
from
Samsung
Bioepis
and
Sandoz,
and
Wezlana
from
Amgen,
two
Stelara
biosimilars
that
have
received
FDA
approvals
in
the
past
year.


—Eli
Lilly
drug

Retevmo
is
now
FDA
approved

for
treating
adults
and
pediatric
patients
age
2
and
older
who
have
advanced
cases
of
medullary
thyroid
cancer
carrying
a
RET
mutation.

The
drug
has
been
available
in
this
indication
under
accelerated
approval.
The
latest
regulatory
decision
converts
Retevmo’s
status
to
traditional
approval.


—Dupixent,
a
blockbuster
immunology
drug
from
Sanofi
and
Regeneron
Pharmaceuticals,

expanded
its
approved
uses
to
include
chronic
obstructive
pulmonary
disease
(COPD)
.

Dupixent
is
the
first
FDA-approved
biological
treatment
for
COPD.
Dupixent
approved
uses
now
span
six
dermatological
and
respiratory
conditions.


FDA
approval
of
Bristol
Myers
Squibb
drug
Cobenfy

makes
the
drug
the
first
novel
schizophrenia
drug
in
decades.

The
twice-daily
capsule
is
designed
to
target
a
different
receptor
than
currently
available
antipsychotic
drugs,
offering
better
efficacy
and
tolerability.
Cobenfy
comes
from
Karuna
Therapeutics,
which
BMS
acquired
for
$14
billion.


—Eli
Lilly
drug

Kisunla
is
now
approved
in
Japan

for
the
treatment
of
patients
in
the
early
stages
of
Alzheimer’s
disease.

Kisunla
is
part
of
a
class
of
antibody
drugs
that
work
by
reducing
plaques
of
amyloid
proteins
that
form
in
the
brains
of
Alzheimer’s
patients.
Japan
marks
the
second
major
market
approval
for

Kisunla,
which
was
approved
by
the
FDA
in
July
.


—In
other
Japanese
regulatory
news,
Takeda
Pharmaceutical’s

Fruzaqla
won
approval

for
the
treatment
of
advanced
or
recurrent
colorectal
cancer.

The
Japanese
pharma
giant
acquired
the
oral
small
molecule
from
Hutchmed
in
early
2023.
Nearly
a
year
ago,
the

FDA
approved
the
drug
for
treating
colorectal
cancer
.


—Ipsen
landed

European
Union
approval
for
Kayfanda

as
a
treatment
for
cholestatic
pruritus
(severe
itching)
associated
with
the
rare
liver
disease
Alagille
syndrome.

The
approval
was
made
under
“exceptional
circumstances”
that
permits
marketing
authorization
when
comprehensive
efficacy
and
safety
data
are
not
available.
The

Ipsen
drug
won
FDA
approval
for
Alagille
patients
last
year
;
in
the
U.S.,
the
once-daily
capsule
is
marketed
as
Bylvay.
Ipsen
added
the
drug
to
its
pipeline
via
its

$952
million
acquisition
of
Albireo
.


—Ipsen’s
rare
liver
disease
portfolio
also
welcomed

European
Union
approval
of
Iqirvo

for
treating
primary
biliary
cholangitis
(PBC),
a
chronic
disorder
that
damages
the
liver’s
bile
ducts.

The
approval
covers
use
of
the
once-daily
pill
in
combination
with
ursodeoxycholic
acid
(UDCA)
for
patients
whose
disease
does
not
adequately
respond
to
that
standard
of
care
drug.
Iqirvo
may
be
used
as
a
monotherapy
for
patients
who
cannot
tolerate
UDCA.
European
approval
comes
nearly
four
months
after
the

FDA
greenlit
Iqirvo
for
PBC
.


Zevra
Therapeutics
drug
Miplyffa
became
the
first
FDA-approved
treatment
for
Niemann-Pick
disease
type
C
,
a
rare
inherited
lysosomal
storage
disorder
that
can
become
fatal
by
the
time
patients
reach
adolescence.

The
approval
specifically
covers
the
neurological
effects
of
the
disease.
Zevra
acquired
the
rights
to
Miplyffa
from
Orphazyme,
which
failed
to
win
FDA
approval
for
the
small
molecule
in
2021.


—Days
after
Miplyffa’s
approval,
the

FDA
approved
levacetylleucine
,
brand
name
Aqneursa,

making
the
drug
from
privately
held
IntraBio
the
second
approved
treatment
for
Niemann-Pick
disease
type
C.
Similar
to
Miplyffa,
the
regulatory
decision
for
the
IntraBio
drug
covers
the
treatment
of
neurological
effects
of
the
rare
disease.


—The
European
Union

approved
Astellas
drug
zolbetuximab
,
brand
name
Vyloy,
as
a
treatment
for
advanced
gastric
and
gastroesophageal
junction
cancer.

The
approval
covers
use
of
the
drug
in
combination
with
chemotherapy.
The

FDA
turned
down

Astellas’s
submission
for
the
drug
early
this
year,
citing
manufacturing
issues.
Astellas
resubmitted
its
application,
which
now
has
a

Nov.
9
target
date

for
a
regulatory
decision.


—FluMist,
an
intranasally
dosed
influenza
vaccine
that’s
been
available
in
the
U.S.
for
two
decades,
is
now

FDA-approved
for
self-
or
caregiver
administration
.

The
regulatory
decision
makes
the
AstraZeneca
product
the
first
influenza
vaccine
that
does
not
need
to
be
given
by
a
healthcare
provider.
For
those
choosing
this
option,
the
vaccine
will
be
available
through
a
third-party
pharmacy
following
a
screening
and
eligibility
assessment
completed
when
patients
order
the
vaccine.


—The
FDA

rejected
Vanda
Pharmaceuticals’
tradipitant

as
a
treatment
of
gastroparesis.

This
delayed
gastric
emptying
is
associated
with
diabetes
but
can
also
develop
in
those
who
do
not
have
diabetes.
According
to
Vanda,
the
FDA
disregarded
clinical
evidence
for
the
drug
and
asked
the
company
to
conduct
additional
clinical
testing.
The
company
said
it
still
plans
to
seek
marketing
authorization
for
this
drug.
A
separate
new
drug
application
is
also
planned
for
tradipitant
later
this
year
for
preventing
vomiting
from
motion
sickness.


—An
experimental
Applied
Therapeutics
drug
for
the
rare
genetic
metabolic
disease
classic
galactosemia
will
not
be
discussed
by
an
FDA
advisory
committee.

After
completing
a
late-cycle
review
meeting,
the
agency
told
the
company
a
meeting
was

no
longer
needed

for
the
drug,
govorestat.
The
Nov.
28
target
date
for
a
regulatory
decision
still
stands.


—The

FDA
authorized

the
first
over-the-counter
hearing
aid
software.

Called
Hearing
Aid
Feature,
this
Apple
software
is
compatible
with
the
company’s
AirPods
Pro
headphones.
The
software
was
reviewed
through
the
regulator’s
De
Novo
premarket
review
pathway.
FDA
authorization
is
based
on
a
clinical
trial
enrolling
118
patients
with
mild-to-moderate
hearing
loss.
Results
showed
those
who
self-fit
the
software
and
device
achieved
similar
benefit
as
those
who
received
a
professional
fitting.


Eli
Lilly
won
FDA
approval
for
lebrikizumab,
brand
name
Ebglyss,

a
new
treatment
for
atopic
dermatitis.

It
will
compete
with
biologic
drugs
Dupixent
from
Sanofi
and
Regeneron
Pharmaceuticals,
and
Adbry
from
LEO
Pharma.
Compared
to
those
every-other-week
injectable
drugs,
Lilly’s
new
product
offers
patients
less
burdensome
once-monthly
maintenance
dosing.


Roche
landed
FDA
approvals
for
subcutaneously
injectable
drugs
that
were
originally
developed
as
intravenous
infusions
.

Tecentriq
Hybreza
is
the
injectable
version
of
the
cancer
immunotherapy
Tecentriq;
Ocrevus
Zunovo
is
the
injectable
version
of
the
multiple
sclerosis
drug
Ocrevus.
Both
drugs
employ
drug
delivery
technology
from
Halozyme
that
enables
biologic
drugs
to
be
administered
as
injections.


Travere
Therapeutics
drug
Filspari
converted
its
accelerated
approval
into
a
full
FDA
approval

for
the
treatment
of
the
rare
kidney
disease
immunoglobulin
A
nephropathy.

The
regulatory
decision
came
nearly
a
year
after
Travere
reported
the
drug
narrowly
failed
its
Phase
3
confirmatory
study.
The
approval
is
based
on
longer-term
data
showing
the
once-daily
pill
significantly
slowed
the
kidney
function
decline.


One
Clinical
Hold
Placed,
Two
Lifted


—Following
the
report
of
patient
deaths,
the
FDA
formally
placed
a

clinical
hold
on
zetomipzomib
,
a
Kezar
Life
Sciences
drug
in
development
for
treating
lupus
nephritis.

Kezar
had

voluntarily
stopped

dosing
and
enrollment
in
the
study
after
emerging
safety
data
showed
four
Grade
5
(fatal)
serious
adverse
events
over
the
course
of
the
study
so
far.
The
company
said
that
three
of
those
fatalities
showed
a
common
pattern
of
symptoms
and
proximity
to
dosing;
additional
non-fatal
complications
also
showed
a
proximity
to
dosing.


—The
FDA

lifted
a
clinical
hold

on
Biomea
Fusion’s
Phase
1/2
clinical
trial
testing
BMF-219
in
type
1
and
type
2
diabetes.

Redwood
City,
California-based
Biomea
said
review
of
the
clinical
data
to
date
found
that
concerning
safety
signals
observed
in
the
Phase
2a
escalation
study
did
not
translate
to
the
larger
Phase
2b
expansion
study.
BMF-219
is
a
small
molecule
that
forms
a
covalent
bond
and
inhibits
menin,
a
protein
thought
to
suppress
the
pancreatic
beta
cells
that
produce
and
secrete
insulin.


—The
FDA

removed
the
partial
clinical
hold

placed
on
an
Avidity
Biosciences’
delpacibart
etedesiran,
or
del-disiran,
an
RNA
therapy

in
development
for
the
rare
muscular
disorder
myotonic
dystrophy
type
1.
The
partial
hold
was
placed
in
2022
following
the
report
of
a
serious
adverse
event
in
a
single
patient.
Del-disiran
is
currently
in
Phase
3
testing.


A
Rare
Disease
Drug
Withdrawal


—Pfizer
is

voluntarily
withdrawing
Oxbryta

from
the
market
and
discontinuing
all
clinical
tests
of
the
drug,
which
won
accelerated
FDA
approval
for
sickle
cell
disease
in
2019.

The
pharma
giant
said
its
decision
is
based
on
the
totality
of
data
now
indicating
higher
rates
of
complications
and
deaths
in
patients
treated
with
the
oral
drug.
The

FDA
issued
an
alert

about
the
withdrawal
and
said
it
has
been
conducting
its
own
safety
review
of
postmarketing
data.
When
the
review
concludes,
the
agency
said
it
will
communicate
additional
findings,
if
necessary.
Oxbryta
was
the
centerpiece
of

Pfizer’s
$5.4
billion
acquisition
of
Global
Blood
Therapeutics

in
2022.


Photo:
Mario
Tama,
Getty
Images

Morning Docket: 10.08.24 – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Antonio
Perez

Pool
via
Getty
Images)

*
Supreme
Court
decides
to
keep
R.
Kelly
trapped
in
a
closet.
[

Reuters]

*
Georgia
Supreme
Court
reinstates
6-week
abortion
ban
while
it
considers
appeal.
Dissent
points
out
that
the
majority
couldn’t
come
up
with
any
basis
for
this
outside
of
the
underlying
merits
arguments.
[Washington
Post
]

*
Quantum
computing
will
require
upping
your
cybersecurity
game.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
2
Live
Crew
are
trying
to
get
back
the
rights
to
their
music

which

other
artists
have
had
to
do


but
the
label
is
making
the
novel
argument
that
the
group
was
making
works
for
hire
and
aren’t
eligible
for
the
copyright
clawback.
[Law360]

*
Most
in-house
counsel
don’t
see
AI
as
“transformative.”
Which
is
a
weird
word
to
survey
because
what
does
that
even
mean?
[Corporate
Counsel
]

*
Another
Deshaun
Watson
lawsuit
intercepted
before
trial.
[The
Athletic
]

*
Judge
facing
ethics
inquiry
for
failing
to
be
“patient,
dignified
or
courteous.”
[ABA
Journal
]

Residents win US$38 000 compensation over COVID-19 national lockdown brutality


Sanyatwe
and
Hon.
Muchinguri
stood
trial
at
Shurugwi
Magistrates
Court
after
the
four
residents
namely Grant
Zinyuke
,
who
is
employed
at
Shurugwi
Hospital, Moreblessing
Ncube
,
who
is
self-employed, Batler
Jabangwe
,
an
employee
of
Shurugwi
City
Council
and Mavhuto
Kachepa
,
who
is
self-employed,
sued
the
duo,
demanding
payment
of
compensation
for
violation
of
their
rights,
when
they
were
brutally
assaulted
in
August
2021
by
some
soldiers,
who
were
enforcing
the
national
lockdown
imposed
by
government
in
a
bid
to
curb
the
spread
of
coronavirus.

In
summons
filed
at
Shurugwi
Magistrates
Court, Zinyuke, Ncube, Jabangwe and Kachepa,
argued
that
the
conduct
of
the
soldiers,
who
at
all
material
times
were
acting
within
their
course
and
scope
of
their
employment
as
duly
attested
members
of
ZNA
and
under
the
control
or
instructions
of
Sanyatwe
and
Hon.
Muchinguri,
who
were
held
vicariously
liable
for
their
actions,
was
unlawful.

The
residents,
who
were
represented
by Prisca
Dube
 and Jabulani
Mhlanga
 of Zimbabwe
Lawyers
for
Human
Rights
,
argued
that
the
soldiers
unlawfully,
wrongfully
and
without
just
cause,
assaulted
them
resulting
in
them
sustaining
several
injuries
on
their
bodies.

In
the
case
of
Zinyuke,
he
sustained
some
injuries
which
include
swelling
on
the
forehead,
lacerations
on
the
upper
lip
and
nose,
bruises
on
his
back
and
losing
some
of
his
teeth
and
had
to
seek
medical
treatment.

Dube
and
Mhlanga
told
Shurugwi
Magistrate Patricia
Gwetsayi
,
who
presided
over
the
trial
of
Sanyatwe
and
Hon.
Muchinguri,
that Ncube
sustained
severe
swelling
on
his
face,
forearms
and
bruises
all
over
his
back,
when
he
was
assaulted
by
some
soldiers
on
1
August
2021,
for
allegedly
being
outside
his
residence
buying
airtime
so
as
to
get
an
update
on
the
health
status
of
his
ailing
mother.

Jabangwe,
an
employee
of
Shurugwi
City
Council,
was
assaulted
all
over
his
body
by
soldiers,
who
saw
him
while
coming
from
executing
his
duties
of
opening
water
taps
at
Makusha
shopping
centre
and
who
accused
him
of
wandering
around.

As
a
result
of
the
assault
by
the
soldiers,
Jabangwe
sustained
injuries
on
the
right
side
of
his
back
and
on
his
left
leg,
which
injury
makes
it
difficult
for
him
to
wear
closed
shoes
to
date
and
remains
severely
traumatised
by
the
incident.

In
the
case
of
Kachepa,
the
lawyers
stated
that
he
was
assaulted
by
soldiers,
whom
he
met
when
he
was
on
his
way
home
from
a
beer
retail
outlet,
who
confronted
him
and
without
any
provocation
or
warning,
used
guns
and
broke
his
right
leg
in
two
spots.
While
he
was
lying
on
the
ground,
some
soldiers
assaulted
him
all
over
his
body
and
he
sustained
two
severe
fractures
on
the
right
leg,
swelling
all
over
the
body,
lacerations
on
the
arms
and
some
bruises
on
his
body.

Dube
and
Mhlanga
argued
that such
conduct
by
soldiers
against
the
Shurugwi
residents,
was
cruel,
inhuman
and
degrading
treatment
punishment,
which
left
them
traumatised,
anxious
and
in
shock.

Recently, Magistrate
Gwetsayi
ordered
Sanyatwe
and
Hon.
Muchinguri
to
pay
Zinyuke
US$10
000,
US$12
000
to Mavhuto,
US$8
000
to
Jabangwe
and
US$8
000
to
Ncube,
as
compensation
for damages
for
pain
and
suffering,
trauma
and
nervous
shock
and
for
medical
expenses,
which
they
incurred
while
seeking
treatment.

Post
published
in:

Featured

In Fight Against Leprosy, A Catholic Center In Zimbabwe Assists Those Afflicted With The Disease

Zimbabwe’s
Mutemwa
Leprosy
Care
Centre
is
home
to
34
patients
living
with
an
array
of
deadly
diseases,
such
as
AIDS,
as
well
as
mental
and
physical
disabilities.
The
center
is
supported
by
the
John
Bradburne
Memorial
Society,
founded
in
memory
of
the
missionary
from
the
United
Kingdom.

In
addition
to
a
clinic
staffed
around
the
clock
with
nurses
and
professionals,
the
center,
in
Mutoko,
Mashonaland
East,
located
in
the
eastern
province
of
Zimbabwe,
has
single
rooms
scattered
throughout
its
property.
Patients
without
disabilities
reside
in
the
center’s
adjacent
homes
with
their
families.

Bradburne,
a
lay
member
of
the
Third
Order
of
Saint
Francis,
spent
many
years
traveling
and
searching
until
he
finally
discovered
where
God
wanted
him
to
be

living
alongside
leprosy
patients
in
Mutemwa,
Rhodesia
(modern-day
Zimbabwe),
a
place
he
assisted
in
transforming
into
a
peaceful,
joyful
and
loving
community.

Not
long
after
arriving
in
the
country,
Bradburne
revealed
to
a
priest
his
three
wishes:
to
be
buried
in
the
habit
of
St.
Francis,
to
die
a
martyr
and
to
help
leprosy
victims.

He
was
first
brought
to
the
Mutemwa
Leprosy
Settlement,
located
about
90
miles
(143
kilometers)
northwest
of
Harare,
by
the
Jesuit
missionaries.
He
became
its
warden
after
arriving
at
Mutemwa
in
1969.
For
10
years,
he
helped
those
afflicted
with
leprosy
by
feeding,
tending
to
and
washing
those
in
need,
keeping
watch
over
them
during
their
illnesses
and
burying
them
when
they
died.

Leprosy,
an
illness
that
dates
back
to
ancient
times,
is
a

chronic
infectious
disease
caused
by
a
type
of
bacteria

called
mycobacterium
leprae.
The
disease
predominantly
affects
the
skin
and
peripheral
nerves.
Left
untreated,
the
disease
may
cause
progressive
and
permanent
disabilities.

“His
unwavering
devotion
to
providing
the
residents
with
loving
care
ultimately
led
to
a
falling
out
with
the
management
committee,”
said
Runesu
Maguraushe,
a
theologian.

He
said
Bradburne
was
later
fired
because
he
refused
to
lower
the
patients’
already
meager
nutrition
and
refused
to
place
dehumanizing
number
tags
around
their
necks.

“Then,
he
resided
outside
the
leprosy
compound
in
a
prefabricated
tin
shack
without
running
water
or
sanitary
facilities.
He
then
carried
on
doing
everything
in
his
power
to
assist
the
leprosy
sufferers,”
he
added.



John
Bradburne
dedicated
his
life
to
helping
lepers.
(Photo
courtesy
of
the John
Bradburne
Memorial
Society) 

In
1979,

during
a
civil
war
,
Bradburne
was
abducted
and
killed.
After
his
death,
the
center
was
given
to
the
Catholic
Church
to
run.
The
Franciscan
friars
were
called
by
the
church
to
intervene
and
oversee
the
community’s
spiritual
well-being.

Since
then,
the
community’s
mental
and
spiritual
health
have
been
given
upmost
importance
in
tandem
with
medical
care.
As
a
result,
the
center
has
become
a
beacon
of
hope
to
those
condemned
by
the
society
due
to
their
ailments.

The
community
at
Mutemwa
depends
entirely
on
the
kind
donations
made
by
pilgrims
and
the
assistance
it
receives
from
funders
to
sustain
its
mission
and
necessities
such
as
medicine,
food
and
clothing.

Leprosy
is
once
again
becoming
more
prevalent
in
Zimbabwe.
If
caught
early,
the
disease
is
completely
treatable.
Every
patient
at
the
center
receives
individualized
treatment
and
a
separate
living
space.
The
settlement
has
a
managerial
group
of
Franciscans
with
trained careers
and
nurses
also
onsite.

Globally,
there
are
still
250,000
new
cases
each
year,
according
to
the
U.S.
Centers
for
Disease
Control
and
Prevention,
and
countries
with
weak
health
care
systems
are
most
vulnerable.

In
Zimbabwe,
a
country
burdened
by
extreme
poverty
and
a
crumbling
health
sector,
concerns
have
started
to
grow
that
leprosy,
which
spreads
via
respiratory
droplets,
could
be
making
a
return.

Every
year,
thousands
of
committed
pilgrims

some
2,000
in
all

make
the
trek
on
Sept.
5,
the
day
Bradburne
was
murdered,
to
spend
time
at
Mutemwa
and
ascend
Mount
Chigona.
The
place
is
where
Bradburne
spent
time
caring
for
leprosy
patients.

As
the
pilgrimages
has
continued
over
the
years,
a
call
was
slowly
heard
for
the
Vatican
to
recognize
Bradburne
in
an
official
way.
Bradburne’s
cause
for
beatification
is
now
well
on
its
way.
The
Vatican
has
officially
decreed
to
start
the
procedure
that
would
lead
to
his
canonization
as
a
saint.

Based
on
its
shared
Franciscan
charism
“Well4Africa,”
a
decision
was
made
in
2021
to
provide
funding
for
the
water
project
at
the
Mutemwa
Leprosy
Care
Centre
and
to
guarantee
a
consistent
supply
of
clean
water
to
the
local
community.

“Zimbabwe
experiences
harsher
summers
and
more
water
problems,”
said
Tariro
Hudini,
a
community
member.

The
entire
Mutemwa
community
depends
on
this
reliable
and
permanent
supply
of
fresh
water.
The
borehole
project
helps
34
patients,
17
impoverished
individuals,
four
Franciscan
friars
and
24
staff
members
and
their
families.

Eremenciana
Chinyama,
who
serves
as
presidency
councillor
of
the
Secular
Franciscan
Order,
said
the
patients
and
the
surrounding
community
at
Mutemwa
are
guaranteed
nutritious
meals
due
to
the
water.

“Employees
who
had
been
tasked
for
a
long
time
with
getting
water
to
feed
and
tend
to
the
patients
may
now
concentrate
on
making
sure
the
people
under
their
care
receive
high-quality
treatment,”
she
said.
“In
a
place
like
Zimbabwe
where
water
can
be
scarce,
particularly
during
the
summer,
having
a
dependable
source
of
water
from
the
borehole
is
vital.”

Father
Tawanda
Chirigo,
who
serves
as
national
spiritual
assistant,
visited
Mutemwa
for
a
final
evaluation
of
the
project.

“We
can
only
hope
that
the
project’s
outcome
will
please
our
father,
St.
Francis
of
Assisi,
who
lovingly
cared
for
lepers,
and
our
brother
John
Bradburne,
who
loved
Mutemwa
so
much,”
he
said.


Calvin
Manika
is
an
award-winning
international
journalist
based
in
Zimbabwe. 

Post
published
in:

Featured

Zimbabwe Vigil Diary 5th October 2024



https://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/54047039460/sizes/m/

Special
thanks
to
her
for
her
valiant
efforts.
Special
thanks
also
to
long-term
Vigil
activist
Jonathan
Kariwo
who
looked
after
the
other
Vigil
activists
who
arrived
early
with
their
flags
which
they
waved
in
solidarity
with
the
Palestinian
protesters.
Thanks
also
to
the
others
who
came
today:
Dickson
Chikwizo,
Henry
Makambe,
Philip
Maponga,
Mellisa
Mbavarira
and
Boniface
Zengeni.
Photos: https://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/albums/72177720320927116.

For
Vigil
pictures
check: http://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/.
Please
note:
Vigil
photos
can
only
be
downloaded
from
our
Flickr
website.


Events
and
Notices:


  • Next
    Vigil
    meeting
    outside
    the
    Zimbabwe
    Embassy. 
    Saturday
    19th October
    from
    2

    5
    pm.
    We
    meet
    on
    the
    first
    and
    third
    Saturdays
    of
    every
    month.
    On
    other
    Saturdays
    the
    virtual
    Vigil
    will
    run.

  • The
    Restoration
    of
    Human
    Rights
    in
    Zimbabwe
    (ROHR)
     is
    the
    Vigil’s
    partner
    organisation
    based
    in
    Zimbabwe.
    ROHR
    grew
    out
    of
    the
    need
    for
    the
    Vigil
    to
    have
    an
    organisation
    on
    the
    ground
    in
    Zimbabwe
    which
    reflected
    the
    Vigil’s
    mission
    statement
    in
    a
    practical
    way.
    ROHR
    in
    the
    UK
    actively
    fundraises
    through
    membership
    subscriptions,
    events,
    sales
    etc
    to
    support
    the
    activities
    of
    ROHR
    in
    Zimbabwe.

  • The
    Vigil’s
    book
    ‘Zimbabwe
    Emergency’
     is
    based
    on
    our
    weekly
    diaries.
    It
    records
    how
    events
    in
    Zimbabwe
    have
    unfolded
    as
    seen
    by
    the
    diaspora
    in
    the
    UK.
    It
    chronicles
    the
    economic
    disintegration,
    violence,
    growing
    oppression
    and
    political
    manoeuvring

    and
    the
    tragic
    human
    cost
    involved. It
    is
    available
    at
    the
    Vigil.
    All
    proceeds
    go
    to
    the
    Vigil
    and
    our
    sister
    organisation
    the
    Restoration
    of
    Human
    Rights
    in
    Zimbabwe’s
    work
    in
    Zimbabwe.
    The
    book
    is
    also
    available
    from
    Amazon.

  • Facebook
    pages:
     

Vigil : https ://www.facebook.com/zimbabwevigil

ROHR: https://www.facebook.com/Restoration-of-Human-Rights-ROHR-Zimbabwe-International-370825706588551/

ZAF: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Zimbabwe-Action-Forum-ZAF/490257051027515

The
Vigil,
outside
the
Zimbabwe
Embassy,
429
Strand,
London
meets
regularly
on
Saturdays
from
14.00
to
17.00
to
protest
against
gross
violations
of
human
rights
in
Zimbabwe.
The
Vigil
which started
in
October
2002
will
continue
until
internationally-monitored,
free
and
fair
elections
are
held
in
Zimbabwe.

Post
published
in:

Featured

Strange Bedfellows — See Also

There Are Some Big Supreme Court Cases Coming Up – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Staci
Zaretsky)

The
main
distinction
between
a
right
and
a
privilege
used
to
be
that
rights
could
not
be
taken
away
from
you.
Nowadays,
the
distinction
hinges
on
whether
the
Supreme
Court
has
released
a
new
opinion.
As
terrifying
as
that
is
for
personal
liberty,
it
does
create
the
opportunity
to
gamify
our
dwindling
rights!
So,
which
right
is
up
next
on
the
chopping
block?

Here
are
a
couple
of
the
cases,
courtesy
of

People
For
:


United
States
v.
Skrmetti

will
decide
constitutionality
of
laws
making
it
illegal
to
give
transgender
minors
critically
important
gender-affirming
care.
The
justices
may
also
decide
if
laws
harming
transgender
people
trigger
heightened
judicial
scrutiny
like
laws
discriminating
on
the
basis
of
sex.


Garland
v.
VanDerStok
will
decide
whether
to
exempt
untraceable
“ghost
guns”
from
federal
firearm
safety
laws.


Lackey
v.
Stinnie
will
determine
if
civil
rights
litigants
whose
cases
end
at
the
preliminary
injuction
level
get
to
get
their
lawyer’s
fees
covered.

My
money
is
on
civil
rights
plaintiffs
getting
defendants
to
pay
their
attorneys’
fees.
Now
that
the
plaintiff
in
303
Creative
got
her
lawyers’
fees
handled
by
Colorado,
why
not
pick
the
ladder
up?
Then
again,
you
really
couldn’t
go
wrong
with
undermining
the
EPA.
Will
we
get
Roberts’s
coy
openness
to
regulations
that
matter
or
an
unchecked
Thomas
saying
the
quiet
part
out
loud
this
time?

Only
time
will
tell!
May
the
odds
be
ever
in
your
favor.


What’s
Next
For
the
MAGA
Justices?
The
Upcoming
2024-25
Supreme
Court
Term

[People
For]



Chris
Williams
became
a
social
media
manager
and
assistant
editor
for
Above
the
Law
in
June
2021.
Prior
to
joining
the
staff,
he
moonlighted
as
a
minor
Memelord™
in
the
Facebook
group Law
School
Memes
for
Edgy
T14s
.
 He
endured
Missouri
long
enough
to
graduate
from
Washington
University
in
St.
Louis
School
of
Law.
He
is
a
former
boatbuilder
who
cannot
swim, a
published
author
on
critical
race
theory,
philosophy,
and
humor
,
and
has
a
love
for
cycling
that
occasionally
annoys
his
peers.
You
can
reach
him
by
email
at [email protected] and
by
tweet
at @WritesForRent.

The Law School That Won’t ‘Openly Discriminate Against Conservatives’ Is Gaining Favor With The Supreme Court – Above the Law



Ed.
note
:
Welcome
to
our
daily
feature,

Quote
of
the
Day
.


Half
the
American
people
could
be
characterized
as
conservative.
Half
the
legal
profession
can
be
characterized
as
conservative.
In
fact,
there’s
nothing
wrong
with
being
conservative.
It’s
normal.
It’s
normal
everywhere
except
for
in
the
legal
academy.


I’m
happy
that
we’re
one
of
the
few
law
schools
in
America
that
doesn’t
openly
discriminate
against
conservatives.




Dean

G.
Marcus
Cole

of
the
University
of
Notre
Dame
Law
School,
in
comments
given
to

NBC
News

on
the
fact
that
his
faculty
leans
heavily
to
the
right.
Cole
went
on
to
say
that
at
other
law
schools,
having
conservatives
among
the
faculty
would
be
considered
“a
badge
of
dishonor.”
Now
that

Amy
Coney
Barrett
,
a
Notre
Dame
alumnus,
serves
as
a
justice
on
the
Supreme
Court,
the
school
has
continued
to
curry
favor
with
the
high
court.



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on

X/Twitter

and

Threads

or
connect
with
her
on

LinkedIn
.