Hope with every brick: Zimbabwe’s Rising Star School overcomes resource scarcity

Formed
in
2005,
Hopley,
a
temporary
settlement
in
Zimbabwe’s
capital,
continues
to
grow
in
population
beyond
its
capacity.
It
was
created
to
foster
the
victims
of Operation
Murambatsvina
—an
inhumane
slum-clearing
campaign
by
the
government
that
displaced
thousands
of
Zimbabweans
in
the African nation.
Already
lacking
adequate infrastructure and
basic
amenities
since
its
inception,
the
dire
living
conditions
in
Harare’s
suburbs
continue
to
plague
its
residents.
As
survival
became
a
struggle
with
the
displacement,
thousands
of
students
were
unable
to
go
to
school.

In
2010,
the
citizens
of
Hopley
took
the
initiative
and
founded
the
Rising
Star
School
to
ensure
that
children
got
access
to
education,
in
whatever
capacity
possible.
However,
the
lack
of
resources
limited
the
school’s
functioning,
with
tarpaulins
and
clay
shelters
being
employed
as
classrooms.
These
were
too
narrow,
had
little
light
and
offered
scant
protection
in
the
rainy
season.
The
resolution
of
Hopley’s
residents
was
confined
by
one
limitation—infrastructure.


The
arched
walkway
provides
shading
to
reduce
heat
gain
and
only
allow
diffused
sunlight
into
the
classroomsImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

In
2013,
the school’s
design
 and
construction
was
undertaken
by
German
NGO,
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V,
(Engineers
Without
Borders Germany).
The educational
architecture
 of
otherwise
austere
materiality
stands
out
as
a
behemoth
in
its
context
consisting
of
tiny residential
structures
.
The
tale
of
its
conception
has
been
far
from
steady,
with
construction
unfolding
ever
so
slowly
over
seven
years
and
progressing
through
seven
phases
of
building.


The School is made of almost 600,000 bricks, laid entirely by bricklayers | Rising Star School| Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
The
School
is
made
of
almost
600,000
bricks,
laid
entirely
by
bricklayersImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

One
major
challenge
was
dealing
with
high
groundwater
levels
during
the
monsoon,
which
made
it
impossible
to
lay
the
foundations
during
or
right
after
the
season.
The
school’s
phase-wise
development
allowed
the
students
to
occupy
it
since
the
completion
of
its
first
phase.
The
organisation
described
it
as
‘everyday
co-existence’,
where
children
attended
classes
in
the
completed
portions
of
the
building
while
the
builders
continued
their
work
on
the
next
phase
work
on
the
next
phase
nearby.
Marked
by
perseverance
and
ingenuity
driven
by
a
lack
of
resources,
the
Rising
Star
School
Buildings
now
serves
as
Hopley’s
landmark,
with
its
characteristic brick
structure
 marked
by
arches.


  • The school building’s brick arches provide longer spans and a significantly cheaper alternative to wooden beams | Rising Star School | Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
    The
    school
    building’s
    brick
    arches
    provide
    longer
    spans
    and
    a
    significantly
    cheaper
    alternative
    to
    wooden
    beamsImage:
    Courtesy
    of
    Ingenieure
    ohne
    Grenzen
    e.V.

The educational
institute
 consists
of
14
classrooms
situated
in
three
single-storey
volumes.
The Kindergarten is
housed
on
the
ground
floor
of
a
two-storey
structure,
where
the
first
level
is
occupied
by
the
school
administration
rooms.
The education
buildings
 take
into
account
the
inability
to
provide
active
solutions
for
thermal
comfort
and
hence,
heavily
incorporate
passive
solutions.
The educational
design
 reflects
an
influence
of
the
filigree architecture,
with
an
arched
walkway
protecting
the
classrooms
from
receiving
direct
solar
radiation
while
allowing natural
light
 to
enter.
Built
with
35mm
walls,
the
school
building
acts
as
a
heat
sink
during
the
day
and
maintains
better
ambient
temperature
and
the
openings
in
the facade
design
 and
outer
walls
promote
cross-ventilation.
A
double
roof
enhances
comfort
in
the
classrooms
by
allowing
hot
air
inside
the
building
to
escape,
letting
in
fresh
air
and
enabling
continuous
ventilation.


(L-R) Designed to increase building spans, the arches become characteristic of the buildings' design; Arched walkways and strategic openings protect the classrooms from receiving direct solar radiation while allowing an influx of natural light | Rising Star School | Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
(L-R)
Designed
to
increase
building
spans,
the
arches
become
characteristic
of
the
buildings’
design;
Arched
walkways
and
strategic
openings
protect
the
classrooms
from
receiving
direct
solar
radiation
while
allowing
an
influx
of
natural
lightImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

With
a
lack
of
regulated
and
reliable
water
and
electricity
supply,
apart
from
inadequate
resources,
the
use
of
heavy
machinery
for
construction
was
impossible.
The brick
architecture
 is
entirely
handcrafted,
with
almost
6,00,000
bricks
being
laid
entirely
by
the
bricklayers
and
only
a
few
technical
devices
to
help
them
with
the
construction.
Sourced
from
a
nearby
brick
supplier,
these
were
licensed-fired
clay
bricks,
ensuring
the
high
strength
and
durability
necessary
for
the
arches’
construction.


The openings in the school’s facade allow for cross-ventilation | Rising Star School | Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
The
openings
in
the
school’s
facade
allow
for
cross-ventilationImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

“This
is
why
the
quiet
construction
site,
from
which
Hopley‘s
new
centre
emerged
almost
imperceptibly,
is
no
less
impressive
than
the
result.
Details
of
connections
and
constructions
are
considered
and
optimised
over
the
course
of
the
seven-year
construction
period
and
finally
result
in
the
construction
of
the
two-storey
part,”
the
German
organisation
shares.


The primary school becomes Hopley’s landmark in the vicinity of smaller residential buildings | Rising Star School | Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
The
primary
school
becomes
Hopley’s
landmark
in
the
vicinity
of
smaller
residential
buildingsImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

With
the
dire
lack
of
resources
that
plagued
Hopley,
the
school’s
design
was
born
of
a
need
to
optimise
design
and
construction—as
even
the
use
of
brick
seemed
not
a
consideration,
but
an
inevitability.
Kristina
Ziadeh,
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.’s
architect
and
project
manager
for
the
school
tells
STIR:
“The
inspiration
for
the design lies
above
all
in
the
possibilities
of
the
materials
available
on-site
and
in
the
area
around.
At
the
start
of
the
project,
it
quickly
became
clear
that
brick
was
a
material
that
was
readily
available
and
could
be
an
exciting
material
for
school
construction
thanks
to
people’s
knowledge
of
how
to
build
with
it.
The
aim
was
also
to
utilise
all
the
possibilities
that
the
brick
itself
offers
in
construction.
For
example,
round
arches
made
it
possible
to
achieve
the
necessary
span
for
a
classroom.
The
succession
of
the
so-called
arched
walls
makes
it
possible
to
reduce
the
use
of timber,
which
is
readily
available
in
the
country
but
much
more
cost-intensive.”


The School carries the same materiality as those of the houses in Hopley | Rising Star School | Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
The
School
carries
the
same
materiality
as
those
of
the
houses
in
HopleyImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

The
intangible
impact
of
the
project
was
also
focused
on
supporting
local
businesses,
retailers
and
workers.
Buying
all
building
materials
from
Harare,
the sustainable
structure
 was
constructed
by
builders
who
lived
in
the
school’s
immediate
vicinity—creating
jobs
in
a
low-income
neighbourhood
while
imbibing
a
sense
of
ownership
into
the
residents
that
ensured
future
maintenance.
The
official
statement
by
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.
states,
“Our
goal
was
to
work
together
with
the
residents
of
the
settlement
on
an
equal
level.
We
worked
with
an
experienced
foreman,
bricklayers
and
a
large
number
of
young,
unskilled
assistants
and
offered
them
the
opportunity
to
learn
to
build.”


The new school building is entirely hand-crafted | Rising Star School| Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
The
new
school
building
is
entirely
hand-craftedImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

Ziadeh
recounts
how
in
the
face
of
scarcity,
ingenuity
from
their
builders
enabled
them
to
be
resourceful
and sustainable in
their
design
approach.
“Instead
of
buying
a
product
on
the
market
or
in
stores
for
a
single
use,
we
often
improvised
and
made
our
tools—for
example,
various
tools
for
compacting
the
soil.
A
piece
of
an
old
railway
track
was
turned
into
a
rammer
by
the
local
welder,
or
one
of
the
water
drums
that
was
no
longer
needed
was
filled
with concrete and
fitted
with
a
handle
made
of
reinforcing steel bars.
This
resulted
in
a
roller
for
large-scale
compaction,”
she
elaborates.


Sourced from a nearby brick supplier, the licensed-fired clay bricks ensure the high strength and durability necessary for the arches' construction | Rising Star School| Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
Sourced
from
a
nearby
brick
supplier,
the
licensed-fired
clay
bricks
ensure
the
high
strength
and
durability
necessary
for
the
arches’
constructionImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

Often,
an
architect’s
vision—alongside
the
veiled
superiority
complex—convinces
them
that
‘their
designs’
are
going
to
make
the
world
a
better
place,
often
blinding
them
to
the
realities
of
the
world.
Even
as
the
Rising
Star
School
spans
expansively
in
its
context,
it
does
not
exhibit
unachievable
fantasy.
Built
of
the
same brick as
every
house
in
Hopley,
the
school
showcases
the
potential
of
grit
and
evokes
a
sense
of
aspiration
and
hope.


Rising Star School Buildings for Hopley: Site plan; floor plan; elevation (north); elevation (west); section (single); section (double) | Rising Star School | Ingenieure ohne Grenzen e.V | STIRworld
Rising
Star
School
Buildings
for
Hopley:
Site
plan;
floor
plan;
elevation
(north);
elevation
(west);
section
(single);
section
(double)
from
a
nearby
brick
supplier,
the
licensed-fired
clay
bricks
ensure
the
high
strength
and
durability
necessary
for
the
arches’
constructionImage:
Courtesy
of
Ingenieure
ohne
Grenzen
e.V.

An
exemplary
specimen
that
reflects
a
deeply
embedded
ethos
of community engagement,
the
Rising
Star
School
Buildings
in
Hopley
serves
as
a
beacon
of
hope.
Ziadeh
shared
the
lessons
she
learned:
“Even
if
something
seems
too
complex,
a
solution
can
still
be
found.
I
am
very
grateful
for
my
experience
of
working
and
living
in
a
strong
community.
I
really
appreciate
the
fact
that
there
is
always
someone
who
can
give
you
a
helping
hand.”

Source:


Hope
with
every
brick:
Zimbabwe’s
Rising
Star
School
overcomes
resource
scarcity

Judgment on Zimbabwe activists delayed as SADC meets

<br /> Judgment<br /> on<br /> Zimbabwe<br /> activists<br /> delayed<br /> as<br /> SADC<br /> meets



17.11.2024


16:26

More
than
60
Citizens
Coalition
for
Change
activists
are
being
kept
in
jail
as
the
Southern
African
Development
Community
meets
in
Harare
from
Sunday.



The
opposition
activists
are
on
trial
for
allegedly
taking
part
in
an
illegal
gathering
aimed
at
inciting
public
violence.
Judgment
in
their
trial
has
been
postponed
until
after
the
SADC
meeting.
eNCA
correspondent
Pindai
Dube
reports.
Courtesy



#DStv403

Post
published
in:

Featured


Manage
consent

Interview: Zimbabwe seeks to expand exports to China amid growing trade ties


REUTERS/Philimon
Bulawayo

“Currently,
our
horticulture
exports
primarily
target
markets
in
the
European
Union
and
Britain.
We
are
now
looking
to
diversify,
particularly
focusing
on
exporting
fruits
and
vegetables
to
the
Middle
East
and
Asian
markets,
including
China,
Malaysia
and
Indonesia,”
said
Similo
Nkala,
director
of
operations
at
ZimTrade,
Zimbabwe’s
trade
promotion
agency,
on
Friday.

A
significant
milestone
in
Zimbabwe-China
trade
relations
was
achieved
in
2022
when
the
two
countries
signed
a
citrus
deal,
allowing
Zimbabwean
companies
to
export
fresh
citrus
to
China.

“We
have
also
recently
signed
a
trade
protocol
for
avocado
exports,
which
is
a
major
step
toward
diversifying
our
export
markets,”
Nkala
told
Xinhua.
“Discussions
are
ongoing
for
additional
trade
protocols,
including
those
for
blueberries,
sesame
and
chilies.”

Bilateral
trade
between
Zimbabwe
and
China
has
surged
in
recent
years,
reflecting
the
strengthening
ties
between
the
two
countries.
According
to
the
Chinese
Embassy
in
Zimbabwe,
trade
grew
by
25.6
percent
in
the
first
nine
months
of
2024,
reaching
3
billion
U.S.
dollars.
Zimbabwe
exported
2.1
billion
dollars
worth
of
goods
to
China
while
importing
951
million
dollars,
resulting
in
a
trade
surplus
of
about
1
billion
dollars.

Zimbabwe
enjoys
a
competitive
edge
in
agriculture
due
to
its
fertile
land,
favorable
climate
and
soil
conditions,
Nkala
said.
“There
is
significant
potential
to
increase
our
horticulture
exports,
particularly
fruits
and
vegetables,
to
the
Chinese
market.”

He
added
that
Zimbabwean
exporters
could
improve
their
competitiveness
in
the
vast
Chinese
market
by
consolidating
consignments
to
meet
demand
efficiently.

Zimbabwean
leather
producers
have
also
gained
traction
in
China.
During
the
2024
China
International
Import
Expo
(CIIE),
local
companies
secured
many
orders,
particularly
for
high-demand
leather
products.

The
business
exhibition
of
the
world’s
first
national-level
exposition
dedicated
to
imports
has
attracted
about
3,500
exhibitors
from
129
countries
and
regions
this
year.
Notably,
a
record
high
of
297
Fortune
500
companies
and
industry
leaders
are
attending
the
six-day
expo
that
concluded
on
Nov.
10
in
Shanghai.
And
more
than
400
new
products,
new
technologies
and
new
services
are
unveiled.

“I
have
seen
firsthand
during
trade
fairs
in
China
that
our
leather
products,
are
in
high
demand,”
Nkala
said.

Arts
and
crafts
are
another
promising
sector
for
Zimbabwean
exporters.
Nkala
said
that
artists
participating
in
the
CIIE
generated
over
500,000
dollars
in
business.

“The
potential
is
there,
especially
in
arts
and
crafts,
and
it
remains
largely
untapped,”
he
added.

Post
published
in:

Business

Biglaw Dispute Resolution Partner Goes Low In Parking Dispute – See Also – Above the Law




<br /> Biglaw<br /> Dispute<br /> Resolution<br /> Partner<br /> Goes<br /> Low<br /> In<br /> Parking<br /> Dispute<br /> –<br /> See<br /> Also<br /> –<br /> Above<br /> the<br /> Law


























Want A Federal Clerkship? You Should Consider This Law School. – Above the Law

(Image
via
Getty)



Ed.
Note:

Welcome
to
our
daily
feature

Trivia
Question
of
the
Day!


According
to
the
Princeton
Review’s
2024
Best
Law
School
Rankings,
which
law
school
is
the
best
for
getting
students
federal
clerkships?


Hint:
The
law
school
is
also
perennially
noted
as
one
of
the
top
14
by
U.S.
News
and
is
ranked
the
#3
most
difficult
law
school
to
get
into
by
Princeton
Review.



See
the
answer
on
the
next
page.

Stat(s) Of The Week: Altered States – Above the Law

The
traditional
route
to
becoming
a
lawyer
in
the
United
States
is
to
spend
three
years
and
tens
(or
hundreds)
of
thousands
of
dollars
on
a
law
school
education,
and
then
spend
another
two
months
and
another
few
thousand
dollars
preparing
for
the
bar
exam.


If
you
think
there
has
to
be
a
better
way,
you’re
not
alone.
Earlier
this
year,
the

ABA
endorsed
alternative
pathways

to
attorney
licensing
beyond
the
traditional
bar
exam,
as
a
growing
number
of
states
establish
other
methods
that
focus
more
on
experiential
learning.
For
example:


Earlier
:


Utah
May
Add
A
New
Path
To
Practicing
Law



California
Holds
On
Tight
To
Its
Notoriously
Difficult
Bar
Exam



Nevada
Could
Join
Growing
Number
Of
States
With
Alternatives
To
The
Bar

Conquering Conferences: Nurturing Long-Term Friendships – Above the Law



Ed.
note:

This
is
the
final
installment
in
a
series
providing
a
comprehensive
guide
to
networking
at
conferences.

Read
the
previous
installment
here


In
this
final
chapter
of
“Conquering
Conferences,”
we
delve
into
the
essence
of
networking

building
friendships.


It’s
not
just
about
collecting
business
cards;
it’s
about
finding
your
tribe
and
nurturing
relationships
that
go
beyond
the
conference
halls.


Building
Friendships
(Or
How
to
Be
the
Cool
Kid
in
Conference
Land)
 


Let’s
face
it

knowing
someone’s
favorite
SCOTUS
justice
is
great,
but
finding
out
they
share
your
love
for
karaoke?
That’s
gold.


Remember,
it’s
not
about
how
many
cards
you
collect,
it’s
about
finding
your
tribe
in
this
conference
jungle
gym.


Sometimes,
the
most
memorable
connections
come
from
the
most
unexpected
places.


Early
in
my
career,
at
the
National
Conference
for
the
South
Asian
Bar
Association,
I
saw
an
opportunity
in
the
unexpected.
Among
the
list
of
presenters,
there
was
one
attorney
who
stood
out
because
he
wasn’t
South
Asian.


I
figured
he
might
not
know
many
people
there.
So,
I
reached
out
with
a
simple,
thoughtful
email,
inviting
him
to
join
a
group
dinner.
It
was
a
shot
in
the
dark,
but
it
paid
off.


Not
only
did
he
join
us,
but
that
single
act
of
inclusivity
fostered
a
relationship
that
has
spanned
over
two
decades.
He
became
a
client,
a
friend,
and
an
advisor.


This
experience
taught
me
that
networking
is
more
than
just
exchanging
business
cards;
it’s
about
being
thoughtful,
sometimes
stepping
out
of
your
comfort
zone,
and
seeing
every
individual
as
a
potential
connection.


Networking
at
conferences
shouldn’t
feel
like
a
chore.


It’s
all
about
making
authentic
connections,
not
just
adding
names
to
your
contact
list.
Strive
for
meaningful
interactions
where
you
can
effortlessly
and
comfortably
reach
out.


True
success
lies
not
in
the
quantity
but
the
quality
of
connections
made.
Imagine
creating
five
to10
solid
relationships,
rather
than
a
sea
of
forgettable
handshakes.


These
are
the
connections
that
will
bring
a
sense
of
anticipation
and
excitement
for
future
encounters,
transforming
the
once-dreaded
networking
ritual
into
an
opportunity
for
genuine
friendship
building.


After
the
Conference:
The
Art
of
Keeping
the
Dance
Alive


Once
the
conference’s
final
curtain
falls,
the
real
magic
of
networking
begins.


It’s
about
nurturing
those
five
to
10
meaningful
relationships
you’ve
ignited.
A
follow-up
email
that
recalls
a
personal
tidbit
or
a
professional
insight
shared
during
your
chat
can
work
wonders.


Remember,
the
goal
is
to
transform
a
brief
encounter
into
a
lasting
professional
friendship.


So,
reach
out
with
a
personalized
touch

a
LinkedIn
message,
a
friendly
email,
or
even
a
quick
call
can
keep
the
rhythm
of
your
new
networking
dance
going
long
after
the
conference
lights
have
dimmed.


As
we
conclude
our
series,
remember
that
the
true
magic
of
networking
lies
in
the
relationships
you
cultivate
after
the
conference.


Keeping
the
dance
alive
through
thoughtful
follow-ups
and
genuine
connections
is
the
key
to
transforming
brief
encounters
into
lasting
professional
friendships.


Thank
you
for
joining
me
on
this
journey
through
the
world
of
networking.


May
your
future
conferences
be
less
awkward,
more
rewarding,
and
filled
with
successful
connections.


Have
any
tips
on
how
you’ve
successfully
nurtured
post-conference
connections?
Let’s
hear
those,
too

the
more
creative,
the
merrier!


Final
Steps


✔️
Follow
up
with
new
connections
in
a
personalized
and
thoughtful
manner.
✔️ 
Transform
brief
encounters
into
lasting
professional
relationships.


Your
Turn!


✔️
Share
your
own
tips
and
stories
on
successful
post-conference
follow-ups.




Sejal PatelSejal Patel is
the Founder
of
Sage
Ivy
,
a
New
York-based
consultancy
specializing
in
empowering
attorneys
with
innovative
practice
development
strategies.
With
over
20
years
of
experience,
Sejal
applies
her
expertise
in
assisting
clients
convert
their
relationships
into
revenue
by
applying
individualized
strategies
to
their
networks
and
leveraging
their
unique
styles
authentically.  

Courts Should Not Ask Lawyers To Hurry Up And Wait – Above the Law

One
thing
litigators
know
all
too
well
is
that
most
of
the
time
spent
in
a
courthouse
is
not
spent
on
legal
tasks.
Rather,
lawyers
usually
need
to
wait
for
their
case
to
be
called,
and
the
time
they
spend
in
front
of
a
judge
or
other
court
officer
can
be
rather
limited
compared
to
the
time
they
spend
in
court.
This
is
frustrating,
since
lawyers
could
be
doing
other
activities
rather
than
waiting
in
court,
and
clients
probably
wish
they
did
not
need
to
pay
lawyers
to
sit
idly
around
a
courthouse.
However,
courts
can
manage
their
affairs
in
certain
ways
to
reduce
the
time
lawyers
waste
in
court.

Before
the
COVID-19
pandemic,
it
was
common
for
courts
in
a
jurisdiction
in
which
I
practice
to
schedule
numerous
matters
to
be
heard
at
a
particular
date
and
time.
Dozens
of
lawyers
might
arrive
at
court
for
a
scheduled
9:30
a.m.
appearance
even
though
the
court
could
only
take
the
cases
one
at
a
time.
To
some
extent,
this
makes
sense,
since
people
might
show
up
to
court
a
little
late,
and
the
court
could
hear
cases
in
which
all
of
the
attorneys
were
present
before
other
matters
were
ready
to
be
called.
However,
other
lawyers
wasted
time
waiting
around
since
court
officers
can
only
hear
a
select
number
of
cases
at
a
time.

During
the
COVID-19
pandemic,
this
phenomenon
largely
disappeared.
Courts
usually
scheduled
matters
for
discrete
times,
typically
at
hour
or
half-hour
increments.
Since
people
simply
needed
to
log
into
Zoom
at
a
scheduled
time
rather
than
appear
in
person,
attorneys
showing
up
late
was
rarely
an
issue.
In
this
situation,
attorneys
and
courts
did
not
waste
time
waiting
around
since
there
was
a
set
time
block
to
discuss
matters.

Only
once
did
I
see
a
court
schedule
dozens
of
matters
at
the
same
time
for
Zoom
appearances,
requiring
attorneys
to
wait
while
cases
were
called
into
separate
Zoom
rooms
one
at
a
time.
Since
all
of
us
were
at
home
or
in
our
offices
logging
into
Zoom,
not
much
time
was
wasted,
since
everyone
could
work
on
other
tasks
while
waiting.
However,
parties
waste
the
least
time
when
courts
schedule
specific
periods
to
conduct
court
hearings
so
no
one
has
to
wait
around.

Now
that
remote
proceedings
are
mostly
a
thing
of
the
past
for
many
courts,
judicial
proceedings
are
being
conducted
in
a
similar
way
to
before
COVID-19.
Several
times
this
year,
I
appeared
on
cases
that
were
calendared
for
the
same
time
as
dozens
of
other
cases,
requiring
all
of
the
lawyers
to
wait
in
court
for
hours
while
court
staff
managed
all
of
the
cases
that
had
been
scheduled
for
that
date
and
time.

However,
courts
should
learn
the
lesson
of
the
COVID-19
pandemic,
and
implement
practices
that
reduce
time
wastage.
Many
courts
can
schedule
matters
for
discrete
times
rather
than
order
dozens
of
lawyers
to
show
up
on
a
given
morning
and
just
take
the
cases
one
by
one
as
the
lawyers
fully
appear
on
a
matter.
Perhaps,
for
some
reason

and
I
would
appreciate
someone
explaining
the
reasoning,
if
they
know
it

courts
prefer
to
schedule
matters
en
masse.
Maybe
it
is
a
bigger
administrative
challenge
to
schedule
matters
as
discrete
units
rather
than
just
tell
a
collection
of
lawyers
on
various
cases
to
appear
in
court
on
a
given
morning.
However,
courts
should
consider
scheduling
matters
for
particular
periods
so
that
lawyers
waste
less
time
in
court.




Rothman Larger HeadshotJordan
Rothman
is
a
partner
of




The
Rothman
Law
Firm
,
a
full-service
New
York
and
New
Jersey
law
firm.
He
is
also
the
founder
of




Student
Debt
Diaries
,
a
website
discussing
how
he
paid
off
his
student
loans.
You
can
reach
Jordan
through
email
at





[email protected]
.

Biglaw’s Congressional Investigations Practices Expected To Be On Fire Under Trump 2.0 – Above the Law



Ed.
note
:
Welcome
to
our
daily
feature,

Quote
of
the
Day
.


I
don’t
think
that
there’s
a
single
industry
that’s
safe
anymore,
safe
meaning
like
off-limits
from
investigations.





Michael
Bell
,
a
partner
at
Hogan
Lovells,
in
comments
given
to
the

National
Law
Journal
,
on
why
Biglaw
congressional
investigations
practices
are
getting
ready
for
more
work
in
2025,
when
the
White
House
and
Congress
will
be
controlled
by
Republicans.
“From
a
pure
bandwidth
perspective,
there
could
be
some
impact,
certainly
at
the
beginning
of
the
new
administration,
where
there
will
be
a
huge
focus
on
confirming
appointees
to
the
various
positions
within
the
Trump
administration,”
Bell
continued.
“And
that
will
take
up
a
significant
portion
of
the
bandwidth
in
the
Senate,
and
so
it
may
delay,
or
slow,
to
some
extent,
the
initiation
of
some
investigations,
but
I
do
think
over
time,
we’re
going
to
see
a
fairly
significant
increase
in
that
activity
in
the
Senate.”



Staci ZaretskyStaci
Zaretsky
 is
a
senior
editor
at
Above
the
Law,
where
she’s
worked
since
2011.
She’d
love
to
hear
from
you,
so
please
feel
free
to

email

her
with
any
tips,
questions,
comments,
or
critiques.
You
can
follow
her
on

X/Twitter

and

Threads

or
connect
with
her
on

LinkedIn
.

Rudy’s Lawyers Are Pulling The Ripcord – Above the Law

Rudy
Giuliani

goes
through
lawyers

like
he
goes
through
wives

quickly,
and
leaving
a
trail
of

resentment

and

unpaid
bills

in
his
wake.

America’s
erstwhile
Mayor
is
currently
in
multiple
federal
and
state
courts
defending
his
honor,
along
with
whatever
is
left
of
his
assets.
And
he
might
soon
be

doing
it

pro
se
,
at
least
in
New
York
where
he
faces
a
collection
action
on
the
$148
million
defamation
judgment
he
owes
to
former
Georgia
poll
workers
Ruby
Freeman
and
Shaye
Moss.
Giuliani
has
already
endeared
himself
to
Judge
Lewis
Liman
by
failing
to
respond
to
court
ordered
discovery,
stripping
his
Manhattan
apartment
of
its
contents
before
abandoning
it
to
the
plaintiffs,
and
arriving
at
an
election
party
in
the
Mercedes
he’d
been
explicitly
ordered
to
hand
over.

On
Wednesday,
Rudy’s
attorneys
Ken
Caruso
and
David
Labkowski

requested

permission
to
file
“two
sealed
ex
parte
documents”
to
protect
“confidential
information”
they
described
as
“ancillary”
to
the
court’s
judicial
authority.

Judge
Liman
promptly
rejected
the
request,
noting
the
presumption
of
public
access
to
court
documents. 

“Although
the
presumption
is
not
strong,
no
countervailing
factors
justify
the
sealing
of
information
regarding
the
identity
and
role
of
the
declarant,
the
relief
sought,
the
grounds
for
the
motion,
and
the
posture
of
the
matters
discussed,”
he

wrote
.
But
he
did
allow
for
a
partial
redaction
of
three
paragraphs
containing
privileged
information
in
Caruso’s
declaration.
(Although,
as
former
federal
prosecutor
Ken
White

notes
,
attorneys
have
an
obligation
to
protect
client
confidences,
even
in ex
parte

communications
with
the
court.)

In
any
event,
Caruso
and
Labkowski’s
plea
to
be
cut
loose
is
now
largely

visible

on
the
public
docket.
And,
hold
on
to
your
hats,
kids,
but
it
turns
out
Rudy
is
kind
of
a
terrible
client!

The
grounds
for
this
motion
arise
under
Professional
Rule
1.16(c)(4),
(6)
and
(7),
which
provide:

a
lawyer
may
withdraw
from
representing
a
client
when:
.
.
.
(4)
the
client
insists
upon
taking
action
with
which
the
lawyer
has
a
fundamental
disagreement;
.
.
.
(6)
the
client
insists
upon
presenting
a
claim
or
defense
that
is
not
warranted
under
existing
law
and
cannot
be
supported
by
good
faith
argument
for
an
extension,
modification,
or
reversal
of
existing
law;
[or]
.
.
.
(7)
the
client
fails
to
cooperate
in
the
representation
or
otherwise
renders
the
representation
unreasonably
difficult
for
the
lawyer
to
carry
out
employment
effectively[.]

You
mean
a
guy
who
got
himself
a
default
judgment
after
completely
failing
to
comply
with
discovery,
and
then
got
himself
kicked
out
of
bankruptcy
for
same,
and
is
currently
claiming
that
he

definitely

resides
in
Florida
for
the
purpose
of
the
homestead
exception,
unless
he
loses,
in
which
case
he definitely
resides
in
New
York


that
guy

wants
his
lawyers
to
do
something
that
isn’t
100
percent
on
the
up
and
up?
The
devil
you
say!

Judge
Liman
has
given
Rudy
until
Monday
to
respond.
And
just
in
case
the
former
head
of
SDNY
(late
of the
bar
,
although
not
of


a

bar
)
is
confused,
the
court
specifies
that
his
response
should
be
submitted
directly
to
chambers,
cc-ing
Caruso
and
Labkowski,
but
not
“any
other
party.”
A
hearing
on
the
matter
is
scheduled
for
November
26,
where
the
court
is
also
prepared
to
hear
from
Giuliani’s
girlfriend
Maria
Ryan
and
his
assistant
Ted
Goodman
as
to
why
they
failed
to
respond
to
subpoenas
served
back
in
August.

If
there’s
one
thing
that
could
make
this
situation
more
of
a
clusterfuck,
it
would
be
Rudy
representing
himself

pro
se
.
And,
PS,
Caruso
and
Labkowski
are
his
primary
counsel
on
the
appeal
of
the
underlying
judgment
to
the
DC
Circuit.

rudy-giuliani-wow


Freeman
v.
Giuliani
 [Docket
via
Court
Listener]





Liz
Dye
 lives
in
Baltimore
where
she
produces
the
Law
and
Chaos substack and podcast.