Morning Docket: 12.30.24 – Above the Law

*
Trump
asks
Supreme
Court
to
halt
TikTok
ban.
[Law360]

*
Lawmakers
question
new
judiciary
travel
disclosure
rules
that
seek
to
obscure
travel
before
2022.
Judiciary
expected
to
tell
them
to
pound
sand
and
then
take
a
lobbyist
funded
vacation.
[Reuters]

*
Oklahoma
Attorney
General
dismissed
charges
against
a
police
officer
who
fractured
the
neck
of
a
71-year-old
man

requiring
a
feeding
tube
and
surgery
to
address
brain
bleeding

because
a
few
bad
apples
have
successfully
spoiled
the
bunch.
[NBC
News
]

*
Fifth
Circuit
continues
playing
yo-yo
with
Corporate
Transparency
Act
implementation.
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
White
lawyer
explains
how
law
school
diversity
helped
his
career.
[Harvard
Crimson
]

*
Proposed
regulation
would
set
rules
for
foreign
company
lobbyists.
Presumably
foreign
government
lobbyists
still
get
to
serve
in
the
next
administration
though.
[National
Law
Journal
]

*
Justin
Baldoni’s
lawyers
tease
countersuit
that
will
“shock
everyone.”
[Deadline]

Zimbabwe’s inflation slows to 3.7 pct in December

Source:


Zimbabwe’s
inflation
slows
to
3.7
pct
in
December-Xinhua


According
to
the
ZIMSTAT,
the
downward
trend
in
inflation
in
November
and
December,
from
a
peak
of
37.2
percent
in
October,
reflects
the
prevailing
stability
of
prices
and
the
local
currency,
the
Zimbabwe
Gold
(ZiG),
after
the
central
bank
devalued
it
by
43
percent
in
September.

While
presenting
the
2025
national
budget
to
Parliament
in
November,
Finance
Minister
Mthuli
Ncube
said
he
expects
the
ZiG
month-on-month
inflation
to
remain
stable
and
average
below
3
percent
next
year,
backed
by
tight
fiscal
and
monetary
policies.

He
said
the
2025
fiscal
plan
was
built
on
single-digit
inflation
and
a
stable
exchange
rate
to
create
a
favorable
business
environment.

“Any
deviation
from
these
assumptions,
including
the
widening
of
the
premium
between
the
official
and
parallel
markets,
will
severely
impact
macroeconomic
stability,”
he
said.

Post
published
in:

Business

Zimbabwe to work with Russia, IAEA to establish nuclear energy


Zimbabwe
is
working
with
the
International
Atomic
Energy
Agency
and
Russian
investors
to
establish
nuclear
energy
as
part
of
its
efforts
to
end
the
country’s
chronic
power
shortages,
government
officials
said
Thursday.The
nation
has
expressed
its
interest
in
nuclear
power
to
the
IAEA,
said
Edgar
Moyo,
minister
of
energy
and
power
development,
and
hopes
to
develop
small,
modular
reactors.

“They
have
indicated
their
willingness
to
take
us
through
paces
until
we
get
there,”
Moyo
told
journalists.

Establishing
nuclear
power
is
expensive
and
complex,
said
Joseph
Siegle,
the
director
of
research
at
the
Africa
Center
for
Strategic
Studies
in
Washington,
which
is
the
reason
countries
such
as
South
Africa
and
Egypt
have
sought
Russia’s
assistance.

The
process
is
also
ripe
for
corruption,
he
said,
so
transparency
is
critical.

“Most
economists
would
argue
that
those
deals
cost
far
more
than
are
warranted
for
the
benefits
that
they
would
provide
to
their
economies
and
to
their
societies,”
Siegle
said,
“and
so
there’s
a
worry
that
these
huge
infrastructure
projects
become
a
source
of
corruption,
both
in
the
country
where
it
is
being
built,
but
also
vis-a-vis
the
state-owned
enterprises
that
the
Russians
provide
to
build
the
plant.

“In
the
end,
it
becomes
the
public
in
the
country
that
is
building
the
plant
that
would
be
responsible
for
paying
off
these
costs,”
he
said.

Zimbabwe
says
its
goal
is
to
have
4,000
megawatts
of
power
capacity
by
2035
and
end
years
of
power
cuts
that
can
sometimes
last
up
to
18
hours
per
day.

Siegle
said
Zimbabwe’s
power
needs
do
not
warrant
a
traditional
large-scale
nuclear
reactor
and
suggested
that
the
government
study
the
lasting
impact
of
waste
disposal.

“[This]
has
always
been
a
concern
with
nuclear
energy

what
you
do
with
the
waste,
which
requires
some
10,000
years
for
the
radioactive
elements
to
decay
and
not
pose
a
health
risk
to
society,”
he
said.

Nuclear
power
also
heightens
security
risks,
Siegle
said.

Gloria
Magombo,
secretary
for
energy
and
power
development,
said
at
the
media
briefing
that
Zimbabwe
aims
to
increase
the
use
of
other
renewable
energies
besides
hydropower,
given
the
nation’s
recurring
droughts.

She
mentioned
solar,
wind
and
mini-hydro
stations.

“We
are
we
are
looking
at
coming
in
by
2030
with
up
to
about
2,000
megawatts”
from
those
sources,
Magombo
said.

Zimbabwe’s
current
capacity
for
power
generation
is
about
2,600
megawatts,
according
to
the
government.
The
actual
daily
generation
is
roughly
half
of
that.

Zimbabwe holiday carnage claims 77 lives, leaves 411 injured

HARARE

A
total
of
77
people
lost
their
lives
in
road
traffic
accidents
recorded
in
different
parts
of
the
country
between
December
15
and
Boxing
Day
this
year,
police
have
said.

According
to
a
statement
by
police
spokesperson
Commissioner
Paul
Nyathi
on
Friday,
there
were
1,211
road
traffic
accidents
recorded
in
the
period,
with
65
of
them
resulting
in
death.

Police
said
411
people
were
also
injured
from
the
accidents.

The
number
of
deaths
is
a
slight
increase
compared
to
the
same
period
last
year
in
which
71
people
were
killed.

Of
the
road
accidents
experienced
this
festive
period,
police
said,
106
were
recorded
on
22
December,
with
seven
people
killed
on
the
day
while
38
were
injured.

On
Christmas
Day,
police
added,
104
road
traffic
accidents
were
recorded
with
13
people
being
killed
and
16
injured.

On
26
December,
87
road
traffic
accidents
were
recorded
with
11
people
killed
while
40
were
injured.

Nyathi
attributed
most
of
the
fatal
accidents
to
fatigue
and
negligence
by
private
vehicle
drivers.

“The
Zimbabwe
Republic
Police
has
established
that,
some
accidents
are
caused
by
fatigue
and
negligent
conduct
on
the
part
of
drivers,”
he
said.

Nyathi
said
most
road
traffic
accidents
involved
private
vehicles
in
which
either
drivers
or
passengers
perished.

“The
only
major
road
traffic
accident
involving
public
service
vehicles
was
recorded
on
22nd
December
2024
where
three
buses
collided
and
two
people
died.

Police
said
accidents
involving
pedestrians
trying
to
cross
the
roads
have
also
been
recorded.

“Drivers
are
urged
to
be
observant
especially
when
approaching
built-up
areas
or
places
frequented
by
the
public
including
residential
areas.

“Meanwhile,
the
Zimbabwe
Republic
Police
reiterates
that
drivers
should
avoid
speeding
and
overtaking
in
circumstances
that
are
clearly
not
safe
to
do
so.
Above
all,
motorists
are
implored
not
to
overload
vehicles
when
travelling
on
the
country’s
roads,”
said
Nyathi.

Cast Your Vote! – See Also – Above the Law

*
Someone
pretending
to
represent
Nintendo
is
filing
fake
DMCA
takedown
notices…
just
like
we
hope

“United
Healthcare”
was
a
fake
for
going
after
Luigi
merchandise
.
[The
Verge
]

*
Judge
Pauline
Newman
claims
the
Federal
Circuit
hid
documents
in
a
bid
to
control
the
media
narrative.
If
they
did,
they
did
a
bad
job
of
it
because
almost
every
media
account
of
the
story
begins
with
“So
anyway,
the
Federal
Circuit
illegally
sidelined
Judge
Newman…”
[Bloomberg
Law
News
]

*
Judge
calls
out
Jay-Z
over
complaints
against
Tony
Buzbee.
[Variety]

*
Microsoft
and
the
ABA
set
up
new
project
to
help
asylum
speakers
before
the
new
administration
tries
to
eliminate
asylum.
[ABA
Journal
]

*
New
York
to
begin

engaging
in
protracted
litigation
with
fossil
fuel
companies

fining
fossil
fuel
companies.
[Reuters]

*
LegalCheek’s
most
read
stories
of
the
year.
[LegalCheek]

*
Social
media
stars
head
to
court.
[Daily
Business
Review
]

The Law Firms We Lost In 2024 – Above the Law



Ed.
note:

Welcome
to
our
daily
feature,

Trivia
Question
of
the
Day!


How
many
law
firms
with
more
than
100
attorneys
dissolved
in
2024?


Hint:
This
year
was
a
little
different
from
2023,
where
we
lost
three
firms
that
once
employed
more
than
100
lawyers
(Stroock
&
Stroock
&
Lavan;
Schnader
Harrison
Segal
&
Lewis;
and
Daugherty
Lordan).



See
the
answer
on
the
next
page.



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on BlueskyX/Twitter,
and Threads, or
connect
with
her
on LinkedIn.

How Appealing Weekly Roundup – Above the Law

(Image
via
Getty)




Ed.
Note
:

A
weekly
roundup
of
just
a
few
items
from
Howard
Bashman’s

How
Appealing
blog
,
the
Web’s
first
blog
devoted
to
appellate
litigation.
Check
out
these
stories
and
more
at
How
Appealing.


“What
Judges
Can
Do
for
the
Rule
of
Law
Under
Trump”:
 Nancy
Gertner
and
Joel
Cohen
have this
guest
essay
 online
at
The
New
York
Times.


“Senate
adjourns
without
confirming
D.C.
judges
as
‘vacancy
crisis’
persists;
Local
officials
decried
the
court
vacancies
as
a
problem
for
public
safety”:
 Jenny
Gathright
of
The
Washington
Post
has this
report
.


“The
Supreme
Court
Case
Over
Trans
Youth
Could
Also
Decimate
Women’s
Equality;
The
principle
of
sex
equality
itself
is
at
stake”:
 Law
professor Naomi
Schoenbaum
 has this
essay
 online
at
Politico
Magazine.


“Donna
Adelson
will
stand
trial
for
murder
and
conspiracy
this
June;
Opening
statements
are
expected
to
start
on
or
before
June
9,
according
to
a
new
court
filing”:
 WCTV
of
Tallahassee,
Florida
has this
report
.


“Before
Scopes,
Clarence
Darrow
fought
another
battle.
He
was
accused
of
bribing
a
jury.”
 Christopher
Goffard
of
The
Los
Angeles
Times
has this
report
.

Donald Trump Brags That Daughter Tiffany Trump Graduated ‘No. 1’ In Class – But Georgetown Law Doesn’t Rank Students – Above the Law

Tiffany
Trump
(Photo
by
Alex
Wong/Getty
Images)

Tiffany
Trump

graduated

from
the
Georgetown
Law
in
May
2020,
and
shortly
thereafter,
America’s
then-celebrity
law
student
seemed
to
fade
into
obscurity.
It
is
unknown
whether
she
ever
took
the
bar
exam,
and
it
unknown
whether
she
ever
secured
a
job
within
the
legal
profession.
But
on
the
campaign
trail,
her
father,
Republican
presidential
nominee
Donald
Trump,
is
bringing
his
daughter’s
law
degree
back
to
the
fore.

Last
night,
at
a
campaign
rally
in
North
Carolina,
the
elder
Trump
took
some
time
to
boast
about
his
daughter’s
academic
success
while
at
Georgetown
Law.
“She
was
a
great
student,
and
she
went
to
a
fantastic
law
school,
graduated
No.
1
in
her
class,”
he
said.

Unfortunately,
that
comment
about
her
class
rank
was
a
lie.

NBC
News

has
the
details:

Tiffany
Trump
is
not
on
a

list
of
honors
graduates

for
the
2020
class
published
on
the
school’s
website.
The
Georgetown
University
Law
Center
also
indicated
on
its
website
that
it
does
not
rank
students.

Poor
Tiffany.
Her
father
is
bragging
about
her
nonexistent
law
school
accolades
and
getting
debunked
on
a
national
stage.
The
embarrassment
here
is
real,
and
we
bet
the
would-be
lawyer
isn’t
too
pleased.

We’re
still
waiting
to
see
what
Tiffany
Trump
will
do
with
her
law
degree

and
we’re
certain
that
it’s
not
this.


Trump
says
daughter
Tiffany
Trump
graduated
‘No.
1’
from
law
school
that
doesn’t
have
class
rankings

[NBC
News]



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on

X/Twitter

and

Threads

or
connect
with
her
on

LinkedIn
.

Top Biglaw Firm Crowned As Law Firm Of The Year, Achieving Industry Greatness – Above the Law



Ed.
note
:
Welcome
to
our
daily
feature,

Quote
of
the
Day
.


The
attributes
that
distinguish
Paul
Weiss
in
the
marketplace
today
are
very
different
from
those
that
distinguished
our
firm
in
2008
or
even
2018.
And
make
no
mistake,
we
must
continue
to
tweak
and
fine-tune
these
attributes,
fully
embracing
the
uncomfortable
reality
that
our
firm
will
look
quite
different
in
2028
and
2035
from
today.


I’m
acutely
aware
that
law
firms
are
dynamic,
organic
bodies
that
must
continually
adapt
to
thrive
in
an
increasingly
hostile
and
competitive
environment.
It’s
absolutely
critical
that
we
evaluate,
and
continually
reevaluate,
what
attributes
distinguish
Paul,
Weiss
in
today’s
marketplace
so
that
we
can
adapt
prudently,
make
wise
investments
and
always
operate
from
a
position
ahead
of
the
curve.





Brad
Karp
,
chair
of
Paul
Weiss,
in
comments
given
to
the

American
Lawyer
,
reflecting
on
what
it
took
for
the
firm
to
take
home
the
honorific
title
of

Law
Firm
of
the
Year
for
2024
.
The
elite
firm
was
able
to
thrive
this
past
year,
with
record
profits,
impressive
lateral
hires,
big-time
changes
to
its
compensation
and
partnership
model,
passionate
dedication
to
its
pro
bono
efforts,
and
zealous
representation
in
all
its
ongoing
matters.



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on BlueskyX/Twitter,
and Threads, or
connect
with
her
on LinkedIn.

ATL Holiday Card Contest: The Finalists! (2024) – Above the Law

Hanukkah
and
Christmas
are
nearly
upon
us,
and
everyone
in
the
legal
profession
is
ready
to
ring
in
the
New
Year,
so
it’s
finally
time
to
reveal
the
seven
finalists
for
our
sixteenth
annual
holiday
card
contest.
But
first
let’s
give
shout-outs
to
some
honorable
mentions
(click
on
each
firm’s
name
to
see
its
card):

1.

Armond
Wilson
:
Behold,
another
holiday
blockbuster
card
from
the
nation’s
4th
best
law
firm
in
Patent
Office
litigation,
per

Patexia
.
In
this
Home
Alone-inspired
hit,
our
nominator
behooves
you
to
“Keep
some
claims,
ya
filthy
animal!”

2.

Diaz
Trade
Law
:
“No
one
has
more
fun
asking
CBP
to
forgive
a
client
for
not
paying
$40M
in
duties
over
10
years
than
Diaz
Trade
Law,”
says
our
nominator.
“And
with
47
federal
agencies
involved
in
regulating
imports
of
goods
into
the
United
States,
DTL
truly
means
it
when
they
say
then
untangle
regulations.”

3.

Shaw
Keller
:
Happy
holidays,
from
your
lawyers’
pets!
This
card
features
paintings
of
all
manner
of
pets,
up
to
and
including
a
bird
and
a
horse.
“We
allowed
one
posthumous
pet
because
otherwise
one
of
our
associates
would
have
had
a
plastic
plant,”
says
our
nominator.

And
now,
the
seven
finalists,
in
alphabetical
order.
Again,
click
on
each
firm’s
name
to
view
its
card.
Please
note
that
most
of
these
cards
have
SOUND,
so
you
might
want
to
turn
your
sound
off
or
down,
or
use
headphones.
Explanatory
comments
come
from
firm
representatives
unless
indicated.

1.

Butler
Snow
:
“This
year,
we
decided
to
take
another
compelling
look
at
lawyers
over-lawyering
seemingly
simple
things.
Admittedly,
it’s
a
bit
of
an
extension
of
our
award
winning
2023
holiday
card.
But
if
it’s
not
broke,
don’t
fix
it,
right?”
Yet
another
excellent
submission
from
lawyers
who
can’t
help
themselves
but
to
over-lawyer
everything.
Our
favorite
part
was
when
of
them
said
they
should
stitch
a
suggested
holiday
greeting
disclaimer
on
a
sweater

“This
holiday
greeting
is
for
informational
purposes
only.
It
does
not
constitute
an
offer,
promise,
or
guarantee
of
any
kind.
Peace,
love,
and
joy
are
subjective,
and
experiences
may
vary.”

and
they
actually
did!
(By
the
way,
where
can
we
get
that
sweater?)

2.

Cades
Schutte
:
A
truly
wonderful
holiday
card
that
shares
the
“spirit
of
aloha,”
straight
from
the
Hawaiian
islands.
Our
nominator
says,
“We
feature
our
client,
Furukawa
Living
Treasure,
a
beloved
senior
community
in
Honolulu,
that
was
about
to
be
shut
down
due
to
permitting
issues.
Through
their
tenacity
and
strong
will,
they
survived
and
are
now
celebrating
their
25th
anniversary.
Our
attorneys
were
honored
to
join
Furukawa’s
anniversary
festivities
and
make
origami
aloha
shirt
crafts
with
the
kupuna
(seniors)
of
the
community.”
This
one
made
us
feel
happy

how
very
sweet!

3.

Davis
Wright
Tremaine
:
The
firm’s
“in-house
creative
team,
Studio
DWT,
proudly
presents
a
delightful
3D
animated
holiday
video
set
in
a
whimsical
gingerbread
ski
lodge
and
resort.
This
festive
video
celebrates
the
sweet
moments
that
inspire
us,
connect
us,
and
make
our
shared
successes
possible.
Studio
DWT’s
expert
storytellers
and
film
producers
have
brought
their
unique
vision
to
life,
delivering
a
heartfelt
message
of
warmth
and
joy
for
the
season.”
This
one
is
a
real
work
of
creative
art.
Nice
job!

4.

Harness
IP
:
“Our
video
holiday
card
stands
out
with
its
unique
blend
of
history,
creativity,
and
holiday
cheer.
By
showcasing
historic
patents
on
sleigh
bells,
we
bring
a
fun
twist
to
a
timeless
holiday
tradition,”
says
our
nominator.
“The
whimsical
elf
band
adds
an
extra
layer
of
charm,
turning
the
story
behind
these
classic
inventions
into
an
engaging
musical
celebration.
This
delightful
mix
of
educational
and
festive
elements
creates
a
captivating
narrative
that
connects
the
past
and
present,
making
it
both
entertaining
and
meaningful.
It’s
not
just
a
card—it’s
an
experience
that
captures
the
spirit
of
innovation
and
joy
that
defines
the
holiday
season!”
This
holiday
card
has
everything
you
could
possibly
want

and
you
can
even
download
an
app
to
turn
your
phone
into
a
set
of
sleigh
bells
each
time
you
move
it!
Absolutely
amazing!

5.

Larson

King
:
This
firm
knows
that
Above
the
Law
editors
are
suckers
for
law
revue
videos,
and
this
is
simply
the
best.
The
11-time
holiday
card
contest
finalist
really
stole
the
show
with
this
submission.
From
our
nominator:
“Our
2024
greeting
highlights
Minnesotans’
love
of
music
by
featuring
assorted
parodies
of
throw-back
tunes
with
a
legal
twist.
Take
a
blast
into
the
past
by
listening
to
hits
such
as

We
Be
Billin’

(Run-D.M.C’s

You
Be
Illin’
),

Don’t
Stop
Appealin’

(Journey’s

Don’t
Stop
Believin’
),

Material
Witness

(Madonna’s

Material
Girl
),
and

Brief
It

(Michael
Jackson’s

Beat
It
).
Also
included
is
Minnesota’s
own
Prince,
featuring

I
Wanna
Be
Your
Lawyer

(a
parody
of

I
Wanna
Be
Your
Lover
).
The
songs
were
custom-created
for
this
video
by
a
local
Minneapolis
musician
and
vocalist.”
We’d
definitely
pay
the
low,
low
price
of
$9.99
for
all
of
these
tunes!
We

LOVED

this
one!

6.

McBrayer
:
A
hilarious
take
on
the
Ebenezer
Scrooge
story,
featuring
Bob
Cratchit
as
a
“former
abused
clerk/new
partner.”
This
lawyerly
view
of
the
Christmas
classic
had
us
cracking
up.
From
our
nominator:
“We
like
to
think
that
we
could
have
helped
famous
miser
Ebenezer
Scrooge
find
the
right
path
in
life
without
supernatural
intervention.
Here’s
our
take
on
how,
with
McBrayer
attorneys
playing
the
roles
of
famous
Dickens
characters
or
simply
themselves.
We’re
biased,
but
our
Scrooge
may
be
one
of
the
better
ones
committed
to
screen.”

7.

Morse
:
From
our
nominator:
“This
year
we
decided
to
really
showcase
the
‘human
side’
of
our
team
by
presenting
their
many
creative
talents
in
a
printable,
shareable,
and
downloadable
e-book
full
of
crafty
DIY
projects
and
gift
options!
The
Morse
team
has
been
finding
creative
solutions
to
legal
issues
for
more
than
30
years,
but
did
you
know
we
can
also
make
a
mean
batch
of
holiday
dog
cookies,
whip
up
some
super
cute
snowman
bath
bombs,
or
decoupage
a
favorite
piece
of
furniture??
But
of
course,
when
it
comes
to
your
legal
needs,
don’t
do
it
yourself!
Call
us.
😉”
Wow!
This
e-book
looks
like
it
could
actually
be
very
helpful
for
those
who
need
to
entertain
elementary
school
students
who
are
home
during
winter
break.
Looking
forward
to
creating
homemade
cookie
mason
jars,
sugar
scrub
sand
art,
and
playdough
thanks
to
Morse!

Now
it’s
time
for
our
audience
to
vote.
We’ll
keep
the
polls
open
through

TUESDAY,
DECEMBER
31,
2024,
at
11:30
p.m.

(Eastern
time).
This
gives
you
ample
time
to
campaign
for
your
pick
over
the
holidays
(but
please,
don’t
cheat).



CLICK
HERE
TO
VOTE
.

Thanks
to
all
the
entrants
and
nominators,
good
luck
to
the
finalists,
and
happy
holidays
to
all!
Above
the
Law
is
happy
to
celebrate
holiday
cheer
with
you!



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on BlueskyX/Twitter,
and Threads, or
connect
with
her
on LinkedIn.