Trump Judge Facing Allegations He Hosted Underage Drinking Party Resulting In ‘Serious And Traumatic’ Injuries – Above the Law

Central
District
of
California
Judge
Mark
C.
Scarsi
is

familiar
with
courting
headlines


like
when
he
took
to
the
public
record
to
rage
against
Joe
Biden’s
pardon
of
his
son.
But
this
isn’t
the
type
of
story
that
gets
you

fawning
coverage

over
at
Fox
News.

According
to

a
complaint
filed
last
week

in
California
state
court,
Scarsi
and
his
wife
hosted
a
party
attended
by
high
school
students
where
there
was
“significant
underage
drinking.”
According
to
plaintiff
Alex
Wilson,
there
was
little
supervision
at
the
party
and
no
security.
A
brutal
fight
broke
out
in
front
of
the
Scarsis’
property,
and
Wilson
was
severely
injured,
according
to
the
complaint.

As

reported
by

Law360:

Wilson
said
the
students
were
drinking
alcohol
at
Judge
Scarsi’s
home,
“without
any
hired
security
or
proper
supervision.”
During
the
party,
the
fight
broke
out
“directly
in
front
of
and
on
the
property
of
the
Scarsi
home,”
he
said.
That’s
when
Wilson
was
“brutally”
beaten,
resulting
in
“significant”
injuries
that
left
him
in
the
hospital
for
weeks,
he
said.

“As
a
result
of
the
ineffective
protection
and
the
underage
drinking
allowed
by
the
Scarsis
on
their
property
and
their
failure
to
supervise
or
have
appropriate
security
personnel,
a
brutal
and
severe
beating
was
perpetrated

upon
plaintiff,
who
had
to
be
admitted
at
a
hospital
for
over
two
weeks
to
receive
medical
care
for
his
injuries,”
the
complaint
states.

Wilson’s
underage
assailant
and
the
assailant’s
parents
are
also
listed
as
defendants.

Wilson
is
seeking
unspecified
damages
for
his
“serious
and
traumatic
injuries”
and
says
he
“will
require
reconstructive
plastic
surgery
and
has
suffered
personal
and
social
anxiety
and
distress
from
the
prominent
facial
scarring
and
the
incident.”
The
complaint
alleges
negligence
and
negligent
security
against
the
Scarsis
and
specifically
points
to
“the
failure
of
SCARSI
security
personnel
to
protect
him,
and
the
lack
of
supervision
at
an
event
that
allowed
underage
drinking
at
the
SCARSI
property.”




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].

Boutique Firm Reportedly Beats Market Rate On Associate Bonuses – Above the Law

Biglaw
and
boutique
law
firm
associates
alike
are
dreaming
of
a
holiday
season
with
a
lot
more
cash
in
their
accounts
thanks
to
Milbank’s
generous

year-end

and

special

bonuses.

The
latest
boutique
to
spread
the
wealth
to
associates
is
New
York-based
investment
fund
litigation
boutique

Rolnick
Kramer
Sadighi
.
The
young
firm
recently
closed
out
its
fourth
year,
and
in
a

LinkedIn
post

published
last
week,
announced
that
“for
the
second
time
in
three
years,
our
associate
and
counsel
bonuses
exceed
the
Cravath/Milbank
year-end
and
special
bonus
scale.”

As
a
reminder,
this
is
what
the
prevailing
market
rate
for
bonuses
and
special
bonuses
looks
like
this
year,
and
RKS
is
reportedly
awarding
bonuses

“above”

these
amounts:

  • Class
    of
    2024

    $15,000
    /
    $6,000
  • Class
    of
    2023

    $20,000
    /
    $6,000
  • Class
    of
    2022

    $30,000
    /
    $10,000
  • Class
    of
    2021

    $57,500
    /
    $15,000
  • Class
    of
    2020

    $75,000
    /
    $20,000
  • Class
    of
    2019

    $90,000
    /
    $25,000
  • Class
    of
    2018

    $105,000
    /
    $25,000
  • Class
    of
    2017+

    $115,000
    /
    $25,000

Congratulations
to
all
Rolnick
Kramer
Sadighi
associates!

Remember
everyone,
we
depend
on
your
tips
to
stay
on
top
of
compensation
updates,
so
when
your
firm
announces
or
matches,
please
text
us
(646-820-8477)
or email
us
 (subject
line:
“[Firm
Name]
Bonus/Matches”).
Please
include
the
memo
if
available.
You
can
take
a
photo
of
the
memo
and
send
it
via
text
or
email
if
you
don’t
want
to
forward
the
original
PDF
or
Word
file.

And
if
you’d
like
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s
Bonus
Alerts
(which
is
the
alert
list
we
also
use
for
salary
announcements),
please
scroll
down
and
enter
your
email
address
in
the
box
below
this
post.
If
you
previously
signed
up
for
the
bonus
alerts,
you
don’t
need
to
do
anything.
You’ll
receive
an
email
notification
within
minutes
of
each
bonus
announcement
that
we
publish.
Thanks
for
your
help!



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on BlueskyX/Twitter,
and Threads, or
connect
with
her
on LinkedIn.


Bonus Time

Enter
your
email
address
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s

Bonus
&
Salary
Increase
Alerts
.


GOP Blocks Federal Judge’s Replacement So He Puts The Breaks On Retirement Plan – Above the Law

On
Friday
,
Fourth
Circuit
Judge
James
Wynn
did
an
about
face
on
his
retirement
plans.
He

joins
two
district
court
judges
,
Max
Cogburn
and
Algenon
Marbley,
in
declaring
backsies
on
his
plans
after
Donald
Trump
won
the
2024
presidential
election.

The
70-year-old
Wynn,
an
appointee
of
Barack
Obama,
decided
against
senior
status
after
President
Joe
Biden’s
choice
to
replace
him,
North
Carolina
Solicitor
General
Ryan
Park,
was
blocked
by
Republicans.
Both
Republican
senators
from
North
Carolina,
Thom
Tillis
and
Ted
Budd,
opposed
Park’s
elevation
to
the
judiciary.
Tillis,
who
sits
on
the
judiciary
committee,
went
hard
against
the
Park
nomination
as

reported
by

News
&
Observer,

Tillis
warned
the
Judiciary
Committee
in
November
that
if
they
approved
Park’s
nomination
there
“would
be
consequences”
and
he
would
vote
to
approve
any
nominee
Trump
put
forward
in
the
future.
Democrats
approved
Park
anyway.

But
before
Park
made
it
to
the
Senate
floor
for
a
vote,
Democrats
and
Republicans
struck
a
late-night
deal
to
throw
out
four
appellate
nominations
from
Biden
if
Republicans
would
stop
making
the
process
of
approving
other
judicial
nominees
difficult
for
Democrats.

After
that
move,
Tillis
issued
warning
to
the
retiring
judges
“not
to
play
partisan
politics
with
the
presidential
transition
and
a
Senate
deal
and
going
back
on
their
word.”
But
that’s
the
thing
about
lifetime
appointment,
at
the
end
of
the
day,
it’s
really
the
judge’s

and
only
the
judge’s

call.

When
Wynn
walked
back
his
retirement,
Tillis
freaked
as
you
might
expect.

“Judge
Wynn’s
brazenly
partisan
decision
to
rescind
his
retirement
is
an
unprecedented
move
that
demonstrates
some
judges
are
nothing
more
than
politicians
in
robes,”
Tillis
said
in
a
news
release
Saturday.
“Judge
Wynn
clearly
takes
issue
with
the
fact
that
Donald
Trump
was
just
elected
President,
and
this
decision
is
a
slap
in
the
face
to
the
U.S.
Senate,
which
came
to
a
bipartisan
agreement
to
hold
off
on
confirming
his
replacement
until
the
next
Congress
is
sworn-in
in
January.”

No
matter
the
stern
language
the
senator
uses,
this
is
pretty
much
exactly
the
consequences
of
Tillis’s
own
actions
and
the
only
response
available
for
Wynn.
But

Republicans
don’t
love
it

when
their
plans
to
manipulate
the
composition
of
the
federal
judiciary
don’t
work
out.




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].

ATL Holiday Card Contest: The Finalists! (2024) – Above the Law

Hanukkah
and
Christmas
are
nearly
upon
us,
and
everyone
in
the
legal
profession
is
ready
to
ring
in
the
New
Year,
so
it’s
finally
time
to
reveal
the
seven
finalists
for
our
sixteenth
annual
holiday
card
contest.
But
first
let’s
give
shout-outs
to
some
honorable
mentions
(click
on
each
firm’s
name
to
see
its
card):

1.

Armond
Wilson
:
Behold,
another
holiday
blockbuster
card
from
the
nation’s
4th
best
law
firm
in
Patent
Office
litigation,
per

Patexia
.
In
this
Home
Alone-inspired
hit,
our
nominator
behooves
you
to
“Keep
some
claims,
ya
filthy
animal!”

2.

Diaz
Trade
Law
:
“No
one
has
more
fun
asking
CBP
to
forgive
a
client
for
not
paying
$40M
in
duties
over
10
years
than
Diaz
Trade
Law,”
says
our
nominator.
“And
with
47
federal
agencies
involved
in
regulating
imports
of
goods
into
the
United
States,
DTL
truly
means
it
when
they
say
then
untangle
regulations.”

3.

Shaw
Keller
:
Happy
holidays,
from
your
lawyers’
pets!
This
card
features
paintings
of
all
manner
of
pets,
up
to
and
including
a
bird
and
a
horse.
“We
allowed
one
posthumous
pet
because
otherwise
one
of
our
associates
would
have
had
a
plastic
plant,”
says
our
nominator.

And
now,
the
seven
finalists,
in
alphabetical
order.
Again,
click
on
each
firm’s
name
to
view
its
card.
Please
note
that
most
of
these
cards
have
SOUND,
so
you
might
want
to
turn
your
sound
off
or
down,
or
use
headphones.
Explanatory
comments
come
from
firm
representatives
unless
indicated.

1.

Butler
Snow
:
“This
year,
we
decided
to
take
another
compelling
look
at
lawyers
over-lawyering
seemingly
simple
things.
Admittedly,
it’s
a
bit
of
an
extension
of
our
award
winning
2023
holiday
card.
But
if
it’s
not
broke,
don’t
fix
it,
right?”
Yet
another
excellent
submission
from
lawyers
who
can’t
help
themselves
but
to
over-lawyer
everything.
Our
favorite
part
was
when
of
them
said
they
should
stitch
a
suggested
holiday
greeting
disclaimer
on
a
sweater

“This
holiday
greeting
is
for
informational
purposes
only.
It
does
not
constitute
an
offer,
promise,
or
guarantee
of
any
kind.
Peace,
love,
and
joy
are
subjective,
and
experiences
may
vary.”

and
they
actually
did!
(By
the
way,
where
can
we
get
that
sweater?)

2.

Cades
Schutte
:
A
truly
wonderful
holiday
card
that
shares
the
“spirit
of
aloha,”
straight
from
the
Hawaiian
islands.
Our
nominator
says,
“We
feature
our
client,
Furukawa
Living
Treasure,
a
beloved
senior
community
in
Honolulu,
that
was
about
to
be
shut
down
due
to
permitting
issues.
Through
their
tenacity
and
strong
will,
they
survived
and
are
now
celebrating
their
25th
anniversary.
Our
attorneys
were
honored
to
join
Furukawa’s
anniversary
festivities
and
make
origami
aloha
shirt
crafts
with
the
kupuna
(seniors)
of
the
community.”
This
one
made
us
feel
happy

how
very
sweet!

3.

Davis
Wright
Tremaine
:
The
firm’s
“in-house
creative
team,
Studio
DWT,
proudly
presents
a
delightful
3D
animated
holiday
video
set
in
a
whimsical
gingerbread
ski
lodge
and
resort.
This
festive
video
celebrates
the
sweet
moments
that
inspire
us,
connect
us,
and
make
our
shared
successes
possible.
Studio
DWT’s
expert
storytellers
and
film
producers
have
brought
their
unique
vision
to
life,
delivering
a
heartfelt
message
of
warmth
and
joy
for
the
season.”
This
one
is
a
real
work
of
creative
art.
Nice
job!

4.

Harness
IP
:
“Our
video
holiday
card
stands
out
with
its
unique
blend
of
history,
creativity,
and
holiday
cheer.
By
showcasing
historic
patents
on
sleigh
bells,
we
bring
a
fun
twist
to
a
timeless
holiday
tradition,”
says
our
nominator.
“The
whimsical
elf
band
adds
an
extra
layer
of
charm,
turning
the
story
behind
these
classic
inventions
into
an
engaging
musical
celebration.
This
delightful
mix
of
educational
and
festive
elements
creates
a
captivating
narrative
that
connects
the
past
and
present,
making
it
both
entertaining
and
meaningful.
It’s
not
just
a
card—it’s
an
experience
that
captures
the
spirit
of
innovation
and
joy
that
defines
the
holiday
season!”
This
holiday
card
has
everything
you
could
possibly
want

and
you
can
even
download
an
app
to
turn
your
phone
into
a
set
of
sleigh
bells
each
time
you
move
it!
Absolutely
amazing!

5.

Larson

King
:
This
firm
knows
that
Above
the
Law
editors
are
suckers
for
law
revue
videos,
and
this
is
simply
the
best.
The
11-time
holiday
card
contest
finalist
really
stole
the
show
with
this
submission.
From
our
nominator:
“Our
2024
greeting
highlights
Minnesotans’
love
of
music
by
featuring
assorted
parodies
of
throw-back
tunes
with
a
legal
twist.
Take
a
blast
into
the
past
by
listening
to
hits
such
as

We
Be
Billin’

(Run-D.M.C’s

You
Be
Illin’
),

Don’t
Stop
Appealin’

(Journey’s

Don’t
Stop
Believin’
),

Material
Witness

(Madonna’s

Material
Girl
),
and

Brief
It

(Michael
Jackson’s

Beat
It
).
Also
included
is
Minnesota’s
own
Prince,
featuring

I
Wanna
Be
Your
Lawyer

(a
parody
of

I
Wanna
Be
Your
Lover
).
The
songs
were
custom-created
for
this
video
by
a
local
Minneapolis
musician
and
vocalist.”
We’d
definitely
pay
the
low,
low
price
of
$9.99
for
all
of
these
tunes!
We

LOVED

this
one!

6.

McBrayer
:
A
hilarious
take
on
the
Ebenezer
Scrooge
story,
featuring
Bob
Cratchit
as
a
“former
abused
clerk/new
partner.”
This
lawyerly
view
of
the
Christmas
classic
had
us
cracking
up.
From
our
nominator:
“We
like
to
think
that
we
could
have
helped
famous
miser
Ebenezer
Scrooge
find
the
right
path
in
life
without
supernatural
intervention.
Here’s
our
take
on
how,
with
McBrayer
attorneys
playing
the
roles
of
famous
Dickens
characters
or
simply
themselves.
We’re
biased,
but
our
Scrooge
may
be
one
of
the
better
ones
committed
to
screen.”

7.

Morse
:
From
our
nominator:
“This
year
we
decided
to
really
showcase
the
‘human
side’
of
our
team
by
presenting
their
many
creative
talents
in
a
printable,
shareable,
and
downloadable
e-book
full
of
crafty
DIY
projects
and
gift
options!
The
Morse
team
has
been
finding
creative
solutions
to
legal
issues
for
more
than
30
years,
but
did
you
know
we
can
also
make
a
mean
batch
of
holiday
dog
cookies,
whip
up
some
super
cute
snowman
bath
bombs,
or
decoupage
a
favorite
piece
of
furniture??
But
of
course,
when
it
comes
to
your
legal
needs,
don’t
do
it
yourself!
Call
us.
😉”
Wow!
This
e-book
looks
like
it
could
actually
be
very
helpful
for
those
who
need
to
entertain
elementary
school
students
who
are
home
during
winter
break.
Looking
forward
to
creating
homemade
cookie
mason
jars,
sugar
scrub
sand
art,
and
playdough
thanks
to
Morse!

Now
it’s
time
for
our
audience
to
vote.
We’ll
keep
the
polls
open
through

TUESDAY,
DECEMBER
31,
2021,
at
11:30
p.m.

(Eastern
time).
This
gives
you
ample
time
to
campaign
for
your
pick
over
the
holidays
(but
please,
don’t
cheat).



CLICK
HERE
TO
VOTE
.

Thanks
to
all
the
entrants
and
nominators,
good
luck
to
the
finalists,
and
happy
holidays
to
all!
Above
the
Law
is
happy
to
celebrate
holiday
cheer
with
you!



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on BlueskyX/Twitter,
and Threads, or
connect
with
her
on LinkedIn.

Biglaw Firm Offers Extra Bonus Money If You Put The Work In! – Above the Law

Not
every
firm
is
just
matching
— 
some
really
make
you
work
for
it!
Quinn
Emanuel
is
one
of
them.
They’ve
recently
announcing
bonuses,
but
there
are
some
caveats.
The
Biglaw
firm
reported
$2,079,448,000
in
gross
revenue
in
and
a
whopping
profits
per
equity
partner
of
$7,270,000
in
2023,
according
to
the
most
recent
Am
Law
100
ranking.
Those
aggressive
earnings
match
their
aggressive
hours
expectations.
Just
barely
made
2000
hours?
You’re
already
behind!
Here’s
their
scale:

Screen Shot 2024-12-16 at 1.31.30 PM

While
the
special
bonuses
match
Milbank,
the
base
bonus
numbers
you’d
expect
to
see
from
this
season
start
around
the
2100-2399
mark,
with
more
money
piling
as
the
hours
do.
The
bonuses
will
be
paid
out
next
week.

We
like
hearing
about
bonuses
almost
as
much
as
you
enjoy
spending
them.
As
soon
as
your
firm’s
memo
comes
out,
please email
it
to
us
 (subject
line:
“[Firm
Name]
Bonus”)
or
text
us
(646-820-8477).
Please
include
the
memo
if
available.
You
can
take
a
photo
of
the
memo
and
send
it
via
text
or
email
if
you
don’t
want
to
forward
the
original
PDF
or
Word
file.

And
if
you’d
like
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s
Salary
&
Bonus
Alerts,
please
scroll
down
and
enter
your
email
address
in
the
box
below
this
post.
If
you
previously
signed
up
for
the
bonus
alerts,
you
don’t
need
to
do
anything.
You’ll
receive
an
email
notification
within
minutes
of
each
bonus
announcement
that
we
publish.



Chris
Williams
became
a
social
media
manager
and
assistant
editor
for
Above
the
Law
in
June
2021.
Prior
to
joining
the
staff,
he
moonlighted
as
a
minor
Memelord™
in
the
Facebook
group Law
School
Memes
for
Edgy
T14s
.
 He
endured
Missouri
long
enough
to
graduate
from
Washington
University
in
St.
Louis
School
of
Law.
He
is
a
former
boatbuilder
who
cannot
swim, a
published
author
on
critical
race
theory,
philosophy,
and
humor
,
and
has
a
love
for
cycling
that
occasionally
annoys
his
peers.
You
can
reach
him
by
email
at [email protected] and
by
tweet
at @WritesForRent.


Bonus Time

Enter
your
email
address
to
sign
up
for
ATL’s

Bonus
&
Salary
Increase
Alerts
.


Biglaw Ugly Sweater Contest Gets Intense – Above the Law

Seward
&
Kissel
never
shies
away
from
bringing

a
little
irreverence

to
its
otherwise
buttoned-up
world.
In
an
era
marked
by
work-from-home
initiatives
and
lateral
turnover,
Seward
&
Kissel
works
to
create

a
culture
that
makes
everyone
happy
to
go
to
work
.

Last
week,
the
firm
held
its
annual
Ugly
Sweater
Contest
which
was
less
“office
holiday
party”
and
more
full-scale
production,
complete
with
themed
floor
competitions,
a
coordinated
runway
walk,
and
a
judging
panel
that
included
not
one,
but

five
Steve
Nadels
.

Spanning
seven
floors
and
involving
approximately
125
participants,
the
contest
turned
the
firm’s
office
into
a
holiday
runway
show. Each
floor
selected
a
corresponding
song
for
their
grand
entrance,
and
strutted
their
stuff
on
the
catwalk
to
compete
for
top
honors.
From
festive
classics
like
“Jingle
Bells”
to
unexpected
anthems
like
Darth
Vader’s
“Imperial
March”
to
Blasterjaxx/Timmy
Trumpet’s
“Narco.”

The
competition,
coordinated
by
partner
Steve
Nadel,
reached
every
corner
of
the
Seward
&
Kissel
ecosystem,
even
tapping
into
its
unique
connection
to
the
Steve
Nadel
Club

a
real-life
network
of
guys
across
the
country
all
named
Steve
Nadel.
Five
Steves
joined
the
judging
panel
virtually
via
Teams.

And
because
Seward
&
Kissel
never
does
anything
halfway,
the
firm
enlisted
Gary
Berger,
audit
partner
from
CohnReznick,
to
serve
as
an
official
auditor
for
the
contest.
Because
S&K
does
its
fun
to
the
hilt.

For
the
second
consecutive
year,
the
19th
floor
emerged
victorious
in
the
“Best
Floor”
category,
with
a
Wicked-themed
presentation.
Associate
and
19th
floor
captain
Jenny
Elberg,
took
“Best
Individual
Outfit”
as
a
green-skinned
Wicked
Witch.
Another
floor
channeled
its
inner
Jack
Sparrow
as
The
Pirate
Ship
(complete
with
Maritime
Group
contributions),
while
the
22nd
floor
was
“Feeling
’22”
with
a
Taylor
Swift
theme.

If
this
all
sounds
delightfully
over-the-top,
that’s
because
it
is.
The
Ugly
Sweater
Contest
has
become
a
hallmark
of
Seward
&
Kissel’s
holiday
season,
embodying
the
firm’s
unique
culture
of
combining
high
standards
with
a
sense
of
fun.

With
themes
growing
more
elaborate
each
year
and
the
stakes
getting
higher,
it’s
clear
that
S&K’s
contest
isn’t
just
about
sweaters
anymore

it’s
a
pitch
battle
for
floor
dominance.
And
the
19th
floor
is
building
a
mini-dynasty.

IMG_1481




HeadshotJoe
Patrice
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
Feel
free
to email
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments.
Follow
him
on Twitter or

Bluesky

if
you’re
interested
in
law,
politics,
and
a
healthy
dose
of
college
sports
news.
Joe
also
serves
as
a

Managing
Director
at
RPN
Executive
Search
.

Zimbabweland’s festive top 20 for 2024


There
are
a
lot
of
blogs
on
the
site
to
choose
from

nearly
600
since
2011

so
readers
often
find
ones
that
were
published
a
while
back
and
some
oldies
get
republished.
The
search
facility
on
the
site
is
quite
good,
so
do
have
a
search
as
the
longer-term
story
of
Zimbabwe’s
land
reform
(and
many
associated
debates)
is
interesting
to
review.

In
terms
of
posts
in
the
top
20
this
year,
there
are
a
few
old
faves.
The
pig
blog
seems
to
get
found
on
searches
regularly
as
people
seek
to
develop
on-farm
‘projects’.
This
was
not
meant
as
a
practical
how-to
guide
to
establishing
piggeries,
but
I
hope
it’s
useful.
In
the
same
way
entrepreneurs
interested
in
poultry,
horticulture
and
so
on
seem
to
find
their
way
to
the
blog.

The
UK
election
was
an
important
political
event
for
some
of
us
this
year,
but
as
predicted
in
the
blog
the
consequences
for
development
aid
and
Africa
are
not
significant.
In
some
respects,
the
incoming
Labour
administration
is
repeating
some
of
the
old
mistakes
that
previous
Labour
governments
have
made
in
respect
of
Zimbabwe,
especially
with
the
failure
to
readmit
Zimbabwe
into
the
Commonwealth.
However,
the
far
more
important
story
for
next
year(s)
I
suspect
will
be
the
return
of
Trump
in
the
US
and
the
question
of
how
China
readjusts
its
economic
relations
with
Africa
given
its
domestic
economic
challenges.

The
series
on
small
towns,
urban
agriculture
and
so
on
remains
popular
and
readers
will
be
happy
to
know
that
we
have
done
new
work
on
small
towns
and
rural-urban
linkages
and
a
new
blog
series
will
appear
in
the
new
year.
Themes
on
agricultural
and
rural
finance
correctly
attract
substantial
interest,
as
well
as
debates
around
the
potentials
for
agriculture-led
private
sector
growth.
Land
tenure
is
currently
a
hot
topic
in
Zimbabwe
and
the
recent
series
on
land
markets
has
generated
interest
given
the
current
policy
interest,
with
the
World
Bank
position
on
this
questioned
in
another
popular
blog
this
year.

There
are
a
few
blogs
in
the
list
on
environmental
issues,
ranging
from
carbon
to
elephants,
plus
the
wider
questions
of
drought
and
climate
that
appear
repeatedly
in
posts
on
Zimbabweland.
We
will
again
be
returning
to
these
themes
in
the
new
year,
hoping
that
the
current
dry
spell
doesn’t
persist
and
the
impacts
of
the
El
Nino
drought
of
last
season
will
not
be
repeated.

Finally,
there
are
a
couple
of
blogs
on
the
bigger
land
reform
and
resettlement
story
in
Zimbabwe,
including
a
brief
history
of
experiences
pre-2000.
The
wider
debate
about
land
redistribution
is
covered
in
a
blog
that
discusses
a
dialogue
session
at
the
Global
Land
Grabbing
conference
in
Colombia
this
March.

Next
year
is
the
25th anniversary
of
the
‘fast-track’
land
reform
in
Zimbabwe
and
our
research
is
gearing
up
to
develop
a
retrospective
look
at
what
has
happened
across
our
sites
where
we
have
sample
households
that
we
have
tracked
for
most
of
this
period.
Look
out
for
updates
from
this
work.
One
of
the
early
updates
will
be
a
blog
series
on
inter-generational
succession
and
young
people’s
livelihoods
in
land
reform
areas,
a
crucial
practical
and
policy
issue
across
Zimbabwe.

1. The
growth
of
small
and
medium-scale
poultry
production
in
Zimbabwe

2. Zimbabwe’s
new
agricultural
entrepreneurs
I:
pig
production

3. The
changing
remittance
economy
in
Zimbabwe

4. The
growth
of
urban
agriculture
in
Zimbabwe

5. Commercialising
horticulture
in
Zimbabwe:
some
case
studies

6. Booming
horticulture
markets
in
Zimbabwe:
a
growing
‘hidden
middle’

7. The
UK
election:
new
development
priorities
in
Africa?

8. Why
financing
agriculture
in
Zimbabwe
needs
a
rethink:
limited
credit
and
few
loans

9. Livestock
populations
decimated
by
‘January
disease’
in
Zimbabwe:
diverse
local
responses

10. Land
tenure
reform
in
Africa:
why
customary
systems
are
important

11. Zimbabwe
as
the
new
carbon
frontier:
dangers
ahead

12. The
trouble
with
elephants:
why
limits
on
culling
are
bad
for
conservation

13. The
World
Bank
and
land:
some
questions

14. Urban
agriculture
in
Zimbabwe:
a
photo
story

15. Private
sector-led
transformation
in
Zimbabwe:
can
agriculture
drive
growth?

16. Financing
agriculture:
what
are
the
challenges
and
opportunities
in
Zimbabwe?

17. Zimbabwe’s
resettlement
experience
from
1980
to
2000

18. El
Niño
drought
hits
Zimbabwe
hard

19. Can
a
new
global
wave
of
land
redistribution
emerge?

20. Policies
for
land,
agriculture
and
rural
development:
some
suggestions
for
Zimbabwe


This
blog
was
written
by
Ian
Scoones
and
first
appeared
on Zimbabweland

Post
published
in:

Agriculture

Some Trump Holiday Cheer – Above the Law

(Photo
by
Win
McNamee/Getty
Images)

To
my
sane
friends

that
is,
the
ones
who
voted
against
Trump

here’s
some
holiday
cheer: 
Things
may
be
OK.

The
Trump
presidency
may
work
out.

Think
about
foreign
policy:
As
to
Iran,
nothing’s
worked
so
far.
Maybe
the
recent
events
in
Syria
will
be
an
improvement,
no
matter
who’s
the
president.
Or
maybe
Trump’s
“maximum
pressure”
policy
will
be
as
good
as
whatever
Biden’s
been
doing.

China?
Same
deal.
Perhaps
threats
of
tariffs,
or
actual
tariffs,
will
bring
China
back
onto
the
right
side
of
the
global
community.
I’d
pay
another
percent
or
two
for
manufactured
goods
in
exchange
for
an
improvement
in
the
world
order.

In
Israel,
Netanyahu
may
give
Trump
the
welcoming
present
of
a
peace
deal
in
Gaza.
That
would
undoubtedly
be
an
improvement.

On
NATO,
maybe
Trump
is
bluffing.
Trump
wants
member
countries
to
contribute
more
money
for
their
defense.
Perhaps
they
will,
and
the
United
States
will
not
withdraw
from
the
alliance.
That’d
be
a
win-win.

In
Ukraine,
victory
for
the
good
guys
appears
to
be
out
of
reach.
Perhaps
a
negotiated
solution
that
ends
the
dying
is
not
so
bad.

North
Korea?
Nothing’s
worked
for
the
past
few
decades.
So
whatever
Trump
does
is
a
push
with
the
past,
unless
Trump
triggers
World
War
III.
I
don’t
think
he’d
do
that,
because
World
War
III
would
ruin
all
of
his
golf
courses.

See?
On
the
foreign
policy
front,
things
could
be
OK.

How
about
domestic
policy?

Maybe
Trump’s
just
bluffing
about
imposing
20%
tariffs
on
Canada
and
Mexico.
Perhaps
our
neighbors
will
make
some
insignificant
adjustments
to
something,
Trump
will
claim
that
he’s
achieved
the
greatest
victory
in
the
history
of
the
world,
and
life
will
move
on.

Same
with
deportation
of
illegal
immigrants:
Trump
will
deport
a
few
thousand
undocumented
workers
who
committed
crimes
while
they
were
in
the
United
States.
Beyond
that,
deportations
will
become
expensive
and
unpopular. 
Deportations
will
stop,
Trump
will
claim
success,
and
life
will
go
back
to
normal.
Actually,
life
will
go
back
to
a
better
normal.

Tax
cuts?
This
is
tricky.
The
Trump
tax
cuts
disproportionately
benefited
the
rich.
Continuing
those
tax
cuts
will
worsen
the
federal
deficit
and
again
simply
benefit
the
rich.
But
we’ve
lived
with
those
tax
cuts
for
six
years
now,
and
we’ve
survived.
And
the
damned
politicians
have
ignored
deficits
since
the
Reagan
era,
and
we’ve
gotten
away
with
it.
Maybe
there
will
not
yet
be
a
price
today.

Climate
change?
Maybe
the
market
economy
will
help:
Coal
and
gas
will
become
expensive
sources
of
energy
compared
to
nuclear,
solar,
and
wind,
and
folks
will
gradually
shift
to
cheaper,
and
more
climate-friendly,
alternatives.

See?
Things
might
not
be
so
bad.

I
confess
that
you’ll
probably
get
a
dose
of
Trump
every
morning
for
the
next
four
years,
as
he
continues
to
steal
the
media
spotlight
for
no
good
reason.
I
can’t
help
you
with
that.
Just
ignore
him.

In
the
meantime,
think
about
this:
Every
day,
for
the
rest
of
your
life,
you’ll
proudly
be
able
to
say,
“I’ve
never
voted
for
a
convicted
felon
to
be
President
of
the
United
States.”
That
puts
you
way
ahead
of
tens
of
millions
of
Americans.




Mark 
Herrmann


spent
17
years
as
a
partner
at
a
leading
international
law
firm
and
later
oversaw
litigation,
compliance
and
employment
matters
at
a
large
international
company.
He
is
the
author
of




The
Curmudgeon’s
Guide
to
Practicing
Law
 and Drug
and
Device
Product
Liability
Litigation
Strateg
y (affiliate
links).
You
can
reach
him
by
email
at 
[email protected].

Zimbabwe Vigil Diary 14th December 2024


16.12.2024


17:21

Another
virtual
Vigil
today
continues
our
protest
against
the
human
rights
abuse
and
lack
of
democracy
in
Zimbabwe. 



https://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/54208041801/sizes/m/

Our
virtual
Vigil
activist
today
was
Chantelle
Manyande.
She
carried
a
placard
expressing
her
dissatisfaction
with
ZANU
PF,
Zimbabwe’s
ruling
regime.  Photo:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/albums/72177720322600817
.

For
Vigil
pictures
check: http://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/.
Please
note:
Vigil
photos
can
only
be
downloaded
from
our
Flickr
website.


  


Events
and
Notices:  


  • Next
    Vigil
    meeting
    outside
    the
    Zimbabwe
    Embassy. 
    Saturday
    7th December
    from
    2

    5
    pm.
    We
    meet
    on
    the
    first
    and
    third
    Saturdays
    of
    every
    month.
    On
    other
    Saturdays
    the
    virtual
    Vigil
    will
    run.

  • The
    Restoration
    of
    Human
    Rights
    in
    Zimbabwe
    (ROHR)
     is
    the
    Vigil’s
    partner
    organisation
    based
    in
    Zimbabwe.
    ROHR
    grew
    out
    of
    the
    need
    for
    the
    Vigil
    to
    have
    an
    organisation
    on
    the
    ground
    in
    Zimbabwe
    which
    reflected
    the
    Vigil’s
    mission
    statement
    in
    a
    practical
    way.
    ROHR
    in
    the
    UK
    actively
    fundraises
    through
    membership
    subscriptions,
    events,
    sales
    etc
    to
    support
    the
    activities
    of
    ROHR
    in
    Zimbabwe.

  • The
    Vigil’s
    book
    ‘Zimbabwe
    Emergency’
     is
    based
    on
    our
    weekly
    diaries.
    It
    records
    how
    events
    in
    Zimbabwe
    have
    unfolded
    as
    seen
    by
    the
    diaspora
    in
    the
    UK.
    It
    chronicles
    the
    economic
    disintegration,
    violence,
    growing
    oppression
    and
    political
    manoeuvring

    and
    the
    tragic
    human
    cost
    involved. It
    is
    available
    at
    the
    Vigil.
    All
    proceeds
    go
    to
    the
    Vigil
    and
    our
    sister
    organisation
    the
    Restoration
    of
    Human
    Rights
    in
    Zimbabwe’s
    work
    in
    Zimbabwe.
    The
    book
    is
    also
    available
    from
    Amazon.


  • Facebook
    pages:   


        Vigil : 
https ://www.facebook.com/zimbabwevigil 


        
ROHR: https://www.facebook.com/Restoration-of-Human-Rights-ROHR-Zimbabwe-International-370825706588551/ 

        ZAF: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Zimbabwe-Action-Forum-ZAF/490257051027515

The
Vigil,
outside
the
Zimbabwe
Embassy,
429
Strand,
London
meets
regularly
on
Saturdays
from
14.00
to
17.00
to
protest
against
gross
violations
of
human
rights
in
Zimbabwe.
The
Vigil
which started
in
October
2002
will
continue
until
internationally-monitored,
free
and
fair
elections
are
held
in
Zimbabwe.

Post
published
in:

Featured

Economic Governance Watch 9/2024


Introduction

At
the
end
of
last
month
the
Minister
of
Finance,
Economic
Development
and
Investment
Promotion
presented
the
2025
national
budget
statement
in
the
National
Assembly.  He
did
this
in
accordance
with
section
305(1)
of
the
Constitution,
which
states:

“(1)  Every
year
the
Minister
responsible
for
finance
must
present
to
the
National
Assembly
a
statement
of
the
revenues
and
expenditures
of
the
Government
in
the
next
financial
year.”

When
the
Minister
presented
his
budget
statement
he
tabled
supporting
documents,
namely
estimates
of
revenue
and
expenditure
and
a
public
debt
report.  Then
last
Friday
a
Finance
Bill
and
an
Appropriation
Bill
were
published
in
the
Gazette.

We
shall
explain
what
these
documents
are
in
this
bulletin.

The
budget
statement

This
statement
sets
out
among
other
things
the
economic
and
political
environment
in
which
the
budget
is
being
presented
and
explains
the
assumptions
that
underpin
the
budget.  The
statement
also
looks
at
the
future
outlook
in
terms
of
economic
growth
and
the
overall
amounts
that
are
to
be
allocated
or
appropriated
to
Ministries,
departments,
agencies,
commissions
and
other
national
institutions.

The
budget
statement
delivered
by
the
Minister
on
the
28th
November
can
be
accessed
on
the
Veritas
website [link].

The
estimates
of
revenue
and
expenditure

The
estimates
set
out
in
detail
the
Government’s
estimated
revenues
and
expenditures
for
the
coming
year,
indicating
the
specific
sectors
from
which
the
revenues
will
come
and
the
proposed
expenditure
of
each
Ministry,
department
and
agency.

Before
the
days
of
computers,
the
estimates
were
printed
in
a
book
with
a
blue
paper
cover;  hence
they
are
colloquially
called
“the
blue
book”.

The
estimates
tabled
by
the
Minister
last
month
can
be
accessed
on
the
Veritas
website [link].

Debt
Statement

Section
300(4)(b)
of
the
Constitution
compels
the
Minister
of
Finance
to
take
Parliament
into
his
confidence
about
the
national
debt.  The
section
reads:

“(4) The
Minister
responsible
for
finance
must—

(b)
at
the
same
time
as
estimates
of
revenue
and
expenditure
are
laid
before
the
National
Assembly
in
terms
of
section
305,
table
in
Parliament
a
comprehensive
statement
of
the
public
debt
of
Zimbabwe.”

The
statement
must
be
“comprehensive”,
meaning
it
should
be
complete
and
detailed.  It
should
contain
the
following
details:
the
names
of
all
lenders
and
the
full
amounts
they
have
lent,
the
rate
of
interest
payable
on
each
of
their
loans,
and
the
extent
to
which
the
State
is
in
arrears
in
making
repayments.  In
other
words,
the
statement
should
explain
the
country’s
debt
performance
in
sufficient
detail
to
keep
the
National
Assembly
fully
abreast
of
the
country’s
indebtedness.

Readers
can
assess
the
accuracy
and
completeness
of
this
year’s
statement
by
accessing
it
on
the
Veritas
website [link]
It
shows
that
as
of
the
30th
September
2024
Zimbabwe’s
public
debt
and
publicly
guaranteed
debt
amounted
to
US
$21,1
billion. 
A
significant
portion
of
this

US
$12,3
billion

is
foreign
and
the
rest
is
domestic.

Appropriation
Bill

This
Bill
sets
out
the
total
amount
of
money
appropriated,
or
allocated,
to
each
government
Ministry
and
department
and
other
institution.  The
Bill
is
mandated
by
section
305(4)
of
the
Constitution,
which
reads:

“(4) When
the
National
Assembly
has
approved
the
estimates
of
expenditure
for
a
financial
year,

the
Minister
responsible
for
finance
must
cause
a
Bill
to
be
known
as
Appropriation
Bill
to
be
introduced
into
the
National
Assembly,
and
that
Bill
must—

(a)
provide
for
money
to
be
issued
from
the
Consolidated
Revenue
Fund
to
meet
the
approved
expenditure;  and

(b)
appropriate
money
to
the
purposes
specified
in
the
estimates,
under
separate
votes
for
the
different
heads
of
expenditure
that
have
been
approved.”

The
Appropriation
Bill
is
brought
up
in
the
National
Assembly
as
soon
as
the
estimates
have
been
approved
by
the
Committee
of
Supply.  The
various
readings
of
the
Bill
are
expedited
in
terms
of
S.O.
125
of
the
Assembly’s
Standing
Orders.

The
Appropriation
Bill
for
next
year
was
published
in
last
Friday’s
Gazette
and
can
be
accessed
on
the
Veritas
website [link].

Finance
Bill

This
Bill
sets
out,
in
legal
form,
how
the
Government
is
going
to
raise
the
revenue
needed
to
meet
its
projected
expenditure
in
the
coming
year.  Most
government
revenue
is
raised
through
taxes
and
duties
of
various
kinds,
so
Finance
Bills
amend
taxing
statutes

the
Income
Tax
Act
and
the
Value
Added
Tax
Act,
for
example

to
increase
and
adjust
taxes
in
order
to
raise
the
necessary
revenue.  Finance
Bills
must,
according
to
Constitution,
be
confined
to
taxation
and
the
raising
of
revenue

see Economic
Governance
Watch
1/2024 [link
but
in
recent
years
they
have
contained
clauses
on
a
wide
variety
of
other
matters.

A
departmental
draft
of
the
Bill
is
often
published
as
soon
as
the
Minister
has
delivered
his
budget
statement,
but
even
if
it
isn’t
the
Bill
itself
should
be
published
in
time
for
it
be
passed
by
the
National
Assembly
together
with
the
Appropriation
Bill.

The
current
Finance
Bill
was
published
in
the
Gazette
together
with
the
Appropriation
Bill
and
it
can
be
accessed
on
the
Veritas
website [link]
It
proposes
the
following
new
taxes:


  • Rental
    Income
    Tax
    :
     Properties
    converted
    from
    residential
    to
    business
    use
    will
    attract
    a
    25
    per
    cent
    tax
    on
    their
    rental
    income.

  • Betting
    Tax
    :
     A
    10
    per
    cent
    withholding
    tax
    on
    gross
    winnings
    of
    sports
    betting
    punters,
    effective
    from
    the
    1st
    January,
    2025.

  • Fast
    Foods
    Tax
    :
     A
    0.5
    per
    cent
    tax
    on
    the
    sales
    value
    of
    fast
    food
    items
    like
    pizzas,
    burgers
    and
    French
    fries,
    effective
    from
    the
    1st
    January,
    2025.

  • Plastic
    Carrier
    Bag
    Tax
    :
     A
    20
    per
    cent
    tax
    on
    the
    sale
    value
    of
    plastic
    carrier
    bags,
    to
    promote
    biodegradable
    alternatives.

These
last
two
taxes
in
particular
are
directed
less
at
increasing
State
revenues
and
more
at
achieving
socially
beneficial
results
such
as
encouraging
people
to
eat
healthy
foods
rather
than
fast
foods
and
promoting
biodegradable
bags
over
plastic
bags.

Conclusion

The
above-mentioned
statements
or
documents
are
what
makes
up
the
national
budget.
It
should
be
noted
that
the
National
Assembly
has
the
power
to
approve,
amend
or
reject
the
Minister’s
proposals
during
debate.  This
seldom
happens,
however,
partly
because
of
time
constraints
imposed
by
the
Assembly’s
Standing
Orders.

The
2025
budget
is
currently
under
debate
in
National
Assembly
and
technically
the
budget
should
be
passed
before
the
end
of
January
2025.



Veritas
makes
every
effort
to
ensure
reliable
information,
but
cannot
take
legal
responsibility
for
information
supplied.

Post
published
in:

Featured