Morning Docket: 09.05.24 – Above the Law

Anna
Delvey
(Photo
by
Alexi
Rosenfeld/Getty
Images
for
ABA)

*
Anna
Delvey
says
law
enforcement
gave
her
permission
to
do
Dancing
with
the
Stars
during
her
house
arrest
while
wearing
an
ankle
monitor,
which
doesn’t
sound
like
something
federal
authorities
would
do,
but
if
you
can’t
take
Anna
Delvey
at
her
word
then
who
can
you
trust?
[Hollywood
Reporter
]

*
Indictment
reveals
Russian
intelligence
paid
useful
idiot
webcasters
hundreds
of
thousands
of
dollars
to
pump
out
content.
[CNN]

*
Jack
Smith
just
filed
an

ex
parte
,
in
camera,
under
seal
classified
document
in
the
insurrection
case.
Roughly
at
the
same
time
the
DOJ
dropped
its
Russian
intelligence
indictment
for
whatever
that’s
worth.
[Newsweek]

*
Harlan
Crow
finally
agreed
to
provide
the
Senate
with
some
documents
surrounding
his
gifts
to
Clarence
Thomas
and
it
only
revealed

further
suspicious
activity

and
possible
tax
violations
so
he’s
back
to
not
cooperating.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
New
Midlevel
Associates
survey
dropped.
[American
Lawyer
]

*
Hunter
Biden
tax
trial
set
to
begin.
[Reuters]

*
Ghost
gun
manufacturer
ghosting
its
own
lawyer
in
suit
over
girl’s
killing.
[Gothamist]

Law Firm’s Founding Partner Allegedly Gambled Away Client Funds At Nearby Casino – Above the Law

Say
it
with
me
now:
The
word
“client”
in
the
phrase
“your
client’s
money”
is
not
silent!
You
can’t
just
take
what’s
not
yours,
even
if
you
intend
on
paying
it
back
later.
That
fundamental
fact
of
practice
is
drilled
into
your
head
as
you
study
for
the
MPRE,
but
that
doesn’t
stop
lawyers
from
failing
when
tested
in
real
life.

The
Ledger

recently
covered
a
law
firm
partner
who
is
being
sued
for
allegedly
misappropriating
his
client’s
funds:

A
civil
lawsuit
filed
in
Polk
County
accuses
the
owner
of
a
law
firm
that
recently
closed
its
three
offices
of
diverting
nearly
$1.8
million
from
a
client’s
trust
fund
to
his
personal
account.

In
the
lawsuit,
the
surviving
children
of
a
Pennsylvania
man
say
that
Jason
Penrod
confessed
to
depleting
the
trust
fund
and
using
the
money
to
gamble
at
the
Seminole
Hard
Rock
Casino
in
Tampa.

His
firm,
Elder
Family
Law,
marketed
itself
as
dedicated
to
assisting
the
elderly
and
their
families
with
the
challenges
that
accompany
aging
(LinkedIn).
What
Penrod
failed
to
mention
was
that
those
challenges
included
money
burning
a
hole
in
their
pocket.
Over
a
period
of
three
months,
Penrod
allegedly
wired
money
from
one
of
his
client’s
accounts
and
spent
it
gambling
at
Seminole
Hard
Rock
casino.

He
has
since
taken
steps
to
address
the
alleged
abuse
of
his
client’s
trust.
The
Ledger
also
covered

his
decision
to
report
himself
to
the
Florida
Bar

for
falsely
using
two
of
his
clients
funds
and
requested
several
penalties:
disciplinary
revocation
and
the
loss
of
ability
to
practice
law
in
Florida
with
the
option
of
later
applying
for
readmission.

Penrod
has
also
tried
to
make
his
victims
whole.
He
reportedly
laid
out
an
apology
and
several
repayment
options:

Penrod
proposed
a
repayment
plan
based
on
a
10-year
promissory
note,
with
payments
made
quarterly.
The
letter
mentions
options
for
early
payments:
transferring
ownership
or
equity
of
his
Lake
Wales
office
building;
naming
the
plaintiffs
as
beneficiaries
on
a
life-insurance
policy;
accessing
his
401k
funds;
and
sharing
profits
from
his
law
firm,
which
grosses
over
$2
million
annually,
he
wrote.

Per
the
complaint,
Penrod
shared
that
his
compulsive
gambling
happened
at
a
time
while
he
was
struggling
with
mental
health
issues.
While
that
doesn’t
excuse
his
behavior,
there’s
no
doubt
that
there
is
a

connection
between
gambling,
depression,
and
anxiety
.
There
is
more
to
life
than
work.
If
you
or
someone
you
know
is
struggling
with
gambling
addiction
and
is
in
need
help,
the

National
Problem
Gambling
Hotline

has
resources
for
you.
There
is
also
a

lawyer
assistance
program

in
your
state
that
may
be
able
to
help
you.
(Don’t
be
fooled
by
the
name;
these
programs
also
provide
services
to
law
students).
Please
reach
out
if
you
need
assistance.


Suit
Alleges
Owner
Of
Polk
County
Law
Firm
Stole
$1.8M
From
Client’s
Trust,
Lost
It
Gambling

[The
Ledger]



Chris
Williams
became
a
social
media
manager
and
assistant
editor
for
Above
the
Law
in
June
2021.
Prior
to
joining
the
staff,
he
moonlighted
as
a
minor
Memelord™
in
the
Facebook
group Law
School
Memes
for
Edgy
T14s
.
 He
endured
Missouri
long
enough
to
graduate
from
Washington
University
in
St.
Louis
School
of
Law.
He
is
a
former
boatbuilder
who
cannot
swim, a
published
author
on
critical
race
theory,
philosophy,
and
humor
,
and
has
a
love
for
cycling
that
occasionally
annoys
his
peers.
You
can
reach
him
by
email
at [email protected] and
by
tweet
at @WritesForRent.

Biglaw Firm’s Mission To End Revenge Porn – Above the Law

There
are
a
lot
of
great
things
about
the
internet.
Seriously,
all
of
the
world’s
information
in
right
at
your
fingertips

I
cannot
imagine
how
people
owned
houses
and
were
able
to
fix
a
single
thing
without
YouTube
how-to
videos.
But
there’s
also
a
dark
side.

One
of
the
most
pernicious
negatives
of
online
life
is
revenge
porn.
That
is,
sexual
explicit
images
or
videos
posted
online
without
the
subject’s
permission.
The
Data
and
Society
Research
Institute

estimates

that
1
in
25
Americans
are
threatened
by
or
victimized
by
revenge
porn.
And
one
Biglaw
firm
is
doing
something
about
it.

Ten
years
ago,
K&L
Gates
founded
the
Cyber
Civil
Rights
Project.
Since
then,
400
volunteers
from
33
of
K&L
Gates’
global
offices
have
logged
28,000+
hours
to
the
effort.
Program
co-founder
David
Bateman

told
Law.com

there
were
some
challenges
starting
the
practice,
“There
were
two
concurrent
problems
at
the
time:
there
really
were
no
laws
and
no
lawyers
with
expertise
on
how
to
deal
with
social
media.
It
sounds
like,
‘Well,
it
was
only 10
years
ago,’
but
a
lot
happens
in
the
technology
world
and
legal
world
in
10
years.
Now
we
have
really
robust
revenge
porn
statutes
and
people
are
more
familiar
with
it,
but
at
the
time
no
one
really
knew
what
to
do.
Victims
had
nowhere
to
go
and
didn’t
have
lawyers
to
go
to.”

But
10
years
later,
the
scourge
of
revenge
porn
continues.
Bateman
said,
“The
reason
it
has
lasted
so
long
is
that
the
behavior
has
not
gone
away.
People
are
still
doing
the
same
thing.
As
with
all
internet
bad
behavior,
you
never
stop
it
by
litigation.
You
can’t
sue
everybody,
you
can’t
arrest
everybody.
The
reality
is,
the
only
thing
that
changes
behavior
is
education.”

The
firm’s
pro
bono
committee
vice
chair
Amy
Groff
says
they
receive
an
average
of
33
requests
for
help
a
week.
K&L
Gates
attorneys
are
able
to
meet
the
demand
for
their
services,
in
part
because
the
firm
allows
pro
bono
hours
to
count
towards
billable
hour
targets.

And
Bateman
says
the
firm’s
experience
in
this
area
allowed
them
to
devise
a
system
for
dealing
with
the
issue.

“We
go
in
order
of
priority.
No.
1
is
to
get
things
taken
down.
The
longer
they
stay
up,
the
more
likely
the
images
will
be
copied,
go
viral,
and
stay
on
the
internet
forever,”
Bateman
said.
“No.
2
is
getting
to
the
poster
and
getting
him
to
stop.
It
usually
is
a
him.
This
is
not
a
gender-neutral
problem.

Getting
them
to
stop and
making
sure
they’re
not
reposting
the
images
and
destroying
all
of
our
efforts.

“That’s
more
of
an
art
than
a
science,”
he
continued,
noting
that
the
act
of
posting
revenge
porn
is
typically
rooted
in
a
sudden
sense
of
anger.
“Often

upon
reflection
the
guy
decides
to
behave
better.
Sometimes
with
a
letter
of
a
large
law
firm
that
says,
‘Hey,
we’re
representing
this
woman,
you
better
stop
or
you’ll
be
in
trouble.’

The
cease
and
desist
letters
are
surprisingly
effective
in
changing
people’s
behaviors.”

Beyond
that,
there
are
a
variety
of
potential
criminal
or
civil
remedies
a
victim
can
pursue,
which
have
been
bolstered
by
an
increase
in
laws
against
revenge
porn.
As
Bateman
notes,
“These
days,
[civil
litigation]
is
just
a
lot
easier
now
that
there
are
so
many
state
and
federal
statutes
that
give
very
concrete
and
positive
relief
to
a
victim
who
wants
to
be
a
plaintiff.”




Kathryn Rubino HeadshotKathryn
Rubino
is
a
Senior
Editor
at
Above
the
Law,
host
of

The
Jabot
podcast
,
and
co-host
of

Thinking
Like
A
Lawyer
.
AtL
tipsters
are
the
best,
so
please
connect
with
her.
Feel
free
to
email

her

with
any
tips,
questions,
or
comments
and
follow
her
on
Twitter

@Kathryn1
 or
Mastodon

@[email protected].

Morning Docket: 09.05.24 – Above the Law

Anna
Delvey
(Photo
by
Alexi
Rosenfeld/Getty
Images
for
ABA)

*
Anna
Delvey
says
law
enforcement
gave
her
permission
to
do
Dancing
with
the
Stars
during
her
house
arrest
while
wearing
an
ankle
monitor,
which
doesn’t
sound
like
something
federal
authorities
would
do,
but
if
you
can’t
take
Anna
Delvey
at
her
word
then
who
can
you
trust?
[Hollywood
Reporter
]

*
Indictment
reveals
Russian
intelligence
paid
useful
idiot
webcasters
hundreds
of
thousands
of
dollars
to
pump
out
content.
[CNN]

*
Jack
Smith
just
filed
an

ex
parte
,
in
camera,
under
seal
classified
document
in
the
insurrection
case.
Roughly
at
the
same
time
the
DOJ
dropped
its
Russian
intelligence
indictment
for
whatever
that’s
worth.
[Newsweek]

*
Harlan
Crow
finally
agreed
to
provide
the
Senate
with
some
documents
surrounding
his
gifts
to
Clarence
Thomas
and
it
only
revealed

further
suspicious
activity

and
possible
tax
violations
so
he’s
back
to
not
cooperating.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
New
Midlevel
Associates
survey
dropped.
[American
Lawyer
]

*
Hunter
Biden
tax
trial
set
to
begin.
[Reuters]

*
Ghost
gun
manufacturer
ghosting
its
own
lawyer
in
suit
over
girl’s
killing.
[Gothamist]

Identifying Your Firm’s Top Business Priorities – Above the Law

Solo
practitioners
and
small
firm
lawyers
can
sometimes
feel
like
they’re
operating
on
an
island,
making
their
own
way
in
the
legal
and
business
world
without
clear
benchmarks
to
guide
their
decision-making.

In
this
new
survey
of
more
than

100
professionals

at
small
and
smaller
midsize
law
firms,
iManage
and
Above
the
Law
shed
new
light
on
the
priorities
and
successes
of
these
organizations.

Download
the
report
today
to
explore:

  • What
    small
    firms
    see
    as
    their
    top
    business
    and
    technology
    priorities
  • How
    their
    priorities
    are
    aligning
    with
    their
    capabilities
  • The
    benefits
    and
    risks
    of
    generative
    artificial
    intelligence
  • How
    tech
    is
    already
    helping
    small
    firms
    meet
    their
    business
    goals

Morning Docket: 09.05.24 – Above the Law

Anna
Delvey
(Photo
by
Alexi
Rosenfeld/Getty
Images
for
ABA)

*
Anna
Delvey
says
law
enforcement
gave
her
permission
to
do
Dancing
with
the
Stars
during
her
house
arrest
while
wearing
an
ankle
monitor,
which
doesn’t
sound
like
something
federal
authorities
would
do,
but
if
you
can’t
take
Anna
Delvey
at
her
word
then
who
can
you
trust?
[Hollywood
Reporter
]

*
Indictment
reveals
Russian
intelligence
paid
useful
idiot
webcasters
hundreds
of
thousands
of
dollars
to
pump
out
content.
[CNN]

*
Jack
Smith
just
filed
an

ex
parte
,
in
camera,
under
seal
classified
document
in
the
insurrection
case.
Roughly
at
the
same
time
the
DOJ
dropped
its
Russian
intelligence
indictment
for
whatever
that’s
worth.
[Newsweek]

*
Harlan
Crow
finally
agreed
to
provide
the
Senate
with
some
documents
surrounding
his
gifts
to
Clarence
Thomas
and
it
only
revealed

further
suspicious
activity

and
possible
tax
violations
so
he’s
back
to
not
cooperating.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
New
Midlevel
Associates
survey
dropped.
[American
Lawyer
]

*
Hunter
Biden
tax
trial
set
to
begin.
[Reuters]

*
Ghost
gun
manufacturer
ghosting
its
own
lawyer
in
suit
over
girl’s
killing.
[Gothamist]

Midlevel Biglaw Associates Aren’t Too Keen To ‘Return To Pre-Pandemic Norms’ Because They’ve Never Experienced Them Before – Above the Law

Are
pandemic-era
midlevels
satisfied
with
Biglaw’s
culture?

Making
it
to
midlevel
in
Biglaw
isn’t
easy,
especially
when
almost
all
you
know
is
pandemic
Biglaw
life.
Today’s
midlevels

third-,
fourth-
and
fifth-year
associates

worked
incredibly
long
hours
during
the
uncertain
times
COVID-19
brought
upon
the
legal
profession
and
the
world
at
large,
and
now
they’re
being
brought
back
to
the
office
in
the
name
of
a
culture
they’ve
never
really
had
the
opportunity
to
fully
experience.

That
is,
of
course,
no
easy
task,
but
if
you

did

make
it
to
your
firm’s
midlevel
ranks
during
the
past
few
years,
it
was
arguably
more
difficult
than
ever

and
these
associates
just
aren’t
feeling
it
anymore.
The

American
Lawyer

just
released
its
midlevel
associates
survey,
and
as
noted
by
Dan
Roe,
“a
return
to
pre-pandemic
norms
isn’t
cutting
it
for
the
first
full
generation
of
midlevels
to
launch
their
careers
during
COVID-19.”
He
goes
on
to
explain
that
today’s
midlevel
simply
aren’t
yearning
to
go
back
to
Biglaw’s
pre-pandemic
norms:

If
you’re
a
Big
Law
partner
trying
to
understand
why
your
midlevel
associates
aren’t
rising
to
the
occasion
the
way
you
did,
think
back
to
how
things
were
back
in
the
day.

Got
it?
Now
forget
it
all.

Today’s
elder
midlevels—fifth-year
associates—had
six
months
on
the
job
at
most
before
COVID-19
shut
the
world
down.
Fourth-years
were
the
first
class
to
take
the
bar
exam
online.
Third-year
associates
joined
during
the
peak
of
the
Delta
variant.

In
other
words,
they
have
almost
no
frame
of
reference
regarding
pre-pandemic
life
in
Big
Law.

To
come
up
with
these
results,
Am
Law
asked
midlevel
associates
to
evaluate
how
satisfied
they
are
with
their
firm
on
a
variety
of
different
questions:
compensation
and
benefits;
training
and
guidance;
relations
with
partners
and
other
associates;
interest
in
and
satisfaction
level
with
the
work;
the
firm’s
policy
on
billable
hours;
and
management’s
openness
about
firm
strategies
and
partnership
chances.

Overall,
midlevels
seem
to
be
a
little
happier
compared
to
last
year,
with
satisfaction
increasing
from
4.312
to
4.364
out
of
five.
But
was
that
because
their
year
may
have
been
easier?
As
noted
by
Am
Law,
billable
hours
fell
3.5%
on
average
since
the
2023
survey
came
out,
while
annual
billable
requirements
were
flat
at
1,932
hours
on
average.
Despite
their
slightly
higher
satisfaction,
there
may
still
be
trouble
in
paradise:

Not
all
indicators
of
midlevel
satisfaction
improved,
however.
Fewer
midlevels
said
their
firms
offered
flexible
work
arrangements,
mental
health
services,
and
onsite
or
accessible
health
care
services.

Firms
may
also
be
tightening
up
policies
on
billable
hours,
with
midlevels
indicating
that
fewer
firms
were
offering
billable
credit
for
shadowing
partners,
professional
development
and
pro
bono.
Perhaps
most
telling
of
all:
The
likelihood
of
midlevels
to
stay
at
their
current
firm
in
two
years
dropped
by
0.3
on
a
0-to-5
scale.

That
said,
let’s
get
down
to
the
rankings.
The
full
list
is
available

here
,
but
these
are
the
firms
that
make
the
top
25
in
terms
of
midlevel
satisfaction:

1.
O’Melveny
&
Myers
2.
Blank
Rome
3.
Morgan
Lewis
4.
McDermott
Will
&
Emery
5.
Proskauer
Rose
6.
Gibbons
7.
Kirkland
&
Ellis
8.
Goulston
&
Storrs
9.
Baker
&
Hostetler
10.
Mayer
Brown
11.
Clifford
Chance
12.
Gibson
Dunn
13.
Akin
14.
Susman
Godfrey
15.
Kramer
Levin
16.
Eversheds
Sutherland
17.
Fried
Frank
18.
Snell
&
Wilmer
19.
Munger
Tolles
20.
Paul
Hastings
21.
Cahill
Gordon
22.
Manatt
Phelps
&
Phillips
22.
Sullivan
&
Worcester
24.
Fish
&
Richardson
25.
Sheppard
Mullin

Congratulations
to
all
the
firms
that
made
the
list

and
to
the
midlevels
who
have
jobs
they’re
relatively
happy
with,
all
things
considered.
Who
knows,
maybe
they’ll
grow
to
enjoy
the
Biglaw
culture
they
never
knew
during
the
pandemic
years
through
time
spent
at
the
office.


The
2024
Midlevel
Associates
Survey:
The
Rankings

[American
Lawyer]

Amnesia:
How
to
Keep
Your
Midlevel
Associates
Happy

[American
Lawyer]



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on

X/Twitter

and

Threads

or
connect
with
her
on

LinkedIn
.

Morning Docket: 09.05.24 – Above the Law

Anna
Delvey
(Photo
by
Alexi
Rosenfeld/Getty
Images
for
ABA)

*
Anna
Delvey
says
law
enforcement
gave
her
permission
to
do
Dancing
with
the
Stars
during
her
house
arrest
while
wearing
an
ankle
monitor,
which
doesn’t
sound
like
something
federal
authorities
would
do,
but
if
you
can’t
take
Anna
Delvey
at
her
word
then
who
can
you
trust?
[Hollywood
Reporter
]

*
Indictment
reveals
Russian
intelligence
paid
useful
idiot
webcasters
hundreds
of
thousands
of
dollars
to
pump
out
content.
[CNN]

*
Jack
Smith
just
filed
an

ex
parte
,
in
camera,
under
seal
classified
document
in
the
insurrection
case.
Roughly
at
the
same
time
the
DOJ
dropped
its
Russian
intelligence
indictment
for
whatever
that’s
worth.
[Newsweek]

*
Harlan
Crow
finally
agreed
to
provide
the
Senate
with
some
documents
surrounding
his
gifts
to
Clarence
Thomas
and
it
only
revealed

further
suspicious
activity

and
possible
tax
violations
so
he’s
back
to
not
cooperating.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
New
Midlevel
Associates
survey
dropped.
[American
Lawyer
]

*
Hunter
Biden
tax
trial
set
to
begin.
[Reuters]

*
Ghost
gun
manufacturer
ghosting
its
own
lawyer
in
suit
over
girl’s
killing.
[Gothamist]

Illumina’s European Court Victory Can’t Salvage Grail Acquisition, But It Nullifies Hefty Fine – MedCity News

Throughout
Illumina’s
more
than
four-year
saga
to
acquire
liquid
biopsy
company
Grail,
it
insisted
the
opposition
from
European
regulators
has
no
basis
in
law.
Europe’s
highest
judicial
body
now
agrees.
The
court’s
ruling
Tuesday
is
too
little
too
late,
as
Grail
has
already
spun
out
from
Illumina.
But
the

legal
decision

does
spare
Illumina
from
paying
what
would
have
been
a
record
fine.

The
fine
of
€432
million
(about
$476
million),
represented
about
10%
of
Illumina’s
annual
revenue.
It’s
the
stiffest
penalty
the
European
Commission
can
impose
under
European
merger
law.
The
commission
levied
it
because

Illumina
closed
the
Grail
acquisition
before
the
regulator
could
complete
its
review
.
But
the
Court
of
Justice
of
the
European
Union
said
the
proposed
acquisition
should
have
never
even
come
under
such
review.

Gene-sequencing
giant
Illumina
is
based
in
San
Diego
and
does
business
globally.
Grail
developed
and
commercialized
a
multi-cancer
early
detection
test
that
looks
for
signs
of
cancer
from
a
small
sample
of
blood.
That
test,
Galleri,
is
only
commercially
available
in
the
U.S.
European
Union
rules
do
permit
the
commission
to
examine
business
combinations
that
do
not
have
a
“European
dimension”
but
still
affect
trade
and
competition
in
EU
territory.
But
the
high
court
said
the
commission
misinterpreted
this
rule.
Grail
has
no
European
revenue
and
does
not
meet
the
threshold
for
examination.
The

court’s
ruling

states
that
absence
of
a
European
dimension
to
the
business
deal
means
it
does
not
fall
under
commission
regulation.

The
commission
had
said
it
examined
the
proposed
Grail
acquisition
at
the
request
of
six
European
Union
members.
That
was
another
mistake,
according
to
the
court.
The
ruling
said
the
national
merger
control
rules
of
the
member
states
making
those
requests
also
do
not
permit
them
to
examine
this
business
deal.

In
a

statement

released
in
response
to
the
ruling,
European
Commission
Executive
Vice-President
Margarethe
Vestager
said
the
regulator
will
carefully
study
the
court’s
judgement
and
its
implications.
But
she
added
that
even
when
turnover
(the
European
term
for
revenue)
figures
are
low,
merger
deals
can
still
pose
anti-competitive
concerns.
She
added
that
there
will
continue
to
be
need
for
review
of
mergers
that
have
competitive
effects
on
Europe,
noting
that
a

2021
commission
evaluation

of
EU
merger
control
found
that
even
small
deals
can
harm
competition
in
Europe.

“A
company
with
limited
turnover
may
still
play
a
significant
competitive
role
on
the
market,
as
a
start-up
with
significant
potential,
or
as
an
important
innovator,”
Vestager
said.
“Killer
acquisitions
seek
to
neutralize
small
but
promising
companies
as
a
possible
source
of
competition.
These
companies’
size
is
often
dwarfed
by
the
large
corporations
that
seek
to
acquire
them,
and
they
should
be
protected
against
the
risk
of
elimination.”

Illumina’s
$8
billion
Grail
acquisition

triggered
antitrust
litigation
in
the
U.S.
and
Europe
.
The
Federal
Trade
Commission
was
concerned
that
Illumina,
as
a
supplier
of
gene-sequencing
equipment
and
reagents
used
in
liquid
biopsy,
would
have
pricing
power
over
Grail’s
competitors.
Late
last
year,

Illumina
said
it
would
stop
further
litigation
and
instead
divest
Grail
.
In
June,

Grail
spun
out
of
Illumina
as
a
standalone,
publicly
traded
company
.
That
divestiture
led
the
FTC
to
dismiss
its
case
against
Illumina
and
Grail
in
August.
Illumina
retains
a
14.5%
stake
in
Grail.
It
also
continues
to
be
a
supplier
to
the
liquid
biopsy
company.

The
Court
of
Justice’s
decision
annuls
the
European
Commission
fine.
As
the
unsuccessful
party
in
the
litigation,
the
European
Commission
must
pay
the
court
costs
of
Illumina
and
Grail,
according
to
the
ruling.

“Today’s
judgment
confirms
Illumina’s
longstanding
view
that
the
European
Commission
exceeded
its
authority
by
asserting
jurisdiction
over
this
merger,”
Illumina
said
in
a

brief
statement
.


Photo:
sinonimas,
Getty
Images

Morning Docket: 09.05.24 – Above the Law

Anna
Delvey
(Photo
by
Alexi
Rosenfeld/Getty
Images
for
ABA)

*
Anna
Delvey
says
law
enforcement
gave
her
permission
to
do
Dancing
with
the
Stars
during
her
house
arrest
while
wearing
an
ankle
monitor,
which
doesn’t
sound
like
something
federal
authorities
would
do,
but
if
you
can’t
take
Anna
Delvey
at
her
word
then
who
can
you
trust?
[Hollywood
Reporter
]

*
Indictment
reveals
Russian
intelligence
paid
useful
idiot
webcasters
hundreds
of
thousands
of
dollars
to
pump
out
content.
[CNN]

*
Jack
Smith
just
filed
an

ex
parte
,
in
camera,
under
seal
classified
document
in
the
insurrection
case.
Roughly
at
the
same
time
the
DOJ
dropped
its
Russian
intelligence
indictment
for
whatever
that’s
worth.
[Newsweek]

*
Harlan
Crow
finally
agreed
to
provide
the
Senate
with
some
documents
surrounding
his
gifts
to
Clarence
Thomas
and
it
only
revealed

further
suspicious
activity

and
possible
tax
violations
so
he’s
back
to
not
cooperating.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
New
Midlevel
Associates
survey
dropped.
[American
Lawyer
]

*
Hunter
Biden
tax
trial
set
to
begin.
[Reuters]

*
Ghost
gun
manufacturer
ghosting
its
own
lawyer
in
suit
over
girl’s
killing.
[Gothamist]